There is often doom and gloom in the country, but one had hoped that the Eid holidays will bring some calm. And they did indeed. Even cell phone calls were made unavailable for Eid enthusiasts. It was a strange kind of calm with news of barbarism the only entertainment. How in the world can any decent person rejoice, even at Eid, after reading that an 11-year-old has been sent to jail for presumably desecrating the Holy Scriptures? Those accosting and tormenting her wanted her blood. The keepers of the law pushed the poor child in prison, in the hope of appeasing her bloodthirsty neighbours. It is moments like these that make one question all faiths that can churn out such bloodthirsty followers. It is not simple bigotry (which by itself is unbearable) but the cruellest form of it mixed with a desire for blood — a child’s blood. Can one imagine the trauma of an innocent child being hounded and then locked away on the charge of blasphemy? If anything is heresy it would be to use religion to intimidate, persecute and harass people and that, too, a mere child.
The exhibition of religiosity in our society has reached dangerous heights. There is total freedom of religion but its manifestation has limits. Declaring other fiqhs like those from Fiqh-e-Jafferia kafirs is a crime. An open invitation to kill them and slogans seeking revenge against them are pasted all over in public spaces, including even on government properties. Surely, the state has a responsibility to arrest those seen so obviously blackening the walls of cities in this manner? This inertia and fright has emboldened religious militants. The Hazaras in Balochistan and simple travellers from Gilgit have been massacred ruthlessly. Not only the government, but all those who are selling themselves as the saviours of the nation must speak up. Violence is not a left or right issue. It is an issue of Pakistan’s survival and dignity. It is a disgrace for any country when its religious minorities leave because of persistent persecution.
Anger is not limited towards religious minorities alone and in fact extends to all vulnerable classes. The tailor gets humiliated. What for? For not getting the sahib’s and the begum sahiba’s clothes ready in time for Eid! A kami gets his eyes gorged out for illicit relations. Where is the law that the puritans made for such vices? It seems that all it has done is to lend further legitimacy to those who preach hate and sit on judgment of other people’s virtues. Let this end now. Let the next Eid be dedicated to peace. Let the faithful not confine themselves to the sacrifice of the best fed animal they see but take care of the animal within.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 25th, 2012.
COMMENTS (111)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
OK, that's right, but what about the girl , that was shown in media's pictures, is looking about only 11 or 12 years old . And her actual photos that were taken when she is going with peoples to helicopter , is looking an adult and her age was must be 20es. we are just going on the wrong trap . because only in Pakistan we are caring all types religion and there religions peoples. but at the other side we don't have respect in foreign countries . Here if only a single human of other religion is murdered or something else the whole worlds media take this on the peak , but at the same way and time there were thousands of Muslims killed in Palestine, Burma, Somalia and so on . please do something as a Muslim, because we have a religion , that's have all the topics in it . and this is our constitution . if an American comes in Pakistan , we give him a highly security , but if our peoples goes there , they investigate on air port 3 to 4 hours . that's the difference i want to explain .
Asma writes: "Let the faithful not confine themselves to the sacrifice of the best fed animal they see but take care of the animal within."
That my dear friends is the root of our problems. It can't be ok to slaughter animals for a "religious" function. The cruelty to animals that we show on Eid is the same cruelty we show the higher ups on that chain.
We start with the poor animals. Then we attach the idolaters - the Hindus - how much better than animals can they be? Then we attack the Christians- oh those nonbelievers! Then we attack the Ahmedis - they are surely not Muslims? Then the Shias - surely they are not as pure as the Sunnis. Pretty soon it will be your turn, no matter who you are.
So, mark my words. As Buddha once remarked in this very land, the kindness you show animals and the weakest amongst us is the final mark of any civilization. Let's reclaim the peaceful ways that marked our,subcontinental civilization from the rest of the world.
So you are advocating her because of her small age.. have you ever think about the killing of 11 months old child who was killed in drone attack? Whatever done by the USA is humanity for you ! Why you have double standards for terrorism ?
Neither Asma nor the readers represents the whole mindset of Pakistan. How many people in Pakistan can read English? How many Pakistanis have access to tribune blog? If her thoughts are put in front of whole representative population of Pakistan then she will be get slapped by thousands. Asma is such a stupid person. She is in government and still blaming. If you in government cannot change the situation then how does the people with no authority can bring the change?
