Rise of sectarianism and unchecked killings by the LeJ, especially of Hazaras in Balochistan, as well as of people in Gilgit-Baltistan, has destroyed Pakistan’s integrity and polarised society. The TTP and the LeJ are also targeting people in Karachi, Lahore and other urban centres and their rancour can be traced back to the hate literature and speeches that are spewed from some mosques and seminaries. In this, the religio-political parties could play a positive role by exposing dangers inherent in the pursuit of these intractable sectarian prejudices.
The proxy war that is being fought on our soil between Saudi Arabia and Iran has been another contributory factor in which some militant groups have been their local partners. Hopefully, there is now a better understanding with these countries and financial support to militant groups is being withdrawn.
The cumulative impact of failure to vigorously implement the National Action Plan could lead to Pakistan becoming fertile environment for the Islamic State (IS) and other emerging global and regional militants. Already, there are indications that the IS is recruiting members in Pakistan.
The government also needs to calibrate its anti-terrorist policies that do not weaken fragile democratic institutions. The balance of power has further shifted in favour of the military due to the establishment of military courts and a lacklustre response to security and governance issues. The accumulation of pending terrorist cases created a serious security problem. The military leadership seized the initiative for setting up military courts that also has popular support. Now that military courts are a reality, the best option for the judiciary and the executive would be to reform and strengthen the system within the next two years and reclaim the people’s confidence.
The recent terrorism in France aroused deep public indignation throughout the world that could have serious ramifications for the Muslim world. It is likely to give rise to increased intolerance and discrimination against Muslims in Europe and elsewhere, and give boost to conservative, right-wing parties. It was a vivid demonstration of leadership by the French president to mobilise his nation in condemning the brutal killings of people in the attack on Charlie Hebdo by a fanatic group belonging to al Qaeda and the IS. It was a stirring spectacle to witness over 40 world leaders — despite some having dubious credentials — from several continents standing in solidarity with the fallen victims. They were giving a clear message of not giving in to terror and showing resolve to protect their cherished values. In contrast, where are our solidarity marches and protests denouncing terrorists? It is rare to find our civilian leaders reaching out to the public after a terrorist assault and showing their resolve. Our civil society is inclined towards participating in dharnas, but not when it involves serious national issues. What is, however, inspirational is the leadership exhibited by General Raheel Sharif. He clearly stands out as someone who knows how to lift the morale of the stricken and give hope to the nation that the war against militancy will be won. What prevents our civilian leaders from showing their full support to terror victims? It is not for optics that the nation demands their presence. Sharing the sufferings of our people should come naturally to them. Moreover, the endless squabbling between the PML-N and the PTI on the credibility of elections has remained a huge distraction and hopefully would be brought to a decent closure. Otherwise, it will reinforce the image that the priorities of politician are lopsided and narrow, vested interests take precedence over grave national issues.
It is crucial that we fight the war against terrorism without further weakening our democratic structure. A strong democratic framework is an essential prerequisite in combating terror and bringing peace to our land. It would be naive to believe that the government, by gradually passing on its responsibilities to the military either by design or through sheer incompetence, will be able to steer the country from its existential crisis. The nature of the threat is such that it demands a comprehensive response in which the civilian leadership’s role is of crucial significance. It is not merely a fight between the military and militants, but a fight for our ideology, our values and our national integrity.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 21st, 2015.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (13)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
There are incompetent leaders in India also, Dev Gowda, IK Gujral, Vp Singh, Lalloo Prasad, Mulayam Singh, Azam Khan, Mamta Banerji, Yedyurappa, who have damaged the nation. In new breed it is Rahul Gandhii. In the era of globalization and skills, perhaps muslim community is not fully ready. people of older generation in Southall, Bradford, Birmingham, are not well adjusted. They are of both india and Pakistan. The immigrants from Algeria, Tunisia, MOrocco, Libya, Africa are not assimilated because of low skill levels. When compared to citizens of REunion French island with indian muslim background. Reunion is prosperous. I feel CUba is an eye opener, the French citizens should try their luck back in their native. The slums of Marseilles, are nothing but a recruitment centre for Al QAeda, This wil bring further resentment towards Muslims globally.
@ishrat salim:
Had our politicians been strong enough with strong nerves, patriotic & honest, 5 years & 20 months of civilian rules is a long period to get rid of the menace of terrorism. All these features are not required from the political leaders, but only COMPETENCE, EFFICIENCY and MANAGEMENT skilln . Remember Sir the trees do not growx Minor in the sky!!
Rex Minor
Truth be told : Thanks.
I asked a question that touched on the stellate ganglion and I hope apart from cursing me as "majority of your type" attitude, people ask the introspective question.
What are the PAK ideology and values that commentators are asking the people to fight for to save the integrity of PAK.
