We were ‘outraged’, because just weeks earlier, over eighty — we’ll never know the exact number — of these same poor folk, including women and old men and children, were massacred in the Alamdaar Road area of Quetta in another blast, this time caused by around a similar amount of explosives.
We were so ‘outraged’ that there were protest demonstrations, according to a major English newspaper of the country: “from Karachi to Parachinar, and Hyderabad to Multan, Rawalpindi and Islamabad”. I only went to the dharna at the Governor’s House in Lahore on Tuesday, February 19, where the extent of the Lahoris’ ‘outrage’ was a gathering of at most 3,000 protesters; oh all right, 4,000, mostly Shia. And this, just a day after another atrocity against our Shia brethren in Lahore: the point-blank shooting of eminent eye surgeon, and from all accounts, great human being, Dr Ali Hyder and his 12-year old son, Ali Murtaza (RIP). Shame on us.
Such then, is the extent of our ‘outrage’ my friends, a city of close to 10 million people producing just this many protesters to show their disgust at what is being methodically done to a peaceable section of our society, several of whose number have also defended this country with their sterling services, to name just three: General Mohammad Musa, the country’s second army Commander-in-Chief and later Governor of Balochistan; Air Vice Marshal Sharbat Ali Changezi; and Flight Lieutenant Samad Ali Changezi who was shot down and killed in the 1971 war, receiving the Sitara-e-Jurat for valour.
Last but not least, let us recall that another Hazara, Flight Lieutenant Saira Batool who is one of the few women fighter pilots in the PAF, not to forget the many other Hazara who served in our armed forces and gave their lives defending their country.
And yet, the braves of the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (LeJ), the Jaishul Islam, and the flavour of the month, the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, stalk about killing Shia sons and daughters of Pakistan from Balochistan to Kaghan to Kohistan, wantonly and cruelly, to fulfil God alone knows what bloodlust. Shame on them; and double shame on their friends, the movers and the shakers of the Deep State. Durr fittay muun, I say to them.
These Yahoos, and I use the term advisedly: a mythical mixed race (Gulliver’s Travels) of man and beast with the qualities of neither but the cruelty and beastliness and plain nastiness of both, openly boast that they are the killers of, respectively, the Hazara Shia of Quetta; the Mastung Hazara pilgrims; and the Shia workers travelling home to Skardu and Gilgit through Kaghan and Chilas. And yet, nothing moves even a leaf in the fancy gardens of our government houses, civilian and army.
Isn’t it time that we, all of us Pakistanis, once and for all, removed these killers from our midst by prosecuting them and locking them up in prisons and throwing away the keys? But no, no political leader (barring Imran Khan, about whom later) will name and shame these terrorists, preferring to use mealy-mouthed terms such as ‘these terrorists’; ‘they can’t be Muslims’; ‘they are CIA agents’; ‘they are RAW agents’; ‘they are agents of foreign powers out to destabilise Pakistan’ and other such nonsense.
They purposely fail to recall that the world at large is scared stiff of a further destabilised (a job we have ourselves done quite well thank you very much) Pakistan, with a possible consequence of our bums or nuclear material falling into jihadi hands. The politicians say what they say knowing full well the reality of the situation: that the beast is within us, and openly and loudly says it is within us.
As to Imran Khan, whilst on the one hand he is to be lauded for naming the LeJ as the killers, on the other he must be castigated for once again advocating talks with the terrorists who commit such brazen acts against this country and its people. One has to say that the Honourable Supreme Court is the only institution to have said clearly that if the LeJ are the perpetrators, let them be arrested and brought before the courts.
I must in passing also appreciate my (junior!) school-mate Khawaja Asif for saying it as it is and not mincing his words like his other colleagues when he freely admitted that the tyrant Zia was the fountainhead of all the filth that we see around us, and that the so-called ‘jihad’ this country has waged is nothing but a massive fraud.
But may we now, after damning us ‘bloody civilians’ doubly and more, ask why and how these killers did what they did, in the environs of a most heavily guarded army cantonment that houses not only the Command and Staff College, but also the Infantry School, the EME Regimental Centre, AND a Corps Headquarters too?