Great insight into the scourge that is getting a strong foothold in our society. Continue the good work.
Isn't 65 years enough to gauge the depth of the failure of an Ideology?Any nation founded on Hate,Bigotry and misplaced chauvinism cannot hope to survive in this modern age of Diversity and mutual cooperation amongst cultures and faiths.Bleed my poor country because no one has the potency to speak up against the worst form of tyranny_ Religious!perhaps writers will write,activists will agitate within their closeted spaces but none will have the courage to take on this monster.This blighted land never had visionaries only pseudo intellectuals,arm chair revolutionaries and feudal demagogues who adorned the 'Awami' jackets of tyranny to deliver the first blow to whatever little Hope there was of liberal survival.Remember it was the 'Great intellectual, Berkley educated 'but a feudal__ deep skinned, that went to Mansoora and begged the bearded bigots to lend them support.In return he bartered away the rights of a mute minority,banned wine and women(its another matter that he eyed all the luscious women of his cabinet members and friends). That was the greatest Giveaway by a man who could have changed the course of History had he not been a Feudal mind set and was vision-less. The same forces rejoiced when he was lead to the gallows.Nemesis!As an educationist who has been interacting with young minds for the past 42 years and giving them Hope of a vibrant Future, I now feel that even these young minds and hearts are seeing through this facade.
@Anas Abbas: sir where in the world is pakistani media giving any coverage to Burma...........i couldnt find a single news paper with even the smallest bit of ordinary news on Burma till August......and even now only a handful of columnists wrote about it and when you say media.even on the electronic media....cdnt find a single channel with any coverage on the Burma atrocities...kindly give links or addresses to your sources so i can also see some of the excessive coverage you are talking about.....the only media i could find with any kind of coverage was the internet!
Mr. Shahbaz Tahir represents our societal mindset. We should not be surprised on his comments when we know that every one here believes all other religions as inferior and anti-Islam and everyone has been taught that Islam would conquer all societies. This "thekadaran-e-Islam" mindset has been developed by the "efforts" of our mulla, pseudointellectuals, textbooks. No body can change it in days. Rather it would take 2-3 generations.
@Poliprof:
Thank you for your very polite and kind words. If following the Book of Allah Subhana, i.e the Holy Quran, and following the sunnah of the Holy Prophet, SAWS takes me back to the stone age, believe me, I wish to remain as such. Inshallah one day, your ignorance, and arrogance will enable you, to understand reality, with a clear state of mind. How ever, remember the guidance only comes to those who seek guidance from Allah Subhana. Those who disobey, then for such he does not guide. May Allah Subhana save us all, from his punishment.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: And you're a perfect example of the religious bigotry, hatred and backwardness to which Ms. Jahangir refers. Perhaps once you've left your infantile Stone Age behind, you'll see fit to join the decent, intelligent people of this planet. Putz.
@Komal S:
My views are not extreme. I never suggested any punishment, for a minor girl, as this article is pointing out. How ever as a Muslim, in a pre dominantly Muslim country, where the Quran and Sunnah must take precedence over the entire comstitution, I fully endorse the blasphemy law. Secondly as every Muslim should care about the misery of other Muslims, in any part of the world, I stated, that the author, should voice concern about the way they are being savagely treated, in Burma, in Palestine, in Afghanistan, in Kashmir. Unfortunately if you read the comments of the liberal mind set that have been criticizing me, it is apparent that they are the ones who are extremist, since they least care about the misery of other Muslims, and would do anything to ridicule, Islamic traditions.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: There is nothing wrong in being religious and loving your religion. But your extreme views are scary. Tell me how would you live as a minority in another country where the majority believes in their religion the same way.
@ush gali wahla:
I and every sane Muslim, totally reject your incorrect analysis. The Holy Quran, is the easiest book to understand, in the entire universe, and a challenge to the disbelievers, the like of which can never ever be made, or written.
