The dismal state of human rights in Pakistan

Published: December 12, 2014
The writer is a human rights activists and director of the Gender Studies Centre. She tweets @drfarzanabari

The writer is a human rights activists and director of the Gender Studies Centre. She tweets @drfarzanabari

The International Day of Human Rights was observed on December 10 by the international community to commemorate the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) by the UN General Assembly in 1948. The UDHR sets international standards of human rights in which every individual is entitled to certain fundamental rights, irrespective of his/her class, gender, race, ethnicity, religion and other social divisions. It states in its Article 1 that “All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights”. The principle of universal human rights is enshrined in several international human rights bills and instruments. However, there is a contradictory trend of increasingly pronounced international commitments to human rights, and growing inter-state and intra-state disparities and vulnerabilities around the world. Extremes of wealth and poverty are the hallmarks of the modern world. According to the Global Wealth Report 2013, the top 0.6 per cent of the world population owns 39 per cent of global wealth. Massive vulnerabilities are created along the lines of class, gender, race, ethnicity, religion and other social divisions around the world. Nearly half of the world’s population lives below the poverty line. About 1.1 billion people in developing countries have inadequate access to water and 2.6 billion lack basic sanitation services. Around 121 million children in the world do not have access to education, while if only one per cent is spent less on the purchase of armaments worldwide, this should be sufficient to send all children to schools globally.

Within this global context of integrated economies and inequalities, there was not much to celebrate on International Human Rights Day this year at both the international and national levels. The unjust social and economic development of the country, with its fast-diminishing capacity to deliver to ensure fundamental rights, protection and security to citizens has progressively deteriorated. Neoliberal economic policies have engendered multiple vulnerabilities in our society. It is the socially weak and marginalised who are affected the most by economic disparities and the poor performance of the state when it comes to ensuring rights of citizens. Those whose rights are at greater risk include the poor in general, women, religious minorities, people with disabilities, IDPs, transgenders, bonded labourers, child labourers, people with HIV/AIDS, sex workers, people in prisons and shelters, and people living in conflict zones and disaster-prone areas.

Women are the single largest group whose fundamental rights are systematically threatened by the state and society. The dual system of patriarchy and capitalism positions them as second class citizens legally and socially. This leads to a low investment in their human capital by the family and the state, and creates the basis for gender disparities. For example only 45 per cent of Pakistani women are literate compared with 69 per cent of men. They have the worst health status in the world. We are losing 276 women per 100,000 live births. Nearly 12 per cent of the burden of disease in the country is due to reproductive health problems.

Women’s participation in the formal economy is only 22 per cent while the majority works in the informal sector where there is no legal cover to ensure labour rights. There is also a gender gap in political participation and representation of women as voters, candidates and representatives. Presently there is not a single women minister in the federal government.

Women’s weak socio-economic position makes them vulnerable to all forms of violence. Domestic violence is rampant, women are killed in the name of tradition and honour, and are even bought and exchanged to settle family disputes. This culture of impunity makes the country one of the most dangerous places to live in for women. Rising conservatism in society further endangers women’s rights of mobility, working and participating in political processes. They are attacked by radicals for seeking education and employment.

Our record regarding the treatment of religious minorities is disgraceful. They are discriminated in public and economic life. The roots of faith-based discrimination, hatred and intolerance lie in the very nature of the Pakistani state. Certain laws in the Constitution discriminate against non-Muslims. There seems to be a correlation between growing militancy and the increasing incidents of discrimination and violence against non-Muslim Pakistanis. Mob violence against the Christian community; kidnapping and abduction of Hindu women and forcefully converting them to Islam by marrying them to Muslim men; Sikhs from Fata being asked to pay jazyia; distribution of hate material targeting Ahamdis and attacking their places of worship happens with complete impunity. The ramification of the state’s policy of supporting and promoting a certain interpretation of faith can be seen in the sectarian violence that is rampant in the country.

People with disabilities constitute 19 per cent of the population and are living with little or no government support. The two per cent quota of jobs meant for them is not implemented. Police brutality against blind people in Lahore who were protesting against this non-implementation recently shocked the nation.

The military operation in Fata has resulted in a humanitarian crisis with well over 5.5 million people having to leave their homes. Currently, there are two million IDPs living in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa. The transgender community is another vulnerable group, which has recently been given citizenship rights. However, they are socially excluded and lack opportunities to integrate in the larger society. They are restricted to certain professions, like singing, begging, dancing and are also forced to engage in sex work due to poverty. This makes them more vulnerable to HIV/AIDS.