It is said that a sparrow cannot fly without a flight plan issued by the Mother of All Agencies when it wants sparrows to stop flying. How then, did so many hundreds of kilogrammes of high energy explosives find its way into Hazara Colony and Wahdat Road twice, in as many months? Will the DG ISI stand up before the nation and answer how, and more importantly, WHY, the killings happened?
The ISI’s simply saying it had told the government that the Alamdaar Road atrocity would be repeated is simply not enough. Even I can warn (and dust in my mouth) that there will be another attack on the Shia within a month. So?
In the end, a big thank you to the Australians for accepting 2,500 Hazara families as refugees. God bless your country. And shame on ours for not protecting its own.
Published in The Express Tribune, February 22nd, 2013.
COMMENTS (58)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
. @Lala Gee : . Looks like you got so excited with your new found knowledge, courtesy “uncle google”, that you totally lost what I said in my comments. Please read my comments again and see what are you saying. I never claimed that Changez Khan was Muslim, or the title ‘Khan’ belonged to Muslims. Only one of his 4 Sons, Chagatai Khan, and a grandson, Teqdur Ahmad (son of Hulagu Khan, and king of Persia), accepted Islam, while the rest of Changiz Khan’s immediate family remained Buddhist. . Gee Whiz : You mean that many Pakistani Muslims have a Buddhist Name! . BTW: I never stated that Changez Khan was a Muslim. I stated my “Doubt” as well as stated that Khan – a Name used by many Muslims – is not a Muslim Name and as such it is a wonder that so many Muslims have the name Changez as also Khan. . Cheers
@Naresh:
Looks like you got so excited with your new found knowledge, courtesy "uncle google", that you totally lost what I said in my comments. Please read my comments again and see what are you saying. I never claimed that Changez Khan was Muslim, or the title 'Khan' belonged to Muslims. Only one of his 4 Sons, Chagatai Khan, and a grandson, Teqdur Ahmad (son of Hulagu Khan, and king of Persia), accepted Islam, while the rest of Changiz Khan's immediate family remained Buddhist.
I deem you the voice of the voiceless.A well written piece of writing, Mr. Kamran.
@Lala Gee : . Please take the help of Unnle Google and you will find that one of Genghis Khan's Grand or Great Grand Son was the Second or Third Dalai Lama. . In addition "After the husband of Genghis Khan's daughter was killed at Nishapur - IRAN - in 1221, she ordered the death of all in the city (~1.7 million), and the skulls of men, women, and children were piled in pyramids by the Mongols. ". As such I doubt if Genghis Khan was a Muslim. . Now to the name KHAN being a Muslim Name. "KHAN" is a Mongolian Name - most probably - before the Advent of Islam in Mongolia or for that matter even vast areas of Central Asia. Here is the Link to Mongolian Names : . http://heraldry.sca.org/laurel/names/mongoliannamesmarta.html . Mongolian Naming Practices . khan/kha: king
. Cheers
@Zalmai: @Z.Khan:
I am the reference! This is a pandora box and can only be clarified with the DNA check. No country other than Iceland has undertaken the study. Every one has his own story based on the background and perception as well as the circumstances and the period in history. The term 'Hindu' was given to the people by the Afghans, whereas the term 'Indian' is a standard term which the anglo saxons give to the natives. In the beginning most were nameless and later name calling started with their professions followed by the second name of the father and later by the family name and so on. Some of the nameless started taking on the names of precious stones, others of animals and many went for noble names and finaly the names got plagiarized and imposters took over. This necessitated the control on names.
Rex Minor
@Zalmai: "Millions of people in Pakistan and India call themselves Khan because with conversion to Islam they felt they had to take on Muslim names or names associated with Muslims. They were insecure in being called Raj Kumar,"
As of principle a muslim can have any name (first name; not the cast) from any culture,language race provided that particular name doesn't deny the unity of God.In Pakistan majority of people doesn't hide its family or cast name.However some of the people, for whatever reasons you may say,adopt some titels (not name) as khan ,chaudhary ,shah, sahibzada ,pirzada,etc.There is a general misunerstadning among punjabis that every pathan or afghan is khan which is not true.Let me say it again Khan is not a name but a titel and that has nothing to do with ones lineage.It is always the family name which tells the roots. For example-Imran Khan Niazi-Last name shows Imran's roots.My point is some people tend to adopt titels to show some kind of distinction as from strong family back ground but not to hide their origin.
