The court had reserved its verdict in May last year.
The SHC acquitted Lance Naik Liaquat Ali while upheld earlier life imprisonment sentences for Sub-Inspector Bahur Rehman, constable Mohammad Tariq, constable Minthar Ali, constable Mohammad Afzal and private contractor Afsar Khan and death penalty for Rangers official Shahid Zafar. An anti-terrorism court on August 12, 2011 had handed down these sentences.
Shah was shot twice by the Rangers personnel and was left to die in the Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park in Clifton on June 8, 2011.
Initially, the Rangers had claimed to have killed a robber in an encounter but their claim was refuted after a video footage, incidentally recorded by a private TV channel’s cameraman, was televised nationwide.
The victim’s family had decided to forgive all of them in the name of God.
Shaukat Hayat, the lawyer representing Zafar, had argued that his client had no intention to kill the youth, as visible in the video, but that he had accidentally fired the shot that resulted in Shah’s death.
COMMENTS (17)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Ch. Allah Daad
Thanks for spreading hate speech...
@ Ch A. Daad Right the rangers are not from Karachi that's why they donot care for the this city , they are here to just get rich .
@nadeem: Would you say same for Musharaf? These rangers are punished because they are poor and they are not from Karachi.
@Tanzeel: This was cold blooded murder, pointing the gun to his face who was unarmed. You dont fire 2 shots accidently.
What rule of law? This was, at best, a case of manslaughter, not murder, and by awarding the death penalty for manslaughter, the judiciary has done nothing other than strengthen it's populist credentials. What message does this send? If the public sentiment is strong enough, we'll go with it whether it's right or wrong, legal or illegal?
@Khan: and they let him die in-front of there eyes n did nothing to save Sarfaraz......
"Accidentally fired"???
Execute at every cost.
The last hope for rule of law in this country. Thank you Judiciary.
@nadeem : where was rule of law, human rights and your civilian supremacy on shahzab murder case...
Faith in Justice restored!
A good day for Rule of Law, for Human Rights, and for Civilian Supremacy.
Thank you SHC.