Stop ridiculing the mentally ill

He would handcuff and chain his patients and physically abuse them in order to treat them for substance addiction.

Hassan Majeed (MD) August 03, 2014
Individuals with mental health disorders are often the victims of violence and there is wide-spread discrimination directed towards them, whether by intent, ignorance or insensitivity. They are often the victim of jokes or are ridiculed for their behaviour. This attitude can make life difficult for them and present major obstacles to recovery. It is hard for them to find stable employment, living arrangements and relationships because of diminished self-esteem and weak social support.

I came across two instances recently of major discrimination against people with mental health disabilities in Pakistan. In the first instance, a TV host, on a recent Ramazan transmission program, presented the stereotype of a mentally ill patient and then beat him physically. He asked someone from the audience to act like an insane person and encouraged him to rip apart his shirt to make the act look more realistic. He then had the guy throw himself on the floor, at which point the host began punching and kicking him and chocked his neck with both hands. With an obnoxious smile on his face, he started yelling,
“Mentally ill are beaten physically.”

To this, the crowd started cheering for the much-admired host. It was one of the most disturbing sights I have ever witnessed on a television show as the anchor was cultivating hate and prejudice against the mentally ill and promoting physical violence against them.

In a separate event in Haripur, only 70 kilometres away from the capital, a so-called spiritual healer had chained people with substance addiction at his treatment centre and had been physically and mentally abusing them for years. Family members had left relatives with addiction problems at his asylum where they were handcuffed and put in shackles without any medical or psychological help. Revealing his treatment regime, the self-proclaimed healer stated,
“I recite the Holy Quran, then blow on water and give this water for drinking three times a day.”

The century old ‘cold turkey’ treatment has not had much value in treating addiction in current day psychiatric practice. It can be extremely dangerous and people with alcohol and sleeping pill addiction might die if withdrawal symptoms from drugs are not treated carefully in a medical setting. The image of chained addicts, sitting on a dirty floor in this so called rehabilitation centre was heart-wrenching. Personal stories about their treatment are very disturbing.

One patient stated that he lost his vision to the infection as he did not have any access to medical treatment while many others complained that they were treated as animals.

Incidents like these draw significant negative attention to mental health issues and hinder the treatment and recovery of those who are suffering from these illnesses. As a psychiatrist and mental health advocate, I am very disturbed by the biased coverage and inhumane treatment of people with mental health issues.  They are marginalised and often fall victim to the society’s hostile attitude, the scarcity of mental health institutions, lack of education, poverty and religious extremism. In addition, the stigma of mental illness in a society can bring shame to the patient’s family.

There is a dire need to raise awareness of the rights of the mentally ill and help them obtain appropriate treatment for their illness so that they can contribute positively to society. The most immediate need is to educate the public about mental health issues so that the affected people can seek help without any fear and with an expectation the burden of their disease will be lifted. I challenge the viewers of such programs to demand accurate information and become advocates for a healthier society.
Hassan Majeed (MD) The author is working as a child and adolescent psychiatry fellow at Long Island Jewish Medical Center, NY. He is a marathon runner and his interests include art, culture, travel, gender, human rights, mental health, and education. He tweets @HassanMajeedMD (
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Hassan | 9 years ago | Reply Aamir Liaqat Ali show.
yoyo | 9 years ago No surprises there, don't take aamir liaqat so seriously. I'm short of words to describe him
maida | 9 years ago | Reply very nicely explained.its such a shame that Pakistans illiterate masses believe in torturing the already tortured souls! i know which show you are talking about, i wonder if anybody can put an end to that show and the stupid antics of the host. salams,
Mir | 9 years ago Keyword: Illiterate. It's such a shame rich Pakistanis who live off the sweat of the masses have the idiocy to think that making a man live in poverty and crime all his life will make him a civilized and domesticated person. No wonder this country is falling apart.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