Open online courses: Ready to be MOOCed?

Published: July 20, 2014
Will online courses revolutionise education as we know it?. DESIGN: MUNIRA ABBAS

Will online courses revolutionise education as we know it?. DESIGN: MUNIRA ABBAS

Imagine a world in which every single person on the planet is given free access to the sum of all human knowledge,” said the co-founder of Wikipedia, Jimmy Wales, a decade ago. The idea may have sounded outlandish at the time but has since shaped into a digital reality. Throughout human history, civilisations have attached great importance to education and scholarly pursuits. Numerous higher-learning institutions were established in many cultures — from the Platonic Academy in Greece to Takshashilla (Taxila) in the subcontinent to the Taixue of Han Dynasty and the Gundishapur Academy in Persia. With human progress and the introduction of new technologies, however, the media of imparting knowledge have evolved. From the time when primitive people used hand gestures to convey their messages to the current era of e-learning, this evolution is nothing short of revolutionary. And the latest feather in its cap is the introduction of Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs). 

Understanding MOOCs

A MOOC, as the name suggests, is an online course targeting unrestricted and limitless participation via the internet. Additionally, it also helps build a vibrant online community of students, teachers and researchers for interactive discussions, which are in addition to the traditional course materials such as readings and problem sets. Participation can range from a few hundred to several thousand people engaged simultaneously.

Courses from leading Ivy League institutions such as Harvard, Stanford, MIT and Yale, taught by some of the most prominent names in academia are an example of what MOOCs offer. Almost all MOOCs are free and without any credit, except for those providing a certificate for which a nominal fee is charged. Traditional courses from universities, however, are charged, formally structured and credited. Even though there are no specific prerequisites to join a MOOC, they require the participants to stay up-to-date throughout the programme schedules.

The concept of online learning is fast picking up an audience, which is evident from the spike in enrollment numbers for MOOCs that have escalated from a million in 2012 to over 10 million as of date. The list of subjects offered through MOOCs is extensive, including everything from psychology to computer science to astronomy and history.

The primary components of MOOCs include video lectures, virtual group projects, peer-to-peer assessments and social meet-ups for students belonging to the same geographical area. Timings are flexible and a course can be taken at whatever time is best suited to the student. Moreover, some platforms, such as Coursera, have also added a further option of sub-titling and closed captioning for disabled students. While there is no substitute for live, person-to-person interaction between an instructor and a student, the structure and precision with which MOOCs are designed and delivered compensate for that missing element substantially.

There’s no such thing as a free lunch

Even though MOOCs have taken the world by storm, they have not been spared of criticism. The prime difficulty being faced by MOOC providers is to keep students engaged in online courses. According to research data gathered by Coursera, the course completion rate currently stands at a deplorable 10%. These statistics cast a doubt over the efficiency of a programme that is unable to sustain a major portion of the class.

Upholding academic integrity standards and receiving quality feedback is also problematic due to the massive size of the classes. There is also concern regarding misuse of content when courses uploaded online by professors are used by institutions in some cases as a proxy to traditional classes.

A recent study by Penn University also suggested that 80% of the MOOC users worldwide already have an advanced degree and belong to the upper income echelon — 80% of the students in Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, the largest users of MOOCs, came from the richest six percent of the population, thereby defeating the idea of democratic reach and equal access to education for everyone.

Lack of accreditation for MOOCs is also another issue, as noted by UNESCO in its policy brief. It is important for external educational bodies to recognise and validate the courses in order to be formally recognised by universities and employers.

Is Pakistan ready to be MOOCed?

Most Pakistanis, who grew up during the good old PTV days, would have some recollection of the programmes aired on the channel from time to time, developed by the Allama Iqbal Open University (AIOU), teaching courses such as ‘silk worm farming’, ‘bee-keeping’ and even the famous ‘tractor ki daikh bhaal’ (looking after your tractor). We may not have realised at the time but this was our first encounter with the concept of an ‘open’ institution or ‘distance learning’. It is hence no surprise that AIOU is Asia’s first open university with a course enrollment rate of 3.3 million in 2011.

