Veteran politician Makhdoom Javed Hashmi on Thursday faced a historic by-election defeat as he conceded his traditional National Assembly seat (NA-149) to an independent candidate supported by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI). The rout was all the more telling as it came despite support of many religious and political parties, including the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N).
Hashmi had relinquished the seat after he left the PTI following his disagreement with party chief Imran Khan.
Amir Dogar, the PTI-backed candidate, won with a comfortable margin of 14,000 votes, polling 52,321 votes against Hashmi’s 38,393 votes, according to the official results, announced by the regional election commission. In a distant third place came Javed Siddiqi of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) who secured 6,289 votes.
Returning Officer Muhammad Shahid told media that the “official pamphlet [regarding the election result] will be issued on Friday (today).”
In the run-up to the 2013 election, the NA-149 seat in Multan was considered a hub of the PML-N and the political bastion of Javed Hashmi, who has an impressive record in the constituency.
Last year, Amir Dogar had contested the same National Assembly seat against Javed Hashmi and was at the receiving end of a bruising loss. Dogar secured only 20,719 votes against Hashmi’s 83,640 votes.
Polling opened at the appointed hour, ie, 8:00am and continued more or less smoothly till 5:00pm. Some 286 polling stations were established for almost 350,000 voters. Voter turnout was only 29% as compared to the 2013 elections in which the turnout was estimated at 61%.
Talking to The Express Tribune after the announcement of result, Javed Hashmi said he had accepted the result. “Now I will go abroad for medical treatment. I am not rejected by the people but by the corrupt political parties of Pakistan. I will continue my struggle for the people of Pakistan,” he said.
Shah Mehmood Qureshi, the PTI’s vice chairman, interpreted the by-poll result as a game changer in the politics of Multan, forecasting that it would give rise to a tsunami alert in Pakistan.
“Everyone is aware that all religious and political parties of Pakistan had supported Javed Hashmi against the PTI-backed candidate, but they failed in getting him elected,” he said.
Qureshi said people wanted change and they had given a verdict while the Rs3 billion spent by Punjab CM Shahbaz Sharif for Hashmi’s victory were squandered before the power of the people of Pakistan. During the by-poll ECP strictly followed the rules and removed the banners and camps of the contestants at 23 locations.
Despite monitoring of election commission authorities, Multan’s district administration was accused of facilitating Hashmi and vehicles bringing voters for Hashmi were found in Multan’s Circuit House.
DCO Multan Zahid Saleem, however, refuted the allegations and said they had maintained merit and transparency. “No official of the district government has interfered in the by-elections,” he added.
The PML-N’s women polling agents in government girls’ high schools were also accused of forcing female voters to vote for Hashmi. The PML-N lawmaker Sultana Shaheen brushed aside the allegations though. In some parts, the PML-N’s polling agents also pulled down polling camps of the PTI-backed Amir Dogar.
The PML-N’s district president Bilal Butt also alleged that presiding officers in some polling stations stamped for the PTI-backed candidate.
Four companies of Rangers were deputed during the election today whereas 3,400 police personnel were on duty. There were 90 polling stations, which were declared sensitive.
The voting pattern at NA-149 remained similar to that of the 2013 elections as the winning margin continued to be more or less the same. Last time, the two top contestants had respectively got 83,000 and 73,000 votes and the PTI had won with a margin of 10,000 votes.
The PTI has managed just to retain this small margin despite having a strong PPP-renegade candidate, its own strong political campaign and ‘the huge’ recent rally.
Special ink used in by-poll
The ECP has claimed that it has used a special ink in NA-149 Multan by-polls for thumbprint impressions on the ballot’s counterfoils. The ECP officials said the ink is different from the magnetic ink used in the 2013 general elections. They claimed that the new ink would make it possible to verify every ballot cast in the polls.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 17th, 2014.
COMMENTS (31)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@salman:
Great kick in the ....... to @Thought of the day
@Thought of the day: PTI have always said they are willing to recount any seat they won. It is PMLN who are refusing to do this. But I support any dharna that is to improve transparency. Let me know where you are going to do dharna....I will arrange for food for you. Best of luck!
@salman: But it was a rigged election by the PTI! I am doing a dhrna until there is a recount
@muhammad aqeel hayder: Er...Hashmi himself said PMLN arranged 4000 corner meetings for him. PMLN were hiring airplanes are dropping leaflets to support Hashmi. Hamza Shahbaz himself said in a PMLN parliamentary board meeting that they will support Hashmi. PMLN did not even put up their own candidate. What other support do you want?