"We have made the Quran easy to understand, so who is that will take heed and understand." (Surah Qamar)
@ s asif taher and his like minded:
Although every Pakistani has a right to bear his or her opinion, we must correct the information. In your case it is the later part. Religion is a complex thing and the Quran is immensely complicated with inter twined layer of information, so you need to really understand it properly and learn by a scholar. You are misunderstandings boat load of information about Islam. Please keep the inner emotions or ego at bay when you write or say thing. You will see the change within you Insuallah. Keep faith in the country and take little steps for change. Talk is cheap, ACT. Btw, I am not picking on you bro.
It was a good article.
@Faraz: @cosmo:
Mr Faraz, the tsunami you referred, to you is Imran Khan. May Allah Subhana always protect him, and grant him a long life, Ameen. He is the only sane voice in Pakistan. Those who are taking Pakistan to destruction, are the liberal, secular mindset, and the present NRO tainted government, whose corruption is known to innocent children on the street. Shame on all you liberals, it is time to repent, and fear Allah, and get back to Islam.
We pay more attention to the writing as opposed to the meaning. We try to preserve the printed word yet ignore what the word means.
Blashphemy law has alwaya been there. Its there is western countries as well. The difference being that its not being misused to persecute religious minorities. No condoning somebody if he or she commits an act of blashphemy but thats not usually the case. Its just with hunting. That needs to be guarded against. We have to take responsibility for Pakistan. Just go to any middle eastern countries and you can see that they treat us like dirt.Why do we have to bother about them ? Bigotry in all forms remains bigotry.The liberals , a very small minority are not the enemy. The enemy is within , the enemy is us losing the voice of rationalism and pushing ourselves into a cul de sac. This about it Mr. Shahbaz Tahir before condemning a voice of reason like Asma Jahangir
@Faraz: very well said!
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: People like you and the 10 odd ones who liked your comments are the ones who would take the "pure" country of yours to its ultimate demise ! I wish Pakistanis otherwise though!
@Saleem: Why cant u bring the change? R u incapable or is it your indifference?
@Sultan khan: You are completely right. Bal Thakeray is despised by some Indians. But I wouldn't call it a majority. Our press doesn't have the guts to call a spade a spade.
@Aries: "In your country, India....". I beg your pardon sir, but Im Australian (can be verified by the IP number on this post) and a very proud one, and a Christian. My parents came from India and they too are very proud to be Australians. I can understand why you assumed I'm from India though. Since all other religions have been wiped out in your country, you must have assumed thats how it works in the rest of the world too and all the Sunils must be from India.
Asma, please continue to speak up and spread sanity and rationalism. Please be doubly careful about the rabid fanatics who mean you bodily harm. You have been a tireless champion of human rights and a source of support and succor to those at the receiving end of the religious and nationalist fanatics.
@Was A Pakistani:
Sir or Madam,
I strongly disagree with you regarding no hope about Pakistan. I have had personal encounter with the youth of Pakistan let it be the young female immigration officer, let it be the young man at Telenor of Mobilink Staff or a Bank officer who is under 30 years of age. All my experiences of interactions have been very positive.
This young generation is the hope of Pakistan and for Pakistan. Do not under estimate the power of the youth just because you might not have had any interactions with them. I sincerely believe they care and when the opportunity prevails itself they they will show their resolve and their abilities. Until then we have to wait, suffer and prey that the time comes soon.
@ All. its a good article by asma jehangir. what she said is right but have you ever thought what has happened in Burma or Palestine. 100's of children are killed by non-followers in Burma and even in Pakistan alot of innocent peoples including children and women are killed in Pakistan. i am not opposing her article but i just want that she may also write about all this
For those of you concerned about Burmese muslims, i wonder how many people in Pakistan truly know where Burma is on a map, and how many of them have visited Burma or even met a Burmese citizen?
If it is an overwhelming number of people, then, yes, Pakistanis should be making all the noise. Ditto for Palestine.
It is high time Pakistan focused on its internal problems than obssess about others problems ... like airline announcements ... first put on your oxygen mask before helping others put on their mask!