The potential for MOOCs is massive in the developing world since a huge part of the population cannot afford higher education at leading global institutions. However, one of the dilemmas that prevent it from being used to its maximum is the low rate of internet penetration in countries like Pakistan. Despite the technology boom, Pakistan has only achieved 16% internet penetration to date with a 15 million population online via mobile phone. Any drastic development on this front remains a distant dream as more than half of the country’s population lives below the poverty line. As a result, internet affordability remains an issue for a large segment of the country. While MOOCs may not be able to address plagues such as ghost schools, teacher absenteeism, political influence and lack of quality curriculum that haunt our local educational system, those who have access to the internet and are willing to embark on the journey can bypass these hurdles with the help of MOOCs.

In Pakistan, the Latif Ebrahim Jamal National Science Information Center (LEJ Center) serves as the focal center of the Virtual Education Project Pakistan (VEPP) that is led and supervised by Professor Atta-ur-Rahman, the former chairman of the HEC, in association with Professor M Iqbal Choudhary. The LEJ Centre at the University of Karachi has launched the ‘LEJ Knowledge Hub’, a MOOC platform that is helpful in finding the right courses and also integrates local content such as that developed by Virtual University. “This is probably the most exciting project that I have undertaken in my lifetime, as it can change the landscape of education in Pakistan and in other countries,” says Rahman.

Former information minister and senator, Javed Jabbar, who has also participated in content creation for Virtual University, echoes the same sentiment. “They [MOOCs] represent an enormous leap in expanding access to information, knowledge and education and reducing the vast disparities in the quality of professional capacity-building education that currently exists in Pakistan.” He emphasises that federal and provincial governments, the private sector and public-interest organisations in Pakistan need to enhance their respective levels of awareness of, and support for, MOOCs to make them more widely available to the public.

Cases such as that of Abdullah Ahmad, who works as a finance professional, bear testimony to the relevance of MOOCs for the average Joe. “When I was growing up and my family could hardly keep up with the tuition fee at Pakistani universities, Yale was so far away, it was not even a distant dream. But through a MOOC I enrolled in via Coursera, I was able to attend a course on financial markets conducted by their ace professor Robert J Shiller.”

Similarly, Muhammad Ali, a Karachi-based banker, was able to explore his love for astronomy through MOOCs. “I did not have the time to pursue my love for astronomy, as there were no institutions in Pakistan imparting cutting-edge knowledge on the subject and I didn’t know what I would do if I studied it,” he says. But technology has finally enabled him to study astronomy from institutions such as Duke and Princeton from the comfort of his home, for free. “I feel like I am already over the moon.”

MOOCs can also help raise the bar for education in Pakistan if they are made part of the university curriculum, states Dr Javed Leghari, also a former HEC chairman, in his opinion piece. Students should be registered for MOOC credit courses, classes should be arranged in a traditional classroom environment under tutor supervision and proctored exams and independendent quizzes administered by the university should be conducted in addition to the MOOC assessment. Currently though, Pakistanis have little choice when it comes to participating in MOOCs since many rely on video lectures on YouTube which is still completely banned in Pakistan.

A knowledge-based future?

While Pakistan is still struggling with the basics, there is plenty of innovation taking place in the MOOCs market globally. Recently, a UNESCO moot ended up experimenting with MOOCs on mobile phones, opening up a new dimension called MobiMOOC, which may be used to set up courses for a wide audience. The layout and media of MobiMOOC permits the use of regional languages and a variety of mobile and static devices, allowing the course format to be moulded according to a variety of regions.

Such advancements should be welcomed since knowledge sharing has always accelerated the progress of humankind. The continuous stream of learning traditions from the ancient and classical civilisations of Greece, Rome, China, India and Persia has immensely helped develop the world as we know it today. While the path that MOOCs seek is a lot more even in terms of access to academic resources, it is not completely devoid of potholes — the merits of conveyed knowledge versus a well-rounded education may continue to be debated for many years to come. But maybe that is just one more indication of how much we have yet to learn.

MOOCs development

MOOCs are a recent development in distance education which began to emerge in 2012. Below is a timeline of MOOC development.

In May 2013, a first ever MOOC-based Master degree programme was announced as collaboration between Georgia Institute of Technology and Udacity. This, however, isn’t free but comes at a price tag of $7,000.

