In an anticipated move, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has asked Pakistan to increase interest rates after the inflation inched up to 9.2% in April on a year-on-year basis, hitting a point from where it had started receding seven months ago.
The bad news for Pakistan is that the Consumer Price Index inflation in April increased to 9.2% from 8.5% in March, according to a tweet by IMF_Pakistan, an account being managed by the Resident Representative Office of the IMF.
Bad news on inflation: CPI inflation in April 2014 increased to 9.2% from 8.5% in March. http://t.co/5aKYapVzi6
— IMF Pakistan (@imf_pakistan) May 3, 2014
The IMF has aired its views at a time when the Fund and Pakistani authorities are locked into negotiations in Dubai for the third review of a $6.7-billion programme. Any decision on increasing the interest rates will be taken during policy level talks that will begin next week. At present both the sides are engaged in technical level talks, meant to exchange data with each other.
The policy level talks will be attended by Finance Minister Ishaq Dar and newly appointed Governor State Bank of Pakistan Ashraf Mahmood Wathra.
The decision to go public on the issue by the IMF may bring the government under pressure, particularly at a time when the authorities are discussing such issues behind closed doors.
The IMF said that the trimmed core inflation also increased to 9% year-on-year in April from 8.1% in March. “The SBP monetary policy needs to respond,” according to the IMF.
Trimmed core inflation also increased to 9.0% yoy from 8.1% in March 2014. SBP monetary policy needs to respond.
— IMF Pakistan (@imf_pakistan) May 3, 2014
The trimmed core inflation is a measure used to identify trend in inflation by eliminating items from the index showing sudden changes.
The core inflation, measured by excluding energy and food items, also increased to 8.5% in April as compared to 7.6% in March, according to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics –the national data collecting agency.
The overall energy prices were going down and the inflationary pressure was coming from the core side, strengthening the case of the IMF for an increase in interest rates.
The IMF’s demand to increase the interest rate has come ahead of new monetary policy that the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) is expected to announce by mid of this month. The demand is contrary to the hopes given by Deputy Governor SBP Saeed Ahmad, who had said that last month that the industrialists would soon hear good news on the interest rate.
In its last announcement on monetary policy, the SBP had kept the rate unchanged at 10%.
As CPI-based inflation has gone up to 9.2%, the real interest rate – the difference between the monetary policy rate and inflation, has come down to just 0.8%. The real interest rate is an important factor that foreign investors consider before taking any decision on investing in a country.
Sources said the IMF is demanding a minimum 100 basis points or 1% increase in interest rates, as it considers half a percentage point increase in the interest rates ineffective in controlling inflation. The ministry of finance would try to downplay the increase by terming it a seasonal phenomenon, they added.
It is yet to be seen whether the government will accept the IMF’s view point, as it has so far shown the tendency to appease the industrialists.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 4th, 2014.
Like Business on Facebook, follow @TribuneBiz on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.
COMMENTS (14)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Isnt increasing the interest on PKR going to increase interest rate differential between USD & PKR thereby driving PKR down and USD up? I thought it operates like this?
pray tell me what's imf pakistan doing on twitter!!!???
@ SY
True. But there is a totally opposite perspective as well where higher interest rates contain inflation and hence improve country's RPI (domestic inflation relative to trading partners' inflation) and competitiveness (decreasing REER) reflected in higher exchange rates.
Interest rate kay chaaker may karachi stock ko maren gay
@Ali
You forgot to attend the classes for basic economics. If govt agrees then pkr will go UP (and not DOWN) and usd will go DOWN and not ABOVE 100. But then economics is not a forte of SBP or of pak govt or of you.
@A Reliable Source Inflation has more negative impact on investments than rising rates. Especially since your country needs foreign exchange - rising rates will always drive in more foreign currency and rising inflation will drive out more foreign currency.
@Saleem: The only measure that can make a dent in inflation is to reduce government expenditure. Not going to happen, is it? So interest rates we must raise.
@king Julian: It is legit. See the twitter link here:
https://www.imf.org/external/country/PAK/rr/index.htm
Rise in interest rate definitely puts pressure on exchange rate to depreciate (for Pak rupee to appreciate) but it may have its costs through adversely impacting the investment.
@ali: I don't see why that should be the case. If monetary authorities in Pakistan raise interest rates, that would make local assets more attractive to investors, all else staying equal, who should then demand Pak rupees and supply dollars to the local market, causing further appreciation of the PKR.
Pakistan needs to choose between inflation and lackluster economy. What IMF is suggesting is indeed a textbook recipe to control inflation but is a disaster for economy. IMF doesn't have any proven record of helping any country in world. But unfortunately it is the last resort for countries to borrow money or go bankrupt. Pakistan needs to adopt other measures to control inflation rather than listening to IMF and increase interest rate.
Yaar tribune check tu kerlo if @imf_pakistan is real or not
so it means (if govt agrees) pkr is going down and usd will be above 100 and starts its halted march to new highs
I find it funny how twitter is now being used to pressure governments. Anybody else find it funny? I guess the Turks already learned this lesson sometime ago.
We are experiencing high inflation because of the massive borrowing from the State Bank of Pakistan by the government (because of course they cannot go after tax evasion). So now, they will have to increase the interest rate that will depress the already anemic growth rate. Congratulations my fellow Pakistanis, after the rigged elections, Roshan Pakistan here.