The majority seemed to converge on two points: that he is exceptionally talented and is young, with a good amount of cricket stamina left in him.
This school of thought seems to believe that the young fast-bowler should be given a second chance to play sooner than the expiration of the five-year ban imposed by the International Cricket Council (ICC).
Fans are fans and they will always want to see their heroes in action at any cost, so they can’t be blamed for their emotions. But the authorities that are administering the game have a greater responsibility. Their role should be to refrain from transmitting a one-sided opinion. If a cricket board chief hints at having a soft corner for a player, then it should not be appreciated.
The aforementioned points that are playing their role in seeing Amir’s early return to the field are not persuasive enough for me. I disagree with statements like “he is very young and was trapped” simply because he was not young enough in terms of the experience he carried under his belt.
My question to everyone is — what if Amir was not exceptionally talented? Would your reaction have still been the same?
By incessantly talking about Amir’s return, the Pakistan cricket authorities are indicating to the world that we are probably short of talent in Pakistan or willing to compromise ethics for cricketing gains. What this does, combined with our previous indiscretions, is raise questions about whether talent is the only decisive factor when considering the fate of a player involved in malpractice.
Amir mentioned in his first interview to Sky News that since he was “not used to bowling no-balls” he had to practise rigorously before he was able to make those notorious deliveries at Lord’s. Here, I agree with him, because his track record suggests the same — 14 tests and 24 no-balls — but one wonders what happened in his seventh Test match, where he over-stepped 13 times.
Keeping this point in mind, I would like to remind you all about the incident where Amir was seen talking on his mobile phone during a domestic match in Pakistan and was also penalised for it. Therefore, describing him as completely innocent and only a victim of the trap allegedly set by former skipper Salman Butt and others, is not an argument I am willing to digest so easily.
If the environment is deliberately being moulded in Amir’s favour, then this shows that either we, in Pakistan, are short of talent and don’t believe that there is another Amir present in the entire country, or we don’t want Amir to open up any further so that any other possible culprit can remain unharmed.
If, at the end of the day, the Pakistan Cricket Board or the ICC want to cleanse the game of cricket from corruption once and for all, then the ‘zero-tolerance’ motto must be implemented in its true letter and spirit.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 15th, 2013.
Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.
COMMENTS (6)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I met Amir when they visited New Zealand in 2009-10. He was just a kid. Coming from a very humble background, he was thrust on the world stage with so much popularity and glamour. It must had been difficult for him to cope with all these pressures. And I also believe that as a nation, it's our fault as well. We don't teach our kids the virtues of honesty and truthfulness. We have privileged money over morality and good deeds. He simply was reflecting our society our value system. Why just blame him? Let's all of us accept our share of the blame.
Theek kaha hai aap nay. Shabaash! In a short span of 3 years, Pakistan now has one of the best bowling attacks in the world. No dearth of talent here; we only lack ability to take hard decisions for the betterment of the country in the long run.
Forget the three damaging cricket, they damaged PAKISTAN's reputation. By providing a place in the team will further damage PAKISTANI reputation.
couldn't agree more. confessions by the trio who initially shamelessly denied accusations and dubbed the whole thing as a "conspiracy" against Pakistan cricket, deserve no leniency. They damaged cricket, defiled and tarnished the image of our country and also befooled whole nation who despite clear proofs sided with their stars throughout the case proceedings.
I totally agree. No matter whatever the circumstances/situation/excuse are, talent should NEVER be given preference over principles.