@John B:
"What is PAK ideology and values- the preamble to the constitution, second Amendment, position on Blasphemy laws, limiting freedom of thoughts, denouncing other sects leader in passport application, not recognizing Hindu marriages, hudood laws, etc?"
Excellent points. Also add to the "ideology" enshrined in the constitution: Only Muslims can hold top offices thereby constitutionally rendering non-Muslim Pakistanis as second class citizen.
Had our politicians been strong enough with strong nerves, patriotic & honest, 5 years & 20 months of civilian rules is a long period to get rid of the menace of terrorism, if they think these were the making of a dictator, who stopped them to roll back all those policies which they think were against country`s interest. But, no they know their capability & their capacity, their intellect to gauge the problems in a pro-active manner. After 5 years & 20 month, the civilian leadership realized their limitation & out-sourced actions to the Armed forces....why ? who stopped them from making legislations to make judiciary & other depts. strong in order to face the menace...who stopped them from making ATCs strong instead of using it to arrest people like IK & TuQ ? who stopped them from diverting resources to our LEAs to make them strong to face the menace, instead of spending money on laptops, metros, motorways & the like. Does it need rocket science to fathom that our country has 2 most important issues...1) energy & 2) terrorism. what steps have been taken to root out root cause of terrorism ?...NONE! till now...in fact our political leaders & intellectuals have not been able to define...what is terrorism ? who are they ? how do they get into this heinous crime, who are behind such groups, from where financing is coming ? etc; what steps needed to de-radicalize elements who are surrendering or getting arrested by our LEAs. Do we have answers to these questions ? the day is not far, when we will suddenly see emergence of IS from with us...wait, as we continue to be in a state of denial which has led us to the present mess & remember IS is more violent then what we have witnessed. If these political leadership do not put their act together soon they will surely miss the bus. Then requesting the Army will not help much either. Army will save the country not individuals & they are the only bonding factor as very rightly pointed out by the American high officials during Gen Raheel visit. They realize that & have expressed it. So, please refrain from criticizing the Army, who might be our only savior after Allah swt...many do that. Politicians will rise only if they fear for their chair, like dharnas.
@oBSERVER: Your post to John; What exactly is your ideology, your values and national integriy? Like the swiss cheese there are countless holes in the policy your current civil-military coolition Government that it has become dysfuntional and on track to become a failed state.
Rex Minor
@John B: Your verdict is as absurd as your knowledge of our ideology our values and national integrity. This is nothing new with majority of your type. You first equip yourself with correct knowledge of what I mentioned above then we could argue.
I consider General Talat Masood amongst the very top echelon of the intellectuals in our Country, and make it a point to read his views. I would offer a diverging view to his on these points:
First: We must not fall into the trap of declaring all persons with opposing viewpoints to the Western interests as terrorists or harbouring terrorist views. The ones like Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), the Punjabi Taliban, and Lashkar-e-Janghvi (LeJ), certainly belong in this category.
Those hanged recently from the Air Force are not terrorists, who in fact tried to avenge their thousands of fallen brethren in the Kargil conflict launched by one opportunist Musharraf as a means of gaining glory and power from a very safe distance. If people pay respects to their remains fresh off the gallows, it does not indicate a general sickness with our entire society.
Second: Our public is intelligent enough to know that all politicians are pick-pockets, as a taxi driver mentioned to my father and I taking us to Murree in the late 60's. I was in the 5th class. Everything that has happened since has only fortified this impression in the masses.
Our constitution, as Secretary Shamshad Ahmed pointed out in this paper, was drafted by the same august house that was responsible for the dismemberment of the Eastern half of the Country, with the deliberate ease I might add of switching off a light-bulb. It was also suspended within 5 hours. This is our sacred Magna Carta, the basis of our flawed democracy. To expect democratic wonders by its feudal enactment is to expect fish to ride bicycles.
We can not aspect any action from Nawaz sharif government against terrorism already stuck in petrol crises,, opposition bze in enjoying honeymoon, only pak army in action against Indian funded and supported terrorists...
when religion is worn on sleeves and jihad is glamourised in every book from the school to discussion the mindset is bound to have sympathy with them
The author made strong arguments but lost in the end when he closed The opinion
"It is not merely a fight between the military and militants, but a fight for our ideology, our values and our national integrity.
What is PAK ideology and values- the preamble to the constitution, second Amendment, position on Blasphemy laws, limiting freedom of thoughts, denouncing other sects leader in passport application, not recognizing Hindu marriages, hudood laws, etc?
If the above are the state Ideology and values, then they are no different from "militants" ideology and values. The fight between the militants and current PAK rulers then is purely on the control of the state and not on ideology and values.
Arguments are most welcome.