Auto assemblers say cannot sustain liberal import policy

Published: December 12, 2012
Email
Rs450,000 is the amount that the parts makers lost on each imported car. PHOTO: FILE

Rs450,000 is the amount that the parts makers lost on each imported car. PHOTO: FILE

KARACHI: Standing united in their opposition to car imports, the car assemblers and auto parts manufacturers have categorically declared that the local automobile industry cannot sustain a liberal car import policy.

They say in the presence of inconsistent government policies, the industry will be reluctant to invest in new technology, as it fears it may lose the investment.

Speaking at a press conference here on Tuesday, the representatives of Pakistan Automobile Manufacturers Association (PAMA) and Pakistan Association of Automotive Parts and Accessories Manufacturers (Paapam) said inconsistent car import policy of the government is one of the biggest reasons why the automobile industry is not showing consistent growth.

Paapam former chairman Aamir A Allawala pointed out that around 55,000 cars were imported from July 2011 to June 2012, and went on to claim that this caused an annual revenue loss of Rs25 to Rs30 billion to the local auto parts makers alone, but did not elaborate further on the numbers.

$26,744

In support of his claim, he said average cost of a Pakistani car (excluding taxes) is Rs750,000. An average Pakistani car uses 60% of local components and the value of such components is around Rs450,000. This is the amount that the parts makers lost on each imported car, he said.

Most people believe that locally assembled cars are much more expensive than vehicles manufactured in other countries, but this is a wrong perception, the industry representatives said while giving a comparison between prices of Pakistani cars and those manufactured in regional countries.

Pakistani cars are cheaper than most cars manufactured in India, Allawala claimed, adding 1,800cc Toyota Corolla is being sold in India for $16,334 (retail price excluding taxes) while the price of the same car in Pakistan is $13,253, lower by $3,081.

Including taxes, the retail price of Toyota Corolla in India is $26,744 while in Pakistan it is $19,781, a difference of $6,963.

Similarly, the retail price of 1,800cc Honda Civic in India he said was $19,216 (excluding all taxes) while the same car is being sold for $15,214 in Pakistan, a difference of $4,002, he said.

After including all taxes, the difference in prices of Honda Civic in Pakistan and India is $7,403. In India, Civic is being sold for $30,455 while it is available at $23,052 in Pakistan.

The automakers and vendors have underlined the need for revision in the import duty slabs, saying the old duty structures are favouring car importers.

In response to a question, PAMA Director General Abdul Waheed cautioned the consumers, who are opting for imported used cars, saying they were making a wrong decision.

“The buyers of used cars may spend less initially, but eventually they pay much more in terms of expensive maintenance and low resale value compared to a new car,” he said.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 12th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (4)

  • Pro Truth
    Dec 12, 2012 - 7:36AM

    “1,800cc Toyota Corolla is being sold in India for $16,334 (retail price excluding taxes) while the price of the same car in Pakistan is $13,253, lower by $3,081”

    Indus Pakistan does not assemble 1800CC but maximum 1600CC at present, and no specific model details are given here for comparison!

    Recommend

  • Saif Shamsi
    Dec 12, 2012 - 9:29AM

    “They say in the presence of inconsistent government policies, the industry will be reluctant to invest in new technology, as it fears it may lose the investment”

    They are already reluctant to invest in new technologies and models, specially Toyota & Pak Suzuki. These auto manufacturers have been given ample time to establish themselves and they should now improve their quality to face the competition.

    Recommend

  • Haroon Rashid
    Dec 12, 2012 - 11:57AM

    Statements of PAMA, PAPAM for Indian industry is based on the QC (Quality Control) certification/rating criteria which is certified by the respective international rating criteria, which has enabled the Indian Automobile sector to export cars in the international markets, and also participate in the JAMA (Japan Automobile Manufacturers Association), which is the principal organiser of the Tokyo Motor Show for the more than 50 years.
    Indian Automobile Sector regularly participates at the display/preview of the Japanese made cars made in India, and obtain export orders worldwide.
    An offer was extended by myself to PAMA for participation of the members at the Tokyo Motor Show subject to the adherence of rules and quality criteria for participation at the Tokyo Motor Show to which subsidies/grants could be sought on case to case basis.

    In the past survey being carried by Toyota Motor Japan publisheotd in the international media rated the best Toyota Corolla produced in the world was from Thailand. The worst Toyota Corolla produced in the world from Pakistan.
    Unless our sector seeks export capability they will not be able to gain neither the domestic market if they are not able to produce quality, export and make a business case for exports.

    Recommend

  • Saif Shamsi
    Dec 12, 2012 - 3:31PM

    @Haroon Rashid:

    Very true. Quality of locally assembled cars is far below when compared to imported ones and yet they are expensive

    Recommend

More in Business