In the first spell of monsoon rains to hit the metropolis, the city wore the look of an overflowing drain as the authorities failed put into effect any measures for damage control. As commuters faced delays and 16 people in the city lost their lives, the only concrete step taken by the Sindh government was to sack Karachi Metropolitan Corporation Administrator, Syed Hashim Raza Zaidi.
Sindh Chief Minister Syed Qaim Ali Shah, taking notice of the post-rain mismanagement - or the lack thereof - sacked Zaidi and Municipal Services Director, Masood Alam soon after the downpour started.
In a press briefing late Saturday night, Shah also declared a state of emergency across the province and directed the provincial departments and district administrations to remain alert and assist in evacuation and provide relief to the affectees.
With events escalating quickly as most areas in the city stood inundated in knee-deep rainwater, the local bodies turned to the armed forces for assistance as army personnel were called in to assist the local bodies in their efforts to counter the devastation.
Karachi commissioner, Shoaib Ahmed Siddiqui, told The Express Tribune that the army had been called for assistance in some of the worst-hit areas. “The situation has definitely taken a turn for the worse. We have declared an emergency and are using all our resources to assert control over the situation,” he said.
KMC’s CBA union president, Syed Zulfiqar Shah, was of the view that the municipality had failed to deliver an effective contingency plan despite the fact that the Met office had forecasted heavy rainfalls at the start of the monsoon season. “They have not paid their employees a single penny since the last four months. How can they expect the workers to continue their work?” he asked.
Siddiqui, on the other hand, said that, “It is true that Met office forecasted rain on Friday night. The forecast, however, was only for 11 mm. We were not prepared for this scale of heavy rainfall.”
The sacked KMC municipal services director, Masood Alam, while talking to The Express Tribune, however, refused to take the blame for the disastrous situation and claimed that it was not his responsibility to clear the encroachments along the nullahs. “These cursed rains have caused all this havoc. I am still sitting in my office as I cannot leave the city in this situation” he said.
With the highest rainfall recorded in North Karachi at 126.2mm and the lowest at 39.8 at the Airport, the city stood paralysed as major thoroughfares and junctions were inundated by rain water causing major trouble for the commuters who desperately tried in vain to reach their respective destinations.
The civic agencies, including the cantonment boards, Defence Housing Authority, Karachi Metropolitan Corporation, Karachi Electric Supply Corporation, and Karachi Water and Sewerage Board stood by while the heavy downpour wreaked havoc into the lives of the general populace, thereby exposing their incompetence and failure to address the situation.
Citizens’ plight
“There were no visible efforts to drain the overflowing water,” cried a citizen, Salman Ahmed who claimed to have been stuck at the Sakhi Hassan roundabout for about an hour. “A large number of vehicles have broken down in the middle of the roads. Most areas are plunged in darkness as the electric feeders have tripped. Despite all the inconvenience, there were no traffic police officials or KMC workers in sight. It seems we have been left to fend for ourselves in this ‘dark’ hour,” he lamented.
The Traffic DIG, Khaliq Sheikh, however, told The Express Tribune, that adequate personnel were deployed to tackle the traffic. He negated claims that traffic police was absent from the roads. “The problems occurred due to the heavy flooding which caused the cars’ engines to stop,” said Sheikh, adding that the traffic police provided all the assistance in their power to people whose cars had stopped working. “We could only help them bring their vehicles to the roadsides because we have no mechanics to fix cars for the people.”
Meanwhile, the schedules for trains were also disturbed as three trains, including the Karachi-bound Tezgam, Pakistan Express and Lahore-bound Shalimar Express reached were late due to the rain. “Pakistan Express arrived five hours late, while the Tezgam will depart two hours late from Karachi Cantt Station,” said Karachi Cantt station manager, Rafiq Baloch.
Owais Muzaffar inspects affected areas
The provincial minister for local bodies, Owais Muzaffar, accompanied by the Sindh Information Minister Sharjeel Memon visited different areas of Karachi and suspended several officers over their inefficiency in carrying out cleanliness work. He warned the administrators of the five DMCs of suspension if the cleanliness of nullahs was not conducted properly.
The minister also inspected the cleanliness of main drainage lines in different areas of the city, including Saddar, Zaibun Nissa Street, MA Jinnah road, Nursery, Tariq road, PECHS society, Bahhdurabad, Muhammad Ali Society, Natha Khan goth, Drig Road, Rashid Minhas Road, Gulistan-e-Juhar, Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Hassan Square, Nipa Chowrangi, Liaqatabad, Malir, North Nazimabad, Nazimabad, Bufferzone, Hydery, Sakhi Hassan, University Road and Kamran Chowrangi.
In his speech during the visit, the minister strongly criticised the KMC administrator Syed Hashim Raza Zaidi, Municipal services director, Masood Alam, and executive engineer, Chaudhry Shahid, over their failure to implement the rain emergency plan.
Muzaffar said that the government will make all efforts for cleanliness of the city and utilise all its resources to provide immediate relief to the citizens.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 4th, 2013.
