Invisible Pakistanis: Denied the right to identity

Published: August 19, 2013

A worker of the National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) checks newly printed government identity cards of registered citizens at the NADRA head office in Islamabad November 14, 2012. PHOTO: FILE

KARACHI: 

Imran*, 23, was recently refuse a secretarial job at a private firm in Karachi. The reason: he failed to provide his NIC.

And yet, for this, Imran cannot be blamed. Born out of wedlock, he has no idea about the identity or whereabouts of his father and, hence, has been turned away twice while applying for an identity card.

His mother Nigar*, a former female sex worker who managed to enroll Imran in a public school with the help of her employers, can see hopes for a better life for her son slowly diminishing.

“I walked through fire to get Imran through matriculation, to make sure he wouldn’t end up like me,” she states quietly. “But, in this society, there seems to be no support for people like us.”

All around us

Stories like Imran’s are not unique.

There are nearly 180 million Pakistanis, but only half of them exist as legally recognized citizens  — ie, possess a national identity card (NIC) that confirms their identity as legal citizens of Pakistan and entitles them to basic rights, such as equality of status, access to economic and political justice and freedom of expression, belief and worship. With a rapidly burgeoning population, these innumerable identity-less Pakistanis have faded silently into the background.

Without an NIC, these individuals are unable to enroll in schools and colleges, obtain a driver’s licence or passport, register a vehicle, open a bank account, pay taxes, get a utility connection, file for legal procedures or vote. Furthermore, along with the day-to-day struggles, there is no legal cover in matters of financial entitlement or inheritance.

Who’s lurking in the shadows?

The vast group of invisible Pakistan comprises two kinds of people.

Firstly, there are those who voluntarily choose not to apply for an identity card due to ignorance, illiteracy, unawareness and financial constraints, mainly in rural areas and lower income classes.

Secondly, there are those who cannot apply for an identity card due to legal complications, such as failure to produce a birth certificate, parents’ identity cards or other paperwork. This category consists mainly of second and third generation immigrants – Bengalis, Biharis, Afghans – and children of unknown parentage.

Until recently, this category also included the transgender community. Now, however, they have been allowed by the Supreme Court to register as a third gender on computerized identity cards.

Of fathers and names

Countless children of unknown parentage, who are raised by single mothers, abandoned on the streets or living in orphanages, encounter similar problems once they reach the age of 18.

“By depriving these children of basic rights such as an identity, you are pushing them to the fringes of society,” emphasises Tahera Hassan, a Karachi-based lawyer. “It is time someone takes notice and proposes a change in the law.”

Hassan says she wrote a letter to the Supreme Court on behalf of the Edhi Foundation two years ago, requesting the Chief Justice to take notice of the fact that NADRA was not issuing B-forms or registering children of unknown parentage. In the letter, she also proposed recommendations, including observation of practices of other Muslim countries like Morocco, where such children are put under the lineage of a fictitious father.

The top court had sought the opinion of the Council of Islamic Ideology and senior judges like Justice (Retd) Khalil-ur-Rehman Ramday on the matter but concrete changes have not been made just yet.

In 2011, President Zardari also volunteered for his name to be used by NADRA as the father for all children with unknown parentage. However, after consultation with various schools of thought from different Islamic countries and prominent humanitarians in Pakistan, it was decided to process each case individually and use the institution where these children were living as guardian for the time being.

“Our courts are inundated with problems of all kinds,” states Hassan quietly. “It is extremely difficult to prioritise and address issues like these.”

Published in The Express Tribune, August 19th, 2013.

Reader Comments (3)

  • kumail
    Aug 19, 2013 - 9:52AM

    A blatant violation of UN UNIVERSAL DECLARATION OF HUMAN RIGHTS –
    Article 25 (2) Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. All children, whether born in or out of wedlock, shall enjoy the same social protection.

    Pakistan is also a signatory of this declaration.

    Recommend

  • Sohaib Minhas
    Aug 19, 2013 - 10:25AM

    this is a very important issue that can not be over looked, as the individual is deprived of the CNIC and can not work for a legally identified institutions there are chances that he/she might start earning money through illegal sources, the govt. should at least introduce a similar card(if not permitting them to obtain the original CNIC) which shows the information available, this would at least get the finger prints and other available information about the individuals into the database which i believe is very important, every individuals data should be maintained by the govt to deal with various issues that arise in terms of security and criminal activities, and give them a chance or access to other essentials of life to live a respectable and comfortable life.

    Recommend

  • Aug 19, 2013 - 8:41PM

    Imran better hire an Afghan Refugee for obtaining Pakistan,s CNIC. The Afghan Refugees know the tricks of getting CNIC from NADRA,Recommend

More in Pakistan