MOOC major players
There is a lot of collaboration going on in the global market when it comes to MOOCs. Several universities and professors are currently engaged in offering online courses. While some colleges are starting their own initiatives, some are offering their courses through other platforms. Top names in the field are:

edX is a joint venture being run by Harvard, MIT and Berkeley. edX intends to add other university partners over the course of time and to make the platform open ware so that anyone can use it to provide MOOCs. edX is a non-profit entity with 2.5 million users and more than 200 courses being offered.

Coursera is a for-profit venture that provides a platform to universities and colleges to offer free courses. A percentage of any revenue that comes from ‘verified’ course participation at a nominal price and uses biometric and type-pattern recognition technology to identify students goes to Coursera. These ‘verified’ enrollments are issued an e-certificate upon successful recognition. Coursera has more than seven million users and works with 108 partners that include Yale and Johns Hopkins.

Udacity employs individual professors rather than working with universities and is able to attract renowned scholars. The focus of Udacity is in the field of computer sciences. Currently, it has 1.6 million users enrolled in 38 courses.

Khan Academy was established by an MIT graduate as a non-profit online library housing short tutorials but later attracted funding from Google and Melinda & Bill Gates Foundation. Khan Academy lectures have received more than 440 million views but it does not have any arrangement to provide material from universities and much of the content is related to secondary education.

Iversity is a multi-lingual platform which works with professors to provide free and open courses online. It intends to target one million users in 2014 with over 100 courses. Moreover, it allows anyone to upload a course and charge a nominal fee, which is later split with Iversity.

Adil Mulki works for a private bank and is interested in the outdoors, wildlife and science. He can be reached at [email protected]

Adnan Rizvi is a banker and an investment analyst. He tweets @syedadnanrizvi

Published in The Express Tribune, Sunday Magazine, July 20th,  2014.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (19)

  • mohsin
    Jul 20, 2014 - 1:37PM

    The author should have also mentioned the MIT OCW, itunes U and also NPTEL. Although for some they may not satisfy the definition of MOOC but I think they make a great learning resource.
    Also there is a “FutureLearn” from British universities.
    Too bad one can not access video lectures from mit edx and NPTEL because of youtube ban in Pakistan.


  • Sham
    Jul 20, 2014 - 3:54PM

    Started reading this article, then scrolled down and saw the length of it. Then refused to read further. ET needs to have a word limit to keep the audience engaged.


  • Khan
    Jul 20, 2014 - 8:26PM

    Stanford and MIT are not Ivy League schools. The Ivy League is just an athletic conference in the Northeastern USA. Several world class schools like Stanford, MIT, Duke and Chicago are not members of the Ivy League because of their geographical locations. Do some research in the future.


  • Deeds
    Jul 20, 2014 - 10:04PM

    Pakistan seriously needs to take full advantage of online courses and other new modes of learning – we can catch up fast because we have these new tools at our disposal BUT do we have the VISION and the POLITICAL WILL?Recommend

  • Jul 20, 2014 - 11:44PM

    MOOC is a popular concept.
    But only set up by MIT and Harvard is worthwhile .
    edx provides online courses same as on campus courses. That means academically same value . EDXs non profit. Only missing link is degrees.
    If edx provides degrees millions will enroll in edx .
    Convince edx to provide degrees, write to Dr Anant Agarwal and say
    ” please provide degrees and charge $ 100-200 per course ”


  • shiraz
    Jul 21, 2014 - 11:17AM

    thanks adil; a very well articulated and rich with information


  • Asma Inayat
    Jul 21, 2014 - 12:33PM

    Nicely constructed article on Online open learning resources. Especially in a place like Pakistan where Education has become a normalcy and fallacy it is essential for the go-getters and knowledge thirsty individuals to make something off their lives.

    Good Going :)


  • Muniba
    Jul 22, 2014 - 1:14PM

    Well researched article, and truly people need to tap these portals specially those who are always keen to add feathers of learning something unique and additional to their existing knowledge Inventory….

    Overall Good Work!!


  • Hiba Asif
    Jul 22, 2014 - 1:16PM

    Very well placed article with insight that is not easily accessible by everyone and nor do people give any importance to it.Recommend

  • Ahmed
    Jul 22, 2014 - 1:36PM

    A very detailed article on the concept of Online Courses. With the fast paced environment , the need of the hour is to have online tutorials and classes so that we are upto date with new learnings. Very well written article Keep it up!



