Assembled for a cause


Express June 08, 2010

ISLAMABAD: The ban on Facebook has been lifted; but for some people, the underlying principle that propelled the ban continues to linger on. For this reason, a group of 30 socialites, journalists, students and bloggers assembled in Kuch Khaas Art Gallery on Monday and offered their strongest disapproval of internet censorship.

Renowned writer, editor and columnist Raza Rumi led the discussion and shared his thoughts on Lahore High Court’s (LHC’s) ban on the social networking website.

“It was a terrible thing which LHC did, banning the internet and restricting our access to information,” Rumi said. He quoted an example from the life of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), where a woman used to throw garbage on him everyday but he used to ignore it, to make his point. “Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was a tolerant man [and we should learn from his example],” he said.

The participants also shared their personal experiences during the ban.

Sana Saleem, a participant, said she had written a blog in a newspaper criticising the ban, which turned people, including some of her friends, against her. “The part which scared me the most was that people were getting personal and sending me threats on my mobile phone,” she said. “People I knew were giving me options like ‘either you use facebook or love the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)’,” she added.

Zeeshan, another participant, described the sense of fear that people who were against the ban felt. “The worrisome part was the way everyone was afraid to talk on the subject,” he said. “My friends went to the Press Club in Karachi to protest and were attacked by people [for speaking against the ban],” he added.

Maha, a socialite, was troubled how people in Pakistan blindly supported the ban. “People were not discussing rights and wrongs [in the ban] but were actually agreeing to the censorship,” she said.

At the end, Khaas Art Gallery’s curator, Zeeshan, said more people needed to step-up and discuss issues that concern them.

Kuch Khaas, a sister organisation of Khaas Art Gallery, is a “not-for-profit social enterprise comprising of a community space for public discourse, the pursuit of knowledge, meaningful entertainment, civic engagement and advocacy in the city of Islamabad”, according to their Facebook page. It serves as a platform for urban socialites to come together and discuss issues that bother them.

Published in the Express Tribune, June 9th, 2010.

COMMENTS (6)

Raza Rumi | 13 years ago | Reply Faisal: thanks for the comment. Please note that we as Muslims love and respect our great Prophet (pbuh) - this is a non-negotiable position. But when some silly, uninformed people try to ridicule we must react with reason - after all we are "ashraf-ul-makhlooqat". If we ban the entire internet whom are we damaging other than ourselves! There are many ways to protest and even force sites such as Facebook not to hur the sentiments of the people. But internet is neither a country (whom you can declare jihad against) nor a person (who can be booked under blasphemy laws). As Adil Najam said we have given the issue so much importance that millions noticed that FB page. If at all we should have blocked the FB page (like several other countries) and not ban over 800 sites!! Aziz: I am not sure what are you saying - if it is an attack directed at my blogs then the best place would be to leave such a comment on my blogs. Though I agree that there should be no double standards on censorship. Blog owners/editors face a difficult situation while moderating comments.
Aziz | 13 years ago | Reply what an irony that most of these blogging intellectuals do exercise their right of censorship when you comment on their blogs and that's too absolutely and without any oversight. On the contrary, they are not ready to allow censorship in blasphemy matters!. Come on and state clearly what do you stand for?
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