The only thing PMLN didn't do is rig the elections for Hashmi....but they probably thought about it!
no doubt javed hashmi is a great leader. he is the "symbol of Democracy in Pakistan. but he made wrong decision of election participation. PML(N) did not supported hashmi as PTI supported ammir dogar. besides this NA149 is always anti government. the canidate is supported by the government always is defeated.
The Promise of Naya Pakistan is materializing, Imran, May your dream and vision of Pakistan be a reality someday.
"I am not rejected by the people.."
Er, no...you have been rejected by the majority of people.
I would have thought that a self proclaimed champion of democracy would at least know how elections work. Sad end for a sad man...
GO NAWAZ GO has proved in letter and spirit. Iqbal Hadi Zaidi
Let JUSTICE prevail... .... and it has.
Hashmi a senior leader, though a politician, could not realized this fact that the results may be wrong because selfish people are hopping removal of Nawaz Shariff may bring properity in their life, iron is hot and ignorant people are greedy. Those senior politicians with Imran Khan are also wishing PMship. But as a matter of fact even Imran Khan does not know how and what he will change corrupt people to nice one. This supporting public will go against Imran Khan also whenrealities of life will come on the surface. Misfortune is looming over this nation...
@GS@Y
A margin of 30% is not "fairly narrow" especially considering JH comfortably won against the same in 2013. The difference? PTI support.
@Ch. Allah Daad Let the PML-N do his positive role in parliament what this party is playing for last 1.7 years. And Let the PTI & PAT outside the parliament for POLITICAL SLAP on STATUS QUO for the good of masses. By the way can PML-N do positive things by themselves or they have any reform plans for THANA, JUDICIARY, ECONOMY or they always need TEACHERS like IK & QADRI who will teach them lesson through PUBLIC PRESSURE.
Nobody likes backstabbers.
PML-N by making stupid mistakes like protecting gullu butt and not punishing Model Town killers and promoting VIP culture is gradually losing respect.
Winds of Change
""The PML-N’s district president Bilal Butt also alleged that presiding officers in some polling stations stamped for the PTI-backed candidate.""
PML-N should go for dharna in Multan!
Must be an embarrassing moment for Hashmi sahab after all the big talk. This clearly indicates the massive rigging that took place in 2013. "Go Nawaz Go" !!!
Truth always comes out, doesn't it?
Javed Hashmi lost but with honor. The margin of defeat was fairly narrow and the turnout in NA-149 was quite low. There was no resounding rejection by Multanis that the PTI trolls had hoped for. Good luck to JH for next time around.
Mr. Hashmi, where did you get the money for medical treatment abroad? Was the deal with Nawaz and Shabaz? That they will pay the bills, once you win. Unfortunately things are different now. They will not pay the bills. You also double crossed the citizens,..no triple crossed. Nobody will ever be sure about your loyalties. Or who you represent. A pariah in the making.
Hashmi should seek a doctors advice in getting back his health and mental balance. An trip to a sanatorium should help.
If only the ECP had followed all these rules and regulations in the May 2013 elections rather than just this by-election, things might have been different.
A personal victory for SMQ the Pir, feudal and lifetime professional political lota. Some say that after being foreign minster he and establishment are eying him as future PM. Even though some accused IK being the establishment man but the actual man is SMQ who was brought out of PPP to future role. IK would remain lifelong Chairman of his own party but not the PM.
Baghi to Dhagi to Bhagi ... is how I sum up the arrogance and stupidity of the rightly defeated 'politician' who was backed by Noora league as well as Bilawal league and all of the Fazlu type outfits out there ... He is finished and he knows it, he just went too far thinking he is bigger than the cause of PTI. Lessons for others in the Naya Pakistan.
“Now I will go abroad for medical treatment." and live abroad happily ever after!!
This is it for Mr. Hashmi and PMLN.
Ohoo.. Hashmi sb.. what now - Baghiness all the way?
The Insafians celebrating should really reflect... Dogar won without any change in reform or any change in the way the elections were conducted in 2013... and now the insafians are celebrating that the candidate their party supported won and they in a way retained NA 149 This should also mean the elections of 20 despite a few irregularities were largely free and fair And enough of this dharna nonsense and let the country return back to normal...
It will be extremely wrong to continue as by supporting a candidate PTI has proved it is part of the system... And whether they like it or not election results are valid whether they win or not
Javed Hashmi humiliated by IK. Go Nawaz go.