Great Ms Asma. You are really great. History will remember you as great lady. Since long it was repeatedly said that the fire which was lit to burn the Ahamdiyya community will ultimately engulf other minorities also. In the beginning no one took it seriously. Now results are emerging. Along with Hindus, Christians now Shias have also become the fuel of this hatred fire. Mind you there are 20 millions Shia residing in Pakistan. If state will not extinguish this fire even at this stage, you can write it for record next target will be another sect of Muslims and the dirty game will continue.
Asma is bearing the cross for the silent majority in the hope of , one day, making it fend for itself.She is ready to be crucified, She is doing everything to jolt us into action but apathy is abysmal. We need at least half a dozen of Asmas to do the trick. It is a tall order, keeping in view the infertility of 'wasteland'.
@ sunil matthew: your analysis is totally wrong. The brave voices fighting bigotry and intolerance like Asma Jehangirs are coming from within Pakistan. In your country, India all voices are stifled by corporate greed which ensures that they are no dissenting elements to the popular narrative of a just and prosperous society. You are like the Emperor with no clothes. We recognise our faults. You live in a fools paradise!
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir...Can we please stay relevant to the topic. There is no connection between Bal Thackrey and his alleged friendship with Asma Jahangir to wrongful imprisonment of an 11 year old on blasphemy charges. Prophet Mohammed SAWS would not have recommended such inhuman treatment of an 11year old kid. Our Prophet was an ocean of tolerance which unfortunatley his disciples that include you are not !
Asma Ji We want you to be President of Pakistan! Woh din kab ay gaa!
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir You seem to me like those people who worry far too much about the neighbours across the street while their own house and family members are burning. What a shame.
and let the CJ take suo moto of the minority persecution. Even the Pope took notice. Oh Stop!. i think he must be busy trying to figure out how to digest the unfathomable amounts of Rs made by his genius son. Too busy to take notice.
There is nothing wrong in exhibition of one true religion. Every other religion does that too. Exhibition of religion inspires people to become more religious and good.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: Where was this Blasphamy Law before Zia's regime? Also tell me why without such a law there is no problem in a secular country like India which homes more Muslims than Pakistan?? First learn to respect all religions then everything will fall in line
God bless you for your courage and views you hold I am speechless and my mind is numb when I hear mullahs calling it justified. I have 11 year old daughter and if she is late from school 5 minutes we worry. I live abroad and make decent money here in a white collar work. I live in Pakistan in my thoughts and tell my children that one day we will go back. Probably no,not not to live among those animals. One more thing that people love their handicapped children more than normal children,more so Down syndrome as those kid are very pleasant. It must be big shock for siblings and parents.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: Palestine, Burma etc are not Pakistan 's problems. But alarming increase in exhibitionist religiosity is. The space is shrinking for reason and rule of law. And Quran says a person who has killed one human being has killed the whole humanity. Please note the word human being. Quran and sunah categorically prohibit the present barbarity ranging inour country. I wish people like you could have read and understand Quran instead of enetering into rhetoric.
It would be really useful if such articles could be given a much higher visibility in the Urdu press too.
It was high time that intellectuals like Asma Jahangir speak out on such issues. In fact, there should be many more well-known figures/journalists in Pakistan who should jointly denounce in a number of newspapers,including the ones in urdu language,the perpetrators of such crimes as is frequently done in France. Otherwise, the so-called exhibition of false religiosity will reach new hights and then it will be too late.
Excellent article by an very outstanding lady! Sadly it's too late for Pakistan & especially Pakistanis to take these sane advices since all we have is Revenge, Hatred & Anger.
Dear Miss Jahangir,
Nice to read your article. I would like to inform you about a case which currently took place in our city in Mirpurkhas where you came a few months ago for a Bar visit. There was a Muslim boy of age 20 or 22, he was the owner of a milk shop in Mirpurkhas, he has also offered the prayer "Aitkaf" during Ramadan for ten days, on the 2nd day of Eid Ul Fitr he raped a minority girl of age 13 in his shop. It was really so shocking to hear about that. We are given too much pains in society and the law enforcement agencies are totally vulnerable. There are hundreds of other issues which are not resolved yet like discrimination in education, accurate wages for labor and employment etc. I request you to please do something for our rights, we don't want to leave Pakistan, we love Pakistan.
