The writer is editorial consultant at The Express Tribune, news junkie, bibliophile, cat lover and occasional cyclist
Looking at the image on the Facebook page triggered memories of other pictures of trees bearing unnatural fruits. From the American Deep South, of two black men, their arms smashed to stop them trying to climb the ropes that had strangled them. The crowd, many facing the camera, were gleeful, happy, having a good time with their smiles picked out by the flash. America again — a man hung after boiling pitch had been poured over him and again the throng, the spectators and possibly the murderers, celebrants at the blackest of masses.
Behind the picture of the lynched girls, there was a lack of toilets. They had gone to the field because there was no latrine at their house. The men who killed them would have been well aware of this. There would need to be several of them to do what they did — four or more. They would have, perhaps, pre-planned to the point of obtaining the rope they used to finally kill the girls. Perhaps, they bought it at a local shop.
They raped the girls before they killed them and then chose to put their bodies on display as trophy or a warning — it is impossible to know. But they made a conscious decision to advertise their act. There was no attempt to hide the bodies. These were proud men, confident in their immunity to the law and due process.
Sideslip westwards to Lahore, Pakistan, and a bloodied pavement close to a courthouse where a pregnant woman was beaten to death by her family because she married the man of her choice rather than theirs. A tangled story emerged. Her grieving husband had killed his first wife to clear the way for marrying the now-dead woman.
A crowd was present at the killing. Cellphones took pictures of it as it happened. The police were notable — either for their absence or their failure to intervene to protect the woman. No member of the public attempted to prevent the killing.
The murder in Lahore may not have been pre-planned in the way that the murder of the girls in India was, but the ever-present latency was sparked by the moment, and two lives snuffed out by blows to the head with a brick.
Behind these pictures, there is a common image and a shared curse. Whether lynched or beaten to death, the women shared the curse of being women. The men shared the curse of not being white. The women are commodities to use and discard, the men objects of hatred and marginalisation.
The two cultures — subcontinental and American — may be a world apart, but the underlying sense they share is that some lives are cheaper, less worthy than others, and that taking those lives is a matter not only of little consequence but overt joie-de-vivre; lives reduced to a sordid and terrifying ambush in a field, or the blinding flash that would have been the last thing that the woman in Lahore saw before there came a blessed darkness and the end of pain.
It is anecdotally said that America has gone from barbarism to decadence without passing through civilisation along the way. Civilisations are vast, civilised man being a rarity within that vastness. And the barbarism that is the precursor to civilisation never goes away — in large part because not enough people want it to.
Published in The Express Tribune, June 5th, 2014.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (4)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1725612926-0/Tribune-Pic-(8)1725612926-0-165x106.webp "article")
*/The two cultures — subcontinental and American — may be a world apart, but the underlying sense they share is that some lives are cheaper, less worthy than others, and that taking those lives is a matter not only of little consequence but overt joie-de-vivre;..
It is anecdotally said that America has gone from barbarism to decadence without passing through civilisation along the way. Civilisations are vast, civilised man being a rarity within that vastness. And the barbarism that is the precursor to civilisation never goes away — in large part because not enough people want it to./*
America jumping from barbarism to decadence, skipping civilization is a bit of stretch. The ending of this article is a distraction from the issue of having no easy solution for what ails the subcontinent in the present times. How to become civilized enough to not tolerate marginalization of 50% of the human species? That is the big gorrilla in the room. Forget MURICA.
I felt compelled to read your article slowly and digest what you have to say....and then sit back and reflect on it. To comment on such a vast subject in a few lines would be unjust.
Thank you Chris for an evocative article. America has moved on, there are no more lynchings. I wonder how many decades before we in Pakistan also move on to being a better people. Right now it seems like our darkest days.
One day, we will be free of the mumbo jumbo of dogma and use rationality and common sense, and that is the day we won't have such horrors as murder in the name of "honor", or killing someone just because of a perceived slight. Until then, Pakistan is worse than a jungle.
A good article free from prejudices. Yes its true every civilization eastern or western has its share of evil. The problem arises when we use human rights to achieve political aims and to justify our own goods and bads. In simple words pick and choose whose human rights protection benefits politically and whose not. For example the plight of Burmese Muslims never been on anybody's agenda as it doesn't serve anybody's interest(no oil in Burma either). Its just an example as you also find no memorial of native Americans but several other memorials.