Film review: The Age of Adaline - all about aesthetics

Published: May 17, 2015
Visually appealing as it may be, The Age of Adaline’s hokey story makes the film fall flat.

Visually appealing as it may be, The Age of Adaline’s hokey story makes the film fall flat.

Wonderful art direction, brilliant costume design, flawless re-creations of period cityscapes and a few very fine performances make The Age of Adaline a rather enjoyable film. But the film’s contrived, manipulative and insipid story keeps it from becoming the great film it could and should have been.

Directed by Lee Toland Krieger, the film tells the story of a young lady named Adaline (Blake Lively) whose happy marriage ends with the death of her husband during the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge. She subsequently survives a near fatal car accident to emerge as an ageless person who is destined to remain at a youthful 29 years of age for the rest of her life. Adaline decides that keeping her agelessness a secret is the only way she can lead a ‘normal’ life and changes her identity every 10 years to make sure that no one catches on to her. The strategy results in her having no lasting romantic relationships or friendships in life. The only constant emotional tie is that with her daughter Flemming (Ellen Burstyn). Life goes on for Adaline until she meets the handsome Ellis Jones (Michiel Huisman) and falls in love. The romance creates complications that Adaline has managed to avoid for decades and is not equipped to handle. Things come to a head when she spends a weekend with Jones’ family and Ellis’ father, William Jones (Harrison Ford), reveals a secret that shakes everyone’s lives, forcing them to confront issues and take decisions that are neither easy nor convenient.

The Age of Adaline fails for one primary reason. It is more interested in its hokey gimmick — agelessness caused by lightening, freezing and some other over-explained and under-conceptualised pseudo-scientific theory — and the decidedly dull life of its heroine, than it is in examining the subjects of love, regret, tragedy, aging, mortality and sacrifice that would lend heft and soul to the film. The actors are ready and capable of handling a script that deals intelligently with these issues but the writers, J Mills Goodloe and Salvador Paskowitz, seem doggedly committed to a shallow story full of melodramatic contrivance, manufactured emotion and exaggerated drama.

Lively and Huisman act with competence, believability and style but are easily outdone by the magnificent Ford, Kathy Baker, who plays the role of Jones’ mother, and Burstyn, who are all on top of their game in The Age of Adaline. Two scenes in the movie, in particular, are masterful displays of the tremendous acting talent of the three seasoned stars. The first takes place in a diner where Adaline meets her daughter. During the course of the meal, she comments on her daughter’s excessive use of salt. The much older Ellen Burstyn, who plays the daughter, reacts like a rebuked teenager, showing adolescent petulance and defiance with slight but discernable changes in voice, tone and mannerisms. The second scene takes place in the home of Ellis Jones’ parents. Harrison and Baker are getting ready to celebrate their 40th wedding anniversary when the memory of the husband’s unfulfilled romance with a beautiful woman is rekindled. His wife is soon jealous of the omnipresent memories of her husband’s long lost love. The result is an altercation where Baker displays a wife’s love, jealousy and incomprehension and Ford shows a husband’s conflict, regret and helplessness caused by unrelenting romantic memories. The scene is likely to leave students of cinema in total awe and amazement.

The two powerful scenes, remarkable though that they are, hurt The Age of Adaline instead of helping it. They remind the audience that the fine performances of Ford, Baker and Burstyn belong to a far superior film than its writers allow it to be.

Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, May 17th, 2015.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (9)

  • Ammar Shareef
    May 17, 2015 - 7:27PM

    I was looking for a good critical analysis of the movie, this one is most justified. Good job Ally Adnan and ETRecommend

  • mohsin Kamal
    May 17, 2015 - 7:32PM

    A movie worth watching . A very Well written review by Ally Adnan . A must read Recommend

  • Romeo Armaa
    May 17, 2015 - 7:33PM

    Another exciting piece of writing from our favorite seasoned-writer Sir Ally Adnan.
    I was waiting for this reviewRecommend

  • Arsaln
    May 17, 2015 - 8:52PM

    Good perception in a few words… Nice review!Recommend

  • Moh papounsky
    May 17, 2015 - 9:34PM

    Please keep these reviews coming :-) Recommend

  • Kumail Jaffry
    May 19, 2015 - 10:27AM

    Haven’t seen the movie asyet..but from the review looks like totally worth it..Recommend

  • Kumail Jaffry
    May 19, 2015 - 10:31AM

    after reading the article one has too go and see the quite well written..Recommend

  • Salman Bakhtiyar
    May 19, 2015 - 6:04PM

    Another great and candid review by Ally.Recommend

  • M Waqas Ahmad Khan
    May 19, 2015 - 6:08PM

    i liked it, and keep updating us, i hope you will be writing next on upcoming Pakistani movies …Recommend

More in Magazine