@gp65:
"Why do you think RAW cares whether Pakistanis acknolwedge their Indian lineage or not"
Perhaps you could shed light what RAW cares about then??? As per wikipedia entry on RAW, "The primary mission of R&AW includes aggressive intelligence collection via espionage, psychological warfare, subversion and sabotage."
@Zalmai:
"They were insecure in being called Raj Kumar, Ajay Kapoor or Sanjay Malhotra and still profess to be Muslim"
I am sure you are not feeling well today, otherwise I have never seen, or heard of, an Afghan Muslim calling himself Raj Kumar, or Sanjay Malhotra, or Dalai Lama, Ranjeet Singh either - or any Muslim of any other nationality, for that matter. Is that also in your history that Afghans were always Muslims - else why would they have Arabic/Persian Muslim names - and not the Buddhists or Hindus earlier.
Perhaps over 99% of names of Muslims from all the nationalities of the world have some common phonetics enabling instant recognition and their association with Islam. This is also the case with Hindus, Sikhs, Jews, and Christians as well. A Hindu born in Europe or America still keeps at-least a part of his name that will associate him with his Hindu roots. Same is the case with the Christians of India who also adopt Christian names after conversion. Were they also insecure during the British Raj? Or, they have stopped changing their Hindu names after conversion to Christianity? What about the Christians living in Arab countries. Do they keep Arab Muslim names? No, their names sound more like European names than Arab Muslim names.
What kind of insecurity Muslims could have when in fact they were the rulers in India and elsewhere? Or, you think the Pakistani Muslims have started using Arab/Persian Muslim names only after the creation of Pakistan?
@Rex Minor: This is interesting. Any referecne to DNA check and academic evaluation?
@Lala Gee:
But, Changez Khan himself was a shamanic worshiper. And by that logic, Pakistanis should be actually naming themselves Vishnu, Shiva, Pashupathi, Shankara etc.!
@Zalmai:
The DNA check in Iceland has reveated that two to three families are the lineage of the whole population. My educated guess is that not more than seven families lineage is continuing in India. Only one of the seven is from the Budhist/hindu origin, whereas the remaing are from changez khan and Arab origin.
Nothing personal just an academic evaluation.
Rex Minor
@Usman: Thanks but no thanks. Pakistan studies as a source of history is not what I want to base my history knowledge on.
@Lala Gee: "Anyway, and where did you get that 140 million Pakistanis refuse to own their lineage? Are you smoking something fancy recently or got a handsomely paid job in some RAW propaganda cell.? "
Why do you think RAW cares whether Pakistanis acknolwedge their Indian lineage or not?
@Zalmai:
"Afghans don’t hide their real lineage Pakistanis do. Out of the 180 million Pakistanis 140 million of them are Indian but they refuse to own up to this."
Well you didn't answer my question where did the word 'Khan' come from? Anyway, and where did you get that 140 million Pakistanis refuse to own their lineage? Are you smoking something fancy recently or got a handsomely paid job in some RAW propaganda cell.?
@Lala Gee
Millions of people in Pakistan and India call themselves Khan because with conversion to Islam they felt they had to take on Muslim names or names associated with Muslims. They were insecure in being called Raj Kumar, Ajay Kapoor or Sanjay Malhotra and still profess to be Muslim so they shed everything associated with their former past and adopted practices that has nothing to do with their race, identity, language or culture.
On the other hand, Indonesia is a Muslim state, which has made no attempts to erase its Hindu past and chose to hold on to their indigenous identity while adopting a new faith, which is my point here. Megawati Sukarnoputri and many other Indonesians did not feel the need to take on Arabic names just because they are Muslim. But Pakistanis will keep spinning yarn and claim heritage from everywhere but home.
@Lala Gee
Afghans don't hide their real lineage Pakistanis do. Out of the 180 million Pakistanis 140 million of them are Indian but they refuse to own up to this.