The question is - Who is going to bell the cat??/
Good wishfull thinking! No one stood up against 2nd Amendment & no one will standup now. If the 'educated' class is confused or coward what hope is there? What started as persecution against Ahmadis will not stop there! Only hope is ALMIGHTY ALLAH THE EXALTED!
"The exhibition of religiosity in our society has reached dangerous heights."
Madam Jehangir, truth be told, you have hit the nail on its head, now if only the civilian Government could get its head out of "survival" mode they could persecute the perpetrators of these heinous atrocities.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir
Have you read the Quran? or have you just heard interpretation from the mullahs? Pseudo-Muslims like you are the curse of Islam. For once before you die, Read the Quran!!
Why don't you cry foul about how muslims are killing muslims in syria, how pseudo-muslims like you call your own brother non-muslims and kill them if you could make their life HELL enough!
Save Islam from the likes of you!!
Extremely relevant and very well written. Unfortunately this is like water off a ducks back, the people who can do something are not listening, either out of cowardice or complicity. This barbarism in the name of religion has to take it own course because finally it must consume itself and the loser will be religion as preached in this country which has been forsaken by God.
A brilliant piece from one of the sanest voices in this doomed country, Asma Jahangir, as expected. However I have uneasy feeling on the title of the article and the concluding prayer:
The Title: The animal within The Prayer: Let the faithful not confine themselves to the sacrifice of the best fed animal they see but take care of the animal within.
No animal does what we do. Fear the day when animals will master the art of "human within". We the pretenders as 'Ashraf-ul-Makhlooqaat" of this Pak-land are the worst specimens of all creatures existing on planet earth.
Problems of 'extremist religious hate' invariably emerge when any religion tries to oust the culture of a land. Christianity tried it in Europe during the Crusades, killed and burnt over two million over 200 years and failed. Today the majority think religion is bunk. The same is happening to Islam and Pakistan. Puritanical movements emerge when the illiterate cannot handle life as it gets complex. The Burma killings is exactly this, but only the Buddhists are doing it. Pakistan was created out of hate and sustains itself on hate. Over time IF IF education prevails, our culture will prevail. If not, then we will burn in our own fire. Religion was used to create a State. Religion will be it's undoing.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: This is what she is lamenting. "Superficial religiosity". Just quote the words Like " Quraan and Sunnah", our beloved Prophet(PBUH) and ' last and final prophet' and that's all. After saying these words even if you don't act upon the commands of Allah and His Prophet(PBUH) you have got a ticket for jannat and license to kill. Charity begins at home and it is a fundamental principle of Sharia. If my brother is being killed in another country and my neighbour is being killed at the same time it's my moral and islamic responsibilty to save the neighbour first as I am unable save my brother in another country right at the moment. As far as Bal Thakeray , though a despicable person disliked by even majority of Indians, is concerned he has never owned the killings of Muslims. What about your "brethren in faith" the so-called "Mujahedeen-e-Islam" who kill the innocent people in the most barbaric manner and then own those killings very proudly.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: "Make no mistake, we are a Muslim country, where the Quran and Sunnah, of our beloved Prophet SAWS, the last and final Prophet, are above everything, even the constitution."
Can you tell me why are those who love the Prophet & his Ahl Al Bait (household) murdered in cold blood in your "Muslim" country.
Stop crying about India & Burma, when the devil is within you.
@ZEN: Sir, you say : " GET RID OF THE BLASPHEMY LAW " !
(a) This could have been done ages ago . First * please think* WHY no one can get rid of this law. (b) The stage has been reached when getting rid of the LAW is not going to do the trick. After the law is abrogated, the mindset of the people who have these laws needs to be changed. Religion there is plenty and more. What is missing is the internalization of the positive values of the spiritual aspects of the religion. Without this * internalized * sense of humane values , law or no law, the evil ways of thinking will still run wild.
A mature, secure individual and society , which knows the essence of its religious values as an internal force for good, need not even think for one second about blasphemy or about calling each other kaffirs and killing the * other* in its midst.
There is no hope for Pakistan. We are nation in terminal decline. When body is in its final stage of destruction all kinds of problems occur. So Pakistan now has multiple organ failure because state is simply not functioning and we have bed sores in form of all the mess in the society. We can keep dragging this corpse as long as we want but reality is the dispensation that was planned in 1947 is dead.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: By your analysis only one man was guilty of blasphemy on the fall of Mecca? The rest of the kafirs were only fighting and were otherwise tightlipped? This analysis is against human nature.