  • Aleena ahsan
    Jul 22, 2014 - 2:16PM

    Nice sysnopsis of MOOCs. A point well raised in the article that in countries with less Internet Penetration, like Pakistan, efficacy of such programs decline automatically. I wonder what percentage of Pakistan Population uses MOOCs. And those who do, how many of them completes them till the end.


  • Hammad
    Jul 23, 2014 - 9:03AM

    Distance Learning and online education, though is not an alternative to conventional teaching and learning; however, they are an important tool to impart knowledge without the traditional hinderances of time, place and environment.
    WIth the advent and dayd by day advancement of IT infrstructure and its use in different disciplines inclduing pedagogical procedures, the world is seamlessly squeezing with people coming closure and more connected.
    Well-articulated and well researched content!Recommend

  • Adil Mulki
    Jul 23, 2014 - 11:24AM

    Dear All,
    i) Thanks for your feedback. It is helpful in improving quality of future output.

    ii) As far as Ivy League Institutions are concerned, Stanford and MIT might not be Ivy League, BUT Harvard, Princeton, Yale and Columbia and the other four, all offer MOOCs.

    iii) Further, a comment by Mr. Javed Jabbar got ‘edited’ out in the final version, perhaps due to some miscommunication.

    He had expressed that “While the live, person-to-person interaction between student/trainee and teacher/instructor is ideal and preferable, the structure and precision with which MOOCs are designed and delivered substantially compensate for that missing element.”

    I fully agree with his views that live, person-to-person interaction between student and instructor is ideal and preferable. However, limited availability of resources (time / money) might prevent such interaction and that is where MOOCs are ideal.

    Adil Mulki


  • Adil Mulki
    Jul 23, 2014 - 2:56PM

    In a recent communication, Mr. Martin Schmucker from iversity stated:

    “…We collaborate with universities and individual professors only, and don’t let anyone upload their resources. This is the only way we can assure the quality of our courses. The professors invest a lot of time to produce the courses including all elements such as videos, tests, exams and more. The courses are and always will be free, however we’re monetizing via paid certificates that can be purchased at the end of a free course. After a MOOC, the money for certificates is split up between the professors and iversity…”

    He also shared that many Pakistanis are on their platform and expressed his willingness to help spread awareness about MOOCs.
    Adil Mulki


  • Arsalan
    Jul 30, 2014 - 5:41PM

    Great Stuff Adil! I’ve done a few myself and can vouch for the fantastic precision and delivery of the courses. I hope and pray, these are used by more and more.


  • uzma
    Oct 22, 2014 - 10:50PM

    I have done one with PIAL-PRIA Academy of Life Long Learning which was a very good experience of distance learning. Now i am doing one with Iversity. Most important thing about these types of online courses is that you get a chance to interact with people from different geographical, social and cultural and educational background as there is no strict eligibility or selection criteria for the students for the enrollment of course.
    From Islamabad


  • Oct 23, 2014 - 2:02AM

    My dear Pakistani faculties

    Get smarter than American universities .

    Get our students take courses from EDX , MITi Harvard, Stanford, Johns Hopkins + many more , have your own exams on Campus then if students fulfill all requirements of the degree , award them a degree of your university .

    1.- Quality is perfect
    2.- Fee is nothing free
    3.- No limit, all students can attend
    4.- Go best universities of the World from your home

    Since most Pakistanies speak English no problem of English at all .

    Get smart. Be the first University to provide DEGREES for EDX courses

    Best regards


  • Oct 23, 2014 - 2:06AM

    Provide degrees from your university for edx courses .
    Do your own exam on your campus .
    If a student finish 40 courses provide him with a BA degree .


  • Oct 23, 2014 - 2:11AM

    @Adil Mulki:
    Important thing is ” WHO provides the knowledge “

    Face to face and online are methods of teaching .

    For f2f you need the best teachers of the World , for how many students ???

    In case of online best teachers of the World can Access to millions of students .

    Plus how muıch personel nteraction you can have in a 50 minutes class time in a room , sometimes with 300 students in it .


More in Magazine