@Zalmai:
I don't want to go into lengthy discussion on this topic as this is not the real issue here, but would like to know what your history tells you about the word 'Khan'. Where did it come from? Further, in 180 million population of Pakistan, there are hundreds of castes like Rajput, Jat, Gujjar, Arain, Memon, Sheikh, Khan, Mirza, Mughal, Chugtai, Siddiqui, Syed and what not, and then their sub-castes, some coming from the Indian sub-continent and the others coming from Iran, Afghanistan, Arabs and perhaps rest of the world. It is an individual's choice if he want to deceive the others by hiding his real lineage, like the Afghans do, as you mentioned in your comment.
@Inshallah: People like you are just destined to remain burning in the feelings you have. I feel sorry for you
grt article.
@Lala Gee
"@Zalmai:
“Only in Pakistan people name themselves Changezi, it is like a European naming his son Hitler.”
If you know history, then you would have known that the Changez Khan’s (Genghis Khan) descendants accepted Islam, and the Chugtai and Mughal lineage goes back to him. If Mughal or Chugtai in a name is not the cause of embarrassment, then whats so wrong in calling yourself Changezi. I don’t think you can do much about which family you are born in. By the way, author’s own son’s name is Changez Shafi, if I am not wrong."
Are you trying to tell me that Pakistanis are descendants of Changez Khan or descended from Mughal lineage. No self respecting Hazara in Afghanistan will take on the name Changez as a surname. Just because Hazaras, Uzbeks and other Central Asians have Mongol features does not mean they are descended from Changez Khan. The fact that Changez's descendants adopted Islam does not make them more appealing or genetically closer to a Muslim from the sub-continent.
Pakistanis' feel the need to identify and associate themselves with Afghans, Persians, Turks, Mongols, Arabs but not with who they are, Indian. Projecting has become an accepted norm by Pakistanis.
You will never meet Afghans named after Alexander of Macedonia, Gengiz Khan or Babur but you will meet thousands of people named after Ahmad Shah Abdali and Mirwais Hotak because these two personalities were Afghan leaders not foreign invaders, but that is because we have a history unlike Pakistan.
Who is supplying weapons and financing these terrorists? If the trail goes to our 'friendly' Muslim countries, then what do they gain by destabilizing Pakistan? Further research needs to go into this, and if their support is nipped, then that will finish these terrorist organizations and save more blood shed of our military.
@Zalmai: Obviously you have little knowledge of history, otherwise you won't make such an asinine comment. The Hazaras are direct descendents of the 1000 ('Hazar') Mongol troops Genghis Khan's army left behind in this region (after chasing the deposed ruler of the Khwarazm Empire, Jalaluddin, Shah up and down the Indus and then to Afghanistan around 1220 AD). As they all descend for the original Mongol lashkar left behind by 'Jangez' Khan they are perfectly entitled to call themselves Changezi.
It is the IB ( under ministry of interior ) who is reponsible for internal inteligence and counter terrorism than ISI.....and no finger is ever pointer at them...why ? Bcz bashing Army and its affiliates has become a Fashion now a days and IB being a civilian outfit with large secret fund is not held responsible bcz its funds are used by the govt for its own self vested interest making its working in- efficient.....STOP holding only ISI for all internal disturbances.....there are many other Intel dept who are equally responsible and should be held accountable too....
@Zalmai:
"Only in Pakistan people name themselves Changezi, it is like a European naming his son Hitler."
If you know history, then you would have known that the Changez Khan's (Genghis Khan) descendants accepted Islam, and the Chugtai and Mughal lineage goes back to him. If Mughal or Chugtai in a name is not the cause of embarrassment, then whats so wrong in calling yourself Changezi. I don't think you can do much about which family you are born in. By the way, author's own son's name is Changez Shafi, if I am not wrong.
You are simply Superb! Salute you for your excellent articles.
Thank you for saying it like it is.
@gp65: You need to read some history.
100 percent agree with you.
if we fail to recognize the dangers of hate today then the day is not far when our own relatives will be sitting in a Quetta with our dead bodies, protesting for justice. Your life, your country, Love or Hate , your choice. Stop Hate to stop Shia Killings, here is my take on it http://stopextremism.wordpress.com/2013/02/18/hate-is-the-reason-english/
The deep state can proudly add another hundred to the thousands and increasing by leaps and bounds and blame the number on the Americans as the losses the state has suffered because of 'their' war and extract billions for their own merrymaking. Don't know of any other precedence in world history by worst of tyrants, of fodder making of own citizens and use the dead as begging bowls.
