Pakistan: treading a difficult path

Our economic realities are stark, but the future depends on us.


Zeeshan Shah March 10, 2013
Due to high government borrowing from the International Monetary Fund in the past and rescheduled debts, every Pakistani born today carries a debt of Rs72,000. ILLUSTRATION: JAMAL KHURSHID

KARACHI: Recent developments around the world indicate a clear need for urgency in bringing about an economic recovery. The last few years have seen most of the economic realities of our era come to light. These include widespread unemployment, rampant inflation, recessions, credit crunches, liquidity shortfalls, trade deficits, natural calamities and war.

2013 will be a real challenge. For starters, our debt-to-GDP ratio is at a steep 108%. We are a whopping Rs12 billion in deficit, which will eventually force us to rethink our economic realities. In the last three years, government borrowing from domestic sources has crossed 133% from Rs3.2 billion to Rs7.6 billion. Meanwhile, external borrowing has touched the highest levels – from Rs2.7 billion to Rs4.3 billion in four years, a growth of over 65%.

Pakistan also faces another problem that impedes its economic growth: only 22% of the population actually pays taxes. Due to high government borrowing from the International Monetary Fund in the past and rescheduled debts, every Pakistani born today carries a debt of Rs72,000. Meanwhile, corruption continues to flourish, with daily losses to the economy of Rs6-8 billion due to the absence of accountability controls and measures, says the National Accountability Bureau.

The central bank’s annual report indicated that: “It is important to realise that over-dependence on consumption makes growth unsustainable, especially while the investment rate in the country has been falling.” Here, the government fails to explain why the rate of actual investment is down and why we are missing our targeted growth rate. The government has recently unveiled the new investment policy for 2013, clarifying that “all restrictions on minimum investments have been removed”. But more needs to be done to cut down redundant processes and approval procedures that are cumbersome and counter-productive. Pakistan needs to ensure that it cuts down the ballooning import bill and create pathways towards self-reliance through exploring internal natural resources like Reko Diq and the Thar Coal projects.

As China takes over the strategic management of Gwadar Port operations, our bilateral relationship with the economic giant has broken new ground. The port is close to the Strait of Hormuz, giving us the maximum advantage over sea routes, opening up a trade and energy corridor for Pakistan.

Realistically, we stand on delicate ground today. But, if we aim to move in the right direction, we shall attain a successful economic frontier.

The writer comments on international relations and public policy

Published in The Express Tribune, March 11th, 2013.

Like Business on Facebook to stay informed and join in the conversation.

COMMENTS (2)

gp65 | 11 years ago | Reply

@Author : Where are you getting your numbers from?

"Pakistan also faces another problem that impedes its economic growth: only 22% of the population actually pays taxes."

Did you mean income taxes? If so the number is lless than 0.5%. If you include sales tax then everyone is a tax payer.

"For starters, our debt-to-GDP ratio is at a steep 108%. "

I have read numbers that range between 60 and 63%. Where did you get the 108% number from?

"We are a whopping Rs12 billion in deficit"

Your deficit is 1.7 trillion rupees.

"the government fails to explain why the rate of actual investment is down"

Because of load shedding and security situation.

abdussamad | 11 years ago | Reply

I don't know where the author got his numbers. Debt to GDP ratio is around 60% not 108% and only 10% of the population pays income tax not 20%.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