Pakistan is extremely fortunate to have people like Asma Jahangir. And, the extreme misfortune of Pakistan is that no one listens to her!
Pakistan is extremely fortunate to have Islam as the state religion. And, the extreme misfortune of Pakistan is that no one follows the teachings of Islam.
I wonder why not many Muslims live in Pakistan? What happened to them?
"The exhibition of religiosity in our society has reached dangerous heights," sums up the current situation in Pakistan. I would like to ask, seriously, whether people there have no vocation and whether in an Islamic country the state's religion can be under any threat.
The uniformity of views of people on issues raised by Asma is frightening.
Asma, there is a more serious malaise eating away the society, and it is at the psychological level. Please refer to a story in Dawn of 24/8 http://dawn.com/2012/08/24/afghanistan-state-of-shock/, which analyses the effect of violence. It is clear that the Pakistani society is also being affected by the violence around. I am not denying, nor belittling the role of religious bigotry in providing an excuse for violence. What I find essential at this time, however, is for credible social psychologists to put their heads together and study the increasing brutality in the society, and suggest ways to handle it, if any. Is it possible for HRCP to gather such a group of psychologists?
Mahatma Gandhi was also a 'liberal fascist' like Asma and he was killed by a religious extremist. Thus it's important to understand the difference between the two. There are only two kinds of people in this world - good and bad. Asma is a good human being. Period
The real culprit is the law enforcement authorities & govt. If any of these spineless authorities had acted strongly against these blood thirsty fundamentalists by taking strong action & putting them behind bars this madness should have slowly come down. For that to happen some genuine patriotic & bold leaders who are not afraid of these hate mongerers should take charge of the country.
Bokharee : Let the British rule Pakistan alone Leave India to itself Hate mongering and violence is the root cause of Pakistan itself. Remember "Direct Action" day started by Jinnah. Things became worse ever since hate mongering and false history teaching eulogizing rapers and plunderers and victimizing people of other religion has been built into school curricula. The only way for redemption is fix the school and college curricula esp Pak history and Islamiat. Then the next generation may become more civilized.
@Anas Abbas: At least it is good to see that your comment is the most fav for this article!
@I.H.Bokharee: "I once again beg the British to come back..." For Pakistan maybe. Indians are better off after we kicked them out. And don't forget they were the ones to create mischief between hindus and muslims to start with with their divide and rule policy. So as far as brits are concerned, I'd say No Thank You. In a democracy, the majority gets what it wants. If the majority (common man in the street) in Pakistan wasn't in favor of fundamentalism, the current climate of intolerance and violence wouldn't have lasted (or increased the way it has). I wonder how many in the urdu press appreciate what Asma ji has written. I'm afraid the worst is yet to come.
The voices like Asma jee will be gone in near future. Without a Divine help, I do not see any hope because those events which were beyond our imagination have become norms of our society and we are still justifying it? A society with morally corrupt and intellectually impotent leadership, both religious and secular, is destined to have a barbaric and inhumane episodes like we see every other day on the name of religion and family “ghairat”!
@Sunil Matthew: You are wrong. Whether Pakistan implodes or explodes, its neighbors have to pay a heavy price. Do not forget what Nazi Germany's neighbors had to go through.
How things shape up from here will clear the Air whether the country has a moderate majority or a fanatic majority.
@Sid:
Does Quran Sura e Hazab Ayat # 57 and 61, and Sura e Maida Ayat 33 mandate death penalties for Blasphamy?
Any Islamic Scholar?
I once again beg the British to come back and rule over us for another 100 years. Just one solution.....
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir:
After reading your response to such a thought provoking article, this is why I am of the opinion that;
Iran produced "Pasdaran-e-Islam. Afghanistan produced "Taliban-e-Islam Pakistan produced "Thekedaran-e-Islam.
In the name of Islam The Nation of Pakistan is killing each other and calling each other non-muslims and you want hem to stop killing each other and start worrying about Muslims in the other parts of the World?
