This country is currently ruled by an ethnically-dominant establishment and anyone who dares to speak or demand truth, justice and fair treatment is deemed a ‘traitor’, ‘foreign agent’ and an ‘enemy of the state’, and treated with brute and inhuman methods, such as enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killing and collective punishment.
Balochistan, being the least populated province, has suffered immensely. Contemporary accounts of human rights violations and killings of political activists, leaders, human rights defenders and journalists are shocking. From 2002 to 2013, thousands of people have gone missing in Balochistan and nearly 800 tortured bodies of Baloch activists have been recovered from different parts of the province. In stark contrast, the number of missing persons reported from Punjab is negligible, even though the province is home to some of the deadliest extremist outfits.
On December 20, 2013, Pakistan’s interior minister, in a written reply to the Senate, tried his best to conceal the facts when replying to Dr Karim Ahmed Khawaja’s question concerning the number of missing persons in the country since 2001 with a province-wise break-up and mutilated bodies found during the said period. A vague reply was prepared by the interior ministry, with no substantive data given. Despite the tall promises made by this government of ending brutal practices, it is complicit in hiding shocking facts related to extra-judicial killings.
It seems that ending enforced disappearances is not a priority for the government and the security establishment because Punjab is unaffected by them. Enforced disappearances are a socio-physiological trauma not limited to affected family members but are also used as a method of collective harassment to create mass fear. Our country has turned into a hell for religious minorities, sects and ethnic groups. Unrepresented in the country’s powerful establishment, the Baloch are on receiving end when it comes to human rights violations. To some extent, Sindhis and Pashtuns are also bearing the brunt.
Today, Balochistan with its cosmetic government is nearly a volcano of human sufferings and emotions. Although countless women and men are not part of the rallies and the long marches because of unprecedented intimidation and threats, each and every Baloch family has been affected.
As hopes for the recovery of ‘disappeared’ persons fade, relatives of individuals subjected to enforced disappearances continue to suffer hardships, isolation and despair, in some cases made worse by threats and false promises from government officials. Causing such sufferings to family members of disappeared persons is also a human rights violation.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 29th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (21)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Zahid Khan:
Really? I know some folks can read hands but never knew that some can even read the mind+set & at the same time give doctrine on Cold War era geopolitics. Wow!
Whats is the make-up / break-up of the Indian Armed forces, American Armed forces, Israeli Armed Forces, heck, just fill me about the Swiss Armed Forces??
regards,
Thanks for highlighting the situation. Establishment trolls won't under stand that Pakistan is not a monolith country and that is beauty of it. They are trying to make it monolith country with force so that they can can exploit the resources of smaller provinces . Fortunately they cannot occupy whole Baloch through settlers.
A really good Article by Sana Sahab. Up to the point and a bold attempt to question the dominant establishment..
@Lal Din: The facts prove the ethnically dominant establishment.. Just check the ethnic breakup of all armed forces of Pakistan... Even the FC Balochistan is manned by outsiders...
@Asad Khan: You represent the truth denying mindset that is responsible for fall of Dhaka...
With due respect if Baloch and Sind his stop providing gad - Pun jab wouldn't be able to produce 10% of current it's agricultural production. We are thankless - we have to give Baloch what they want - colonisation don't work any more.
@rasgullah: Please explain this so-called genocide with some facts and figures ...
Good article. Pakistan is moving towards the grave yard of Sindhi-es and Balochis. on one hand forced disappearance and extra judicial killing is at peak, on other hand state sponsors religious extremism in our areas by funding Mullahs. State sponsored version of Islam made our societies paralyzed. Provincial autonomy is today's need to save this federation.
State certainly should respect all its citizens and we share the pain of our countrymen in Balochistan but like it has been said earlier: What about non-Balochs being mowed down in cold blood, never heard him condemn those who perpatrate such atrocities.
@Asad Khan: Keep trying harder. I'm one day sure you will succeed in using the right words at the right times. Calling Mr. Sana Baloch immature is, how shall I put it - Cute.
Mr. Baloch has made some excellent points, especially regarding the establishment usurping the rights of the people of all three smaller provinces. But what about the rights of the so-called settlers? Why not the writer condemn atrocities committed against them? I hope that will be a topic for another week. Anyway, keep writing Mr. Baloch. You are a true son of the soil and a voice of the oppressed, not just for people of Balochistan but also those from other provinces too who have been oppressed by the establishment.
We don't feel ashamed and responsible. We compelled majority Bengalis to succeed now pushing ethnic minorities such as Baloch to quit Pakistan. We are a nation in deep moral depression.
Good Sir for highlighting the plight of ethnic Arabs(Balochis) at the hands of Scythian Sakas.I hope you do what is "necessary".
The UN security Council should take note of this and world should help end the genocide in Balochistan.
I agree with this a lot, but I doubt Punjabis would.
Times change.
Lethargic, Delusional, Chieftain Nationalistic Politics has now no place in today's Balochistan Mr Ex Senator, there are no buyers left for your outdated & out of touch Mea culpa. Plz grown up or find another tune for the trumpet.
regards,
Dear senator, the punjabis living in bluchistan are also a minority. Please write an article on suffering of that minority too. Dont tell lies. Can u condemn the maltratment meted out to them ?
It is sad but the primary assertion (ethnically dominant establishment) need some further probe. Let us not mix facts with stereotypes.
Well written account of human rights violations - 2013 is departing with horrific facts that Balochistan is a modern day colony and will remain on receiving end.
Mr. Sana Baloch: Your piece is always touching and based on the facts.We as citizen of Pakistan has deep concern and sympathies with the families thos have lost their dear one. As you have mentioned about the cosmetic provencial governmnet yourself there is no need to say about Balochistan's crisis. In fact, the provincial government has always been equally responsible for wrongdoing and it must be admitted.State's elite get support by the provincial government. No doubt, the current government made promises to remove greivance of the Baloch people and so far has not met its words.The resilience of people is an evidence that they are strong enough and tolerating repression for a long time. Providing prtection and security to the citizen is the state's responsiblity.In Balochistan's case it seems State has been completely failed and paralized.