COMMENTS (23)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@ SyedPk Such hamesha karwa hi lagta haiy. Truth is always bitter. Start accepting the facts. Reality will never change. Otherwise reap the seeds that you sow. KWSB has been under MQM control since 1990's. Farooq Sattar was the mayor of Karachi. These problems should have been dealt then. The tone of your comment actually projects that you are either Mustafa Kamal or someone from MQM media cell.
the man who was involved in land grabbing in Karachi...has been made the minister of Local bodies..PPP has made city of light to city of garbage and target killing during it 5 years rule
@Nadir: And they can't comment on tribune too. No laptop or internet in those areas too
@Pappoo: "when he will sack himself?" . When the century ends.
Why is Tappi visiting different areas of the city. If he contests election from Karachi he is sure to lose.We dont want him in Karachi. Please let the real representatives of Karachi serve its people. Nothing else will work.
"The minister also inspected the cleanliness of main drainage lines in different areas of the city, including Saddar, Zaibun Nissa Street, MA Jinnah road, Nursery, Tariq road, PECHS society, Bahhdurabad, Muhammad Ali Society, Natha Khan goth, Drig Road, Rashid Minhas Road, Gulistan-e-Juhar, Gulshan-e-Iqbal, Hassan Square, Nipa Chowrangi, Liaqatabad, Malir, North Nazimabad, Nazimabad, Bufferzone, Hydery, Sakhi Hassan, University Road and Kamran Chowrangi." And where were the KMC top officials and their engineering, cleaning crew? When a civilian new minister can go to this many places why did the fat cats of KMC not move? These officials are rich and never worked in their entire life. Try getting a death certificate from KMC. This is not the first time it rained in Karachi or any other city in monsoon season. Where is the much praised improvement of two decades in Karachi? Even the nullah and gutter systems could not be made or kept working.
Clearly the MQM propaganda machine is at its best and moreover are whining why the KMC administrators and other officials have been sacked because they were appointed on their advice.
The CM has done well to suspend these incompetent officers. Also I fail to understand that entire media footage shows ankle deep water not knee deep. Knee deep water on the embankments of Lyari, Malir and other nullahs is there because those drains are meant for that rather than illegally encroaching and building houses.
@ Such Bolta Hoon, The situation under MQMs municipal rule was really great in terms of response time to rain water problem and cleanliness. Rain water issue of Karachi was down to the factor of 10 as compared to today , and neither MQM nor MK claimed that the problem was over, and said much is needed to done in addition, MQM only had 5 years of municipal governance not many years.. On one side many people criticized him actually by calling him Mustafa Kudal for carrying out too much work in parallel in Karachi, and on the other side there are people like you who complain he should have done more.. Such bol to letay ho aap , thora demagh istemal kerna bhi shroo kerooo.
if the drains of city are not cleaned, off-course the water will stay, and drains need to be cleaned every month or two, you cannot blame MQM for not putting a Blackhole of garbage there so that whenever somebody throws garbage in next 100 years it should automatically disappears. Get a life Sore Complainer
Reader/ Bloggers Planning for surface water flooding doesn't happen in weeks. It takes years of work, attention given to critical infrastructure and disaster management planning. MQM has been controlling the Muncipal system for years and it goes to show that the development that we all saw was only face lift or fake rather than proper solution of underlying problems/ issues.
'Jaag Karachi Jaag, Lotaray loot rahay hain. Bhatta wassool kar rahay hain, Lasaniat ki bunyad per Aapni Dukaan chumka rahay hain,
Jaag Karachi Jaag
Pani sir say guzar jaey ga, Waqat Youn nakal jaey ga,
Jaag Karachi Jaag
Tumahain Youn kab tak ruswa is tarah Huna haiy. Aab yahein apna marna or jeena haiy Uth kharay hoo agar kuch tu nay karna haiy Jaag Karachi Jaag
when he will sack himself?
Support Tappi for the CM of the province please
Er, yeah, and it was your failure to deal with the 'cursed rains' that led to you being sacked, sweetheart...
Hasan
Bechara Kuch Is Ada Sey Rukh Hi Badal Gaya Ek Shaks Sarey Shehar Ko Veeran Kar Gaya
Where are you Mustafa Kamal? Karachi needs you..Please come back!!
FLOODY Pakistan !
Minister for Local bodies should take responsibility and resign. Things are in big mess due to rain
Pakistan must build more and more dams like India if they want to control flooding and power shortages. Small dams are better and cost effective.
If CM continues to sacked local bodies administer's, I am not sure who will clean this mess. This is not the time to show power and prove your incompetence. The two minister should come out from there double cabins rather just give speeches.
Bureaucracy takes its jobs for granted. They think it's their right, and they are not supposed to deliver anything. It's time for these old, tired, lazy chaps, who have spent their entire career doing nothing, to start working, or get fired.
God this is the first time it has rained in Sind and Karachi. Obviously Lotttas are busy brown-nosing.
The incompetent rulers of Sind will now begin the blame game to punish those who are not related to anyone to protect them. Its really like a protection mafia in business.
Well done Mr Qaim Ali shah... Another example of your incompetency....
Guess big city folk now realise how IDPs, people of FATA, militancy hit areas and remote areas of the country "fend for themselves".