@Falcon: My only question is why intellectuals of this country don’t propose solutions to these problems.
Falcon Sahib,
The solution is obvious... Pakistani Islamists have to be dealt with violently and defeated completely. The question is whether the Pakistani state has the capacity to do it (doubtful) or whether the rest of the world has to do get together and fix this problem.
I think the point of no return has been reached. The downward spiral of Pakistan is catching momentum and cannot stop now despite Asmaji's noble thoughts. With intolerance towards Ahmedias and other minorities being enshrined in your constitution makes me confident that It is only a matter of time that Pakistan will go down the drain. We will then have peace in Kashmir, Afghanistan, Balochistan etc. We just have to be a bit patient, till then sit back and enjoy the tamasha.
This lady has guts to call a spade a spade! You are the voice of the oppressed in Pakistan! May you have a long life! (Amen)
@s shah:
I am not supporing any evil or justifying any evil. Shame on you, and those like you, who are foolish, with limited understanding.
@ann: @Umer:
Yes the blasphemy law was then too. When Prophet Mohammed SAWS, victoriously entered Makkah, he forgave each and everyone, except one person, whose name I am forgetting. Never the less about that individual, the Habib of Allah, SAWS, said, if he wore to touch the ghilaf of Kaba, and take refuge, he will not be able to save himself. I suggest you speak to eminent scholars, regarding this, incident, before you start making conclusions. I am not saying that a 11 year old girl be punished. She is a minor, but the blasphemy law, has been there ever since the time of our Prophet SAWS. For us Muslims, who believe in the oneness of Allah, and the finality of Prophet Mohammed, SAWS, they mean to us, more than even ourselves. We love them, more than even our selves, if we truly believe. Unfortunately the liberal secular agenda, of which this author, is a champion, will Inshallah never succeeed. It is far beneficial for all of us to repent now, and get back on the way of Allah, and the way of his Habib.SAWS. May Allah Subhana teach us the best.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: And does the evil done around the world excuse or justify the evil done in Pakistan against its minorities ? Shame on you and your twisted mindset.
brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: How is the persecution of Muslims in other countries in any way connected to the mindless religiously motivated violence that is engulfing Pakistan? How are the two even connected? Why is it that anyone who questions the state of affairs in this country be branded a traitor or heretic? Also please give a reference on how the Blasphemy law is in any connected to Quran and Sunnah in its present form?
Well, Ma'am you have written all that we already know. We have read all of this in the papers and to some extent watched it on electronic media. We all know it is bad and barbaric. But the fact remains that who is to bring the change. Who is going to help eradicate all this evil from our society? It is high time remedial measures are taken. Ma'am, you are in a position far better than the common man, we expect a lot from people like you. You can do a lot and lead other like mined people for a change.
How about asking the parties in power whom you support to stand up and do something about this scourge? They have been in power for nearly five years and for a change it behooves you to ask them hard questions on this issue. Or may be the only thing you can vocally protest against, every time you are on the TV, is the Supreme Court. When it comes to your criticisms they seem to be the only target. And please do not tell us that it is an old problem and that every one has to change and on and on. Your party in power have ALL the instruments of CIVIL CONTROL in their hands and YOU and THEY need to explain what exactly has been done. And if not why exactly are they in power? When will you ask for their resignations because of their failure? Please pay attention to this also once you have some time left after criticizing the SC.
Dear Asma thanks for the timely Op Ed and for ET to print it. Is is sad to see how much we have degraded and degenerated. Here is a copy from an email that a white American Muslim has sent this Ramazan. It says a lot in few lines and I wish to share it with my fellow Pakistanis: "MUSLIMS CONSPIRING AGAINST INTERFAITH WORK
There is a group of Muslims out there, working to conspire against interfaith work, they intensely hate it - and they live here in America! If Imams Muzammil Siddiqi, Hamza Yusuf, Sayyid Syeed, Mohamed Majid and others have sat with Hindus, Christians, Jews and others in their place of worship, they are susceptible.
They probably don’t know that Prophet Muhammad was the first man to initiate interfaith work, and the one to teach civil conduct through Quran, “to you is your deen and to me is mine.” We have to work on some Sunna priorities - which Sunna to follow first - a beard and pulled up pajamas or telling the truth and taking care of the neighbor?