When pakistan has pple like Zaid hamid types who threat everyone who is not on military payroll and spread his venom thru speeches and facebook to most youngsters who have no knowledge of other religion then what can we expect. Our Country name is Pakistan but what is Pak about it. Give me some examples..i am confused or disoriented.
Jai Ho, Shafisahab! You are doing a yeoman's job for your motherland. May your 'caravan' grow by day and change basic attitudes of its people.
While your condemnation of the atrocities against the Hazaras is commendable, I would rather hear your take on the recent pre-poll rigging by our esteemed elected representative Raja Pervaiz Ashraf. Also, your take on fake degree holders? Loan defaulters? The rightly called extremists that you blame the ISI for wouldn't last 2 weeks if a well educated population does not give them moral support. . Hence, your take on the PM redirecting FATA's development funds to his pet road project? Your take on the government wilfully keeping the public uneducated? One school > 100 soldiers for keeping peace. Or how about some commentary on the Punjab govt. not acting against LeJ in South Punjab?
You didn't defend the poor Ahmadies, who were declared non-Muslim (as if a decree is needed from anyone about being a Muslim), from persecution, destruction of property and murder. Now it's the Shia. The government should be ashamed of its inability to defend its citizens. On the other hand the government is a reflection of the people it governs, and it's hard to find a more bigoted, brain-washed and fanatically ungovernable nation.
People who are at the helm of "Deep State" are delusional idiots. They think that these vultures are their strategic assets. I say to them "Dur Fittay Mun" as well.
you have said what i always maintained: that Shia massacre, if it is not supported, then not resented much by large no. of pakistanis. I am not saying that majority supports this bombing, but if the current trend is any indication, in a couple of years(ie if i am living till then) i will have ample evidence to say that majority does support these killings.
@Zalmai: All you got out of the article is the name Changezi? Please wake and smell the coffee! Look at the big picture - Pakistan is burning and we as a nation are fast a sleep and happily burning with it.
@Kamran Shahib Well said. May you efforts not go in vain!
. Isn’t it time that we, all of us Pakistanis, once and for all, removed these killers from our midst by prosecuting them and locking them up in prisons and throwing away the keys? . Mahor Saab Ji : If wishes were Green Tamarind then thie above wish would cause you the Mother of All Sore Throats. . Cheers
Pakistan was, is and will remain a self-proclaimed JUNG-ZOO riasat of Pakistan army. Nothing will ever change. The state will stay at the borderlines of failing but will never fail. China, Saudia and USA together will neither let the state die peacefully nor stay alive healthy.
The killers have a different world-view. Their "state" is not defined by the geographical boundaries of Pakistan. Or an ideology, or culture, or ethnicity. Their "state" is defined by the extremist imaginary "Extreme Wahabbi-Tribal Nation" that follows their own rules and laws of an extreme form of medieval tribalism. For them anyone who donot share this world-view is fair game. There is no religion involved in this.
The sooner common Pakistanis and their Establishment realised this the better....
Good analysis of the sorry state of affairs in Pakistan! To gage just how bad the situation is, please compare the absolute outrage that swept Pakistan over THE MOVIE posted on YouTube (which almost no one in Pakistan ever saw), with various well known TV pundits and politicians trying to out scream each other over their love for the Prophet, to the muted response to this religious genocide of minorities! The only constant for any of these horrendous attacks is that reference to the ever popular "Foreign Hand" by the usual suspects almost always creeps in!
Kamran Shafi, Excellant article once again-Kudos for your jihad against fake jihadis and their sympathysers. In coming future there is going to be more chaos more killings and eventually kind of civil war in this country.Terrorists are obeying servants of agencies and agencies in return slave of Generals and generals are slave of their worldly desires.How low they descend.
Mr KS ..keep up the good fight ...every human being with a heart is with you....we need to join hands and get rid of these animals....