Natural disasters have played havoc with lives and adversely affected the country’s economy. The massive earthquake of 2005 left over 83,000 dead, while the devastating flood of 2010 affected 20 million people. Nearly 32.8 million people have been victims of these disasters. Sixty per cent of the poor are living in dire conditions as a result of a neo-liberal economic doctrine. The policies of privatisation, downsizing, liberalization, deregulation and promoting free markets have forced millions into poverty. Within this context of exclusion and marginalization, commemorating the International Day of Human Rights this year seemed like a meaningless exercise.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 13th,  2014.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (16)

  • MA
    Dec 13, 2014 - 12:10AM

    Every coming year will be a meaningless exercise too unless you or somebody suggests a solution. You have bashed every economic and political system that we know of without suggesting what should be done. An easy way out, right?


  • sabi
    Dec 13, 2014 - 12:13AM

    5.5 million IDPs from FATA-hilarious!!.Op-ed is full of flaws.Pakistan lacks serious journalism.


  • Ahmed
    Dec 13, 2014 - 1:11AM

    Humans making laws for other humans. WOW.


  • Rex Minor
    Dec 13, 2014 - 5:07AM

    The author Dr Bari has not only described the most dire situation which the people in Pakistan have been facing especially women, non muslims and the people of KPK tribal population, but also provided statistics in support and highlighted the State direct participation in these crimes against humanity. One could describe the lack of education, the systematic destruction by the military coupled with corrupt political system being the causual factors for the situation in the country, but this will be a quick judgement. There is certainly more than what the naked eye can see, how come that people are so indifferent about the state of affairs?

    Rex Minor


  • observer
    Dec 13, 2014 - 7:23AM

    And yet, Pakistanis are more worried about the drummed-up “atrocities” against Muslims of India!


  • Dilli Ki Billi
    Dec 13, 2014 - 8:25AM

    @Ahmed: Bedouini Koresh creating laws for you and you following it ditto brought you to present state. Do you still want to persist on the path to the cliff?


  • csmann
    Dec 13, 2014 - 9:33AM

    Somebody showing you the mirror is necessarly not obligated to remove your ugliness.


  • Ahmed
    Dec 13, 2014 - 10:21AM

    @Dilli ki billi
    They didn’t make laws for me.


  • Ahmed Ali Khan
    Dec 13, 2014 - 11:09AM

    These NGO’s just give once in a while some dreadful news in the shape of article. Probably to renew the grant from foreign sources. In reality the situation is getting worse every year. If these ngo’s have done anything seriously the situation would have not been that bad as she mentioned.


  • kafir
    Dec 13, 2014 - 2:17PM

    @Dilli ki billi
    They didn’t make laws for me.

    Think about it again. They did it long back and you are blind follower of it.


  • Avtar
    Dec 13, 2014 - 4:23PM

    Dr Bari asserts that ” The policies of privatisation, downsizing, liberalization, deregulation and promoting free markets have forced millions into poverty.” I am not sure if this statement is true. For instance, North and South Korea are both homogeneous societies, more or less equal in number of people in each country. South Korea is prosperous and the people are well off with limited natural resources. Thus it is not only capitalistic framework but the economic, social and political institutions that create prosperity and alleviates poverty. And, North Korea!!!
    Pakistan, along with a lot of Islamic states in the Middle East, have a long way to go to confirm to the UN charter of human rights.


  • Ranjha
    Dec 13, 2014 - 4:42PM

    And some of the responsibility rests squarely on the shoulders of Ms. Bari and her companions who have sold their soul for a fist full of dollars! Utterly despicable.


  • Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur
    Dec 13, 2014 - 10:10PM

    Sadly there is no mention of the atrocities against Baloch or the killing of Hazara people.
    Even a line or two would have done.


  • Dec 13, 2014 - 10:19PM

    @Ranjha: Ranjha Ji, there are very few and I mean I very few educated Pakistani women who continue to enlighten a nation and elites about the Gender discrimination in Pakistan. Pick up any Newspaper, English or Urdu, you will not find a liberal, progressive and enlightened article or debate about the Rights of Women, Gender issues or the social conditions of our Disability Groups in Pakistan, but last several years, Professor Bari continues to provide this opportunity to public readers and also to so many other groups as well, who read the Colonial English Language, to understand the issues, which are being ignored by our Parliament, and Law makers about women and their mistreatment, disrespect in our society. I hope you will agree with me that how to achieve these rights for women, we must first try to understand them first and then we make a plan how to achieve these plans. But in your case, you are not not even being sympathetic to these issues and attacking a messenger. I hope you will start supporting all social and cultural issues which largely are faced everyday by the women of Pakistan in their homes, on streets, in work place and everywhere.


  • raider
    Dec 14, 2014 - 7:52PM

    love to equalize men and women in rights as human being but not to love making men and women equal gender,


  • sadaqat
    Dec 18, 2014 - 12:59PM

    great…….salute to human rights activists and director of the Gender Studies Centre great women of pakistan Dr Farzana barii


More in Opinion