I pray that God give us sense to do good, rather than being an impediment to the good work of knowing and taking care of neighbors. Amen!"
The author seems to live in cuckoo land wishing away all the evils of a stoneage society. Who will bring the desired change?!
Asma sahiba,its a true and nice article but unfortunately our people the nation is still in deep sleep and there is no way except doom and gloom in our part on eid and on any occasion. we can't celebrate it with joy but with fear,
@Falcon: perhaps you remember the fate of the man who was killed for a stand on this law.
asma, perhaps, doesn't want to gift her life so easily by being an impediment in the path of the law. she just want the law to remain, but not followed in letters, as are so many laws in our constitution which serve only cosmetic purposes.
welcome to Pakistan where violence is presented as entertainment where half the population is perpetuating or condoning violence and the other half is too scared or does not care much to raise a voice and when someone like Asma Jehangir raise her voice in defense of the minorities the religious fanatics start attacking her personal life rather than refuting her arguments with logical arguments of their own. in short its madness all around with not a ray of hope in sight.
@ shahbaz asif tahir i agree 110% that God and the Holy Prophet are above law but dear sir was it the way the state was running at his time? did he make any blasphemy laws then?of course not! then sir you are being blasphemous by not following his example! is there any incident at his time when a non believer was treated the way they are treated here in this islamic state... He is rahmatul alameen....alameen means all the worlds which 'unfortunately' includes everything and everyone not only muslims.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir: She wrote about the current trend prevailing in Pakistan, not about what happening around the world..
Respected Asma Ji, spot on target. What a pity that the while nation is engaged on petty issues of Swiss letter, NATO supply, Burma massacre, and vulgarity of electronic media.
@Anas Abbas: For your information, IK has stated in explicit terms that the girl should be released.
it is better to suspend every law in Pakistan till the current chief justice of Pakistan, who has no concern with justice,just playing his political game
Great piece Ms. Jahangir. You have truly inherited the genes of bravery from your father.
@Shahbaz Asif Tahir:
Oh why why why? We are Pakistanis, when are we going to do something for ourselves for a change? We don’t have responsibility for the whole world. This mind-set is amazing; our own country is going down the drain and yet we still should not focus on our own issue first? Why?
Thank you madam. After BB you are the only who has courage to talk truth. This law itself is wrong. We muslims are criminal minded.
good article.
The elite of this nation have expressed that they don't care what the law of land is about, and now its time, the masses are declaring this. The bitter part is there has been no Government for the people, in our history, ever.
Good article Asma!! Get rid of this blasphemy law, you should take the lead. You have the courage and energy to make this change.
How about writing the same, about the massacre in Burma, of Muslims, the outrageous killings in Palestine, the killings of Muslims all over? Seems like she forgets that the Shiv Sena, Bal Thackerey, who massacred Muslims, in Bombay, is her friend, to whom she paid respects, by dressing in the same color clothes, he was in, and now has the nerve to write on these issues. Make no mistake, we are a Muslim country, where the Quran and Sunnah, of our beloved Prophet SAWS, the last and final Prophet, are above everything, even the constitution.
My eid was spoilt by seeing so much hatred of people for eachother on social media due to sects or opposite political parties. It is a depressing situation that we have become careless and insensitive on our own issues.
And guess what, who started this vicious circle? The party you are representing.
hats off madam... one of the few 'near extinction' sane voice in this country of bigotry!!!
Great piece Asma jee
to sum it up, this is actually what happened.
11 Year old girl is the latest target of Pakistani blasphemy law. Typical reactions:
Pakistani Media: BURMA BURMA BURMA
Pakistani politicians: We will take notice however there is nothing wrong in the law itself, its actually the implementation which needs scrutiny.
Imran Khan: War on terror and Zardari is responsible
Pakistani Urban elite: BURMA BURMA BURMA. OH MY GOD salman khan looks so hot when he takes his shirt off
Common sense: Blasphemy law is a flawed drocanian law that cannot be implemented in any society. Its just impossible. SAVE THE GIRL
unfortunately no 5 is a tiny minority in pakistan