Kudos Sir for speaking the truth and highlighting a lack of sympathy for the affected and greatly traumatised Shia community. My heart goes out to all the families who have suffered at the hands of LeJ or whoever. This cycle of violence has be broken, but it cannot be broken by plain talk alone. The government must be forced to take strong action, media must adjust its co-ordinates, Urdu press needs to recognise the dangers of continuing on their chosen path and mullah must be restrained from preaching violence against any community. When people in the west see the daily carnage taking place in Pakistan on their TV screens and hear the rhetoric about the peaceful nature of Islam they form their own opinions. The situation is bad and something has to give. Make sure it is not the state that gives more space to the likes of Taliban.
These killings in the name of Jihad, as indeed the Jihad itself, have become an industry. Billions are collected and disbursed as part of this. Is it then, any wonder, that the people who should be responsible for security are content at issuing lazy statements. Everyone in power derives some benefit or the other out of this industry.
No doubt it is an outrage, What is happening to my birth place Pakistan, I grew up in Mardan and we were friends to Shias, Ahmadis, hindus and my dad never ever say that they are not acceptable because they believe what they believe. Our neighbors were shias and they were as patriotic Pakistani as any Sunny I knew of, this hatred of others is destroying the country slowly and I see the incompetence of the current government, intelligence agencies and police. Why are these people being paid for doing what , why don't they just leave their jobs to some one who could do it better and stop this carnage once for all. Pakistanis are getting such a bad name around the world and it is called a lawless country, it is hard to call ourselves Pakistanis abroad when our countrymen are slaughtering innocent citizens of their own because it does not fit their brand of religion.You may be right that it can't happen without the blessing of some powerful national organization. I think the Pakistani nation has been desensitized to the extent that they don't feel the pain of others in their country, to them it is one more incident.Thank you for such a candid article, any one paying any heed to it ,I doubt it.
How dare you criticse these solders of islam They are writting new chapters in the art of bravery and chivallary These people you call animals are heros of millions and what is wrong with army relying on their suport. You fully well know it is not capable of winng any war by itself
Fantastic words my Kamran
Thank you Kamran Shafi bhai. Allah aapko jaza day. Keep writing the truth and I am really hoping our brothers in Pakistan will finally wake up from their sleep and stand together with their countrymen that are being slaughtered by cowards.
Did the CIA chief stood infront of US and told his nation that why 9/11 happened? Did the Sovien Union Intelligent stood infront of Russia and told them why SU was divided. I knw there is no more space for u to grow up but still try to Grow Up.
As so blunt you are sir ( kamran shafi ) and for so long... Still no one listens and the innocents still suffer. And those who do not listen ( imagine those bloodied kids as yours for once and feel the pain if you have any humanity left in you ).
Start by dismantling the terrorist network in Southern Punjab, remove the political patronage and stop pandering to anyone and everyone who says a few words in Arabic!
It is time to literally dismantle the Deep State and its Franksenstein militias, Lashkar-e-this and Jaish-e-that. These illegitimate children of Zia ul Haq are worse than metastasized cancer. It has reached a point where the only cure is to immediately dissolve/dismantle ISI. WE WANT TO LIVE LIKE A NORMAL NATION NOW.
Only in Pakistan people name themselves Changezi, it is like a European naming his son Hitler.
Strong and true. Sir these criminals have to be funded and the money trail according to our TV talk show's lead to three ' friendly ' Muslim ' brother 'countries, all three also allies of America.....................so the picture does get complicated.
@Author. I agree 100% with you. We all should be ashamed of what is happening in our country. The loss of Dr. Ali Haider feels so personal that I cant believe it happened. I saw him few times back in 2000 when I was finishing my house job in Mayo Hospital. A nice fellow and one of the few eye surgeons ( only one in Lahore) who could treat retinal bleeding and its complications. His Mother Professor Tahira ( now retired) was my teacher in Anatomy and his Father Syed Zafar Haider was teacher of my teachers ( many of them now professors thmselves in Mayo hospital and else where). What a pathetic nation we have become. I am sure if it was a PTI jalsa or a rock concert, thousands of Lahories would have shown up. But what a shame that a noble and destinguied professor's death is mourned only by few thousands. Where are the young doctors and their associations?
Mr KS hats off for your courageous words. Alas you had started it when atrocities started against ahmadies few decades ago. Even now if it is understood shall not be that late.