Why do the Karachiite-type men fall for Punjabi women?

For all the Karachi men who fall for Punjabi women, make sure you know how to handle the fire before you get burnt!

Farahnaz Moazzam August 27, 2013
I begin with the disclaimer that this blog is not for three kinds of people:

1. Those who have an issue with the sweeping generalisations I am about to make in the spirit of fun, though parts will be definitely based on truth and years of research-based observation.

2. Ladies who are non-Punjabi and take the title as a jibe against themselves, and say to themselves “what does she mean? Don’t men like non-Punjabi women? She doesn’t know what she’s talking about! I know my husband would never be able to do with a Punjabi woman... they’re so loud!”

3. Punjabi women who, well, have ended up with the “non-Karachiite-type” thaith (pure), purely Punjoo men.

Ok so, it just me or do you see it all around you? Out of the inter-provincial, inter-cultural marriages, engagements and other stuff, as a Karachiite I have always seen non-Punjabi men falling for Punjabi women. I, on purpose, used the term “Karachiite-type” men, but to be more specific, we can use the term “Urdu-Speaking” men. So why do Urdu-speaking men keep falling for Punjabi women? Especially considering the fact that many stereo-typical terms are associated with Punjabi women: Loud, tacky, dominating, laraaki (ready to fight), big in size and again, loud.

We seem to forget, generally, the beautiful, slender, groomed and talented Punjabi girls who are quite the norm. It seems like the image that comes to our mind when we say “Punjabi girl” is a large-sized female in a colourful laacha, helping irrigate Pakistan’s agricultural lands by jumping in the fields trying to entertain a disinterested man, or eating a huge paratha dripping with ghee and yelling loud enough to make her lungs fall off on GT Road, screaming,
“Mere naal bakwaas na keeta kar naeen te tera bootha tor diyaan gee”.

(“Don’t talk rubbish with me or I’ll break your face!”)

And yes, she is pretty, even though she is all of the above.

Yet, day after day, the civil, tameezdaar (well-mannered) and wonderfully peace-loving Karachiite (or Urdu-speaking) men fall in love with Punjabi women; and it’s not just them, the other provinces have joined in too, Sindhis, Balochs and Pathans.

The question remains “why”?

A few probable answers I discovered, after careful observation and asking around, are these:

1. Need a change:
“All my life”, said a friend when he was choosing a girl to marry at the ripe old age of 23, “I have seen my mom, sisters, cousins, aunts – so proper. They don’t laugh too loud. They talk in aap janaab. They wear light blues, pastel pinks and beige, and I am like that too, the subtle aap janaab type. So somehow, the idea of a colourful lady in red appeals to me. Who laughs to her heart’s desire and speaks her mind. You know, the phuljharee-type (firecracker-type).”

Phuljharee-type?” I asked him to confirm I had heard correctly.

“Yes yes. the phuljharee, titlee type (the firecracker, butterfly type). For a change you know,” he affirmed.

That’s when I somehow understood it. The firecracker butterfly fun brand actually works for a lot of men. That does not mean other provinces and ethnicities are bereft of phuljharees but maybe it is inbuilt genetic selection that men seem to like the “made in Punjab” variety increasingly.

2. The “khulla dulla ishtyle” (Open-style)
“At least with a Punjabi girl, you don’t spend your life wondering what’s under the cool demeanour,” said another anonymous friend. (And yes, it is best that my informants stay unnamed, lest they face consequences at the hands of the non-Punjoo women in their lives!).

“She is who she is. Ghussay mein ho ya khush, kam az kam pata to chal jaata hai. (If she’s angry or happy, at least we can tell.) You know how we men are, yaar. We are bad mind-readers and women expect us to be just that. At least this way, you know that it is what it is, in your face. Jo hay wo hay (It is what it is). At least she’ll say it and not keep it in her heart for the next decade,” he said.

And that’s one general impression about Punjabis that yes, under the umbrella term “Punjabi” come people who are not afraid to be who they are; plus, they are less formal and more casual. Less takallufaat and formalities, and more of Lath Maar (kicking) stuff.

3. They are lookers:
“For guys, it’s all about looks and Punjabi girls are mostly good looking. For me that is the single most important factor. As it is, I like her to be not stick thin,” said another informant.

Need I say more?

4. They have a lot of fire:

With the package of the whole loud, khulla dulla ishtyle, comes a genuine spirited fieriness; being passionate, being feisty, humorous, hulla gulla (full of life) and fun.
“I’m telling you, the ‘wujood e zann se hai tasweer e kainaat mein rang’ wala shair (in the picture of the universe all the colours are from the female gender)  was written for Punjoo girls,” said one know-it-all, in his second year of a happy engagement with a Punjabi girl, while he himself has ancestors from Lucknow.

My two cents to my friend were: Make sure you know how to handle the fire, before you get scalded.

5. They are such foodies:

And men like food. So in a Punjabi girl, they dream of someone who will be able to share his excitement for puri bhaaji, nihari, gola kabab, kharay masalay ka qeema and biryani. She will also bring into his life the joys of aloo kay parathay, murgh cholay, sarson ka saag and makkai ki roti, and Punjabi pulao. She will understand the cliché that the way to his heart is through his tummy, simply because hey, the way to her heart is also through her tummy.

To each his own. Whatever ethnicity works for you, go for it and rather than the ethnicity, whatever “package deal” works for you, go for it.

This post originally appeared here.
Farahnaz Zahidi


The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Sohail Awan | 9 years ago | Reply @excalibur: If we are talking about the literacy rate than based on the government of Pakistan's results it is 57%, and out of that 57% Punjab have the highest (27.70%) and Sindh (do not ignore the Sindhi people in this percentage as the huge number of URDU speaking lives in this province) have the same which means you are again wrong here as well. I thing this maths will be enough to take you out from your small box of your own world. And now I will not be wrong to justify that the minority (only almost 8% of Pakistan's population) does not stand in this stance. well, my point was to clear the picture where many of the so called URDU speaking have in their mind that they belongs to somewhat out of the blue and Punjabi's are having the Jooti ki Nook wali mentality. And please do read the blog again as it written clearly in that the URDU speaking boys go after the Punjabi girls. And for your information punjabi's are still speaking Punjabi language in their homes even though if you go to America and England you will find it in every single Punjabi's home. As they do prefer their own native mother language in their homes. @S A Hussain: Yes, no doubt that we all love to have the Mughlai food like Chicken Karhai, Nihari, Samosa's etc. but you missed my point that every culture have their own personal speciality of food.
Insaan | 9 years ago | Reply @sterry: Frankly I don’t want my children to marry Indians- Hence I don’t wish to live in India. I hope this clarifies this for you now. Do you mean you don't want your kids to marry Indian Muslims? I wonder why? Pakistanis even don't want their kids to marry other non-related Pakistanis, I guess due to lack of trust in non-related Pakistanis. I have noticed even some Pakistanis and Afghans living in US marry their kids to close relatives.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