Dismay and outrage over Hindu cartoons controversy

Committee formed by Punjab government now wants to ensure that CDs with Hindu cartoons are not sold in Pakistan.


Express September 07, 2010

KARACHI: “It is a renowned fable that a king once directed the subjects in his kingdom to prevent beautiful birds from flying in the sky. People tried to chase them but it was impossible. So is the case in our country, we fight against nature when it is highly impossible to do so,” says Hari Motwani, a current member of the Advisory Council and ex-general secretary of the Pakistan Hindu Council, when asked about the ban on the mythological cartoon characters that is being considered in Punjab.

As reported in The Express Tribune on September 7, the Punjab government has formed a committee which will issue a report asking for a ban to be imposed on cartoons depicting Hindu mythology.

This ban would be an additional measure adopted to curb Indian programming in the country, given that channels without landing rights have already been taken off air.

According to Shadman, a cable operator at Cable Home Vision Communications, “The ban on these cartoon characters has been place for the past 20 days in Sindh and we are following that ban by not showing it at all.”

However, a Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority representative told The Express Tribune that no special directives have been issued for cartoons in particular, except that the Indian transmission of Cartoon Network has been taken offair.

The committee formed by the Punjab government also wants to ensure that CDs with the cartoons are not sold in Pakistan.

However, the move has not resonated well within Pakistan. Commentators on Twitter and The Express Tribune website wrote that the government seemed to be wasting its time with ‘irrelevant matters’ and that the move was ‘ridiculous’.

TV personality Shanaz Ramzi told The Express Tribune, “This is silly. These characters are part of the Hindu culture and viewing them does not change one’s belief or faith. So it certainly is not going to affect anybody’s mindset. We are no longer the pluralistic and tolerant society that we used to be. We breed intolerance.”

While Punjab Member of Provincial Assembly Farah Deeba told The Express Tribune that the move was because the cartoons “had a bad impact on the minds of young children,” parents disagree.

Shahid Ashraf, a father of two girls, told The Express Tribune that he does not think “there is anything wrong with watching cartoons of characters such as Hanuman, who is a character on screen like Dora or Barbie.”

Ashraf said, “I want to be the kind of father who keeps my children well-informed and they themselves should be best judges about things governing our lives. I believe my values are stronger than this and nobody can change that.”

According to Motwani, “For example, ‘Amar Chitra Katha’ is an epic that relates well in Indian culture, it is not a myth but a reality. Whatever decision that the Punjab government has taken is certainly without taking things into their rightful and meaningful context.”

Published in The Express Tribune, September 8th, 2010.

COMMENTS (32)

adyniz | 11 years ago | Reply Huh... They've realised this thing now? Cable operators took of CN Pakistan and started to provide CN India. Does that thing make any sense? I mean we DO have our own CN then why to air someone else's? For GOD SAKE, PEMRA if you're banning star plus, sony and all those channels then atleast advise cable operators to provide CN Pakistan instead of the Indian one. No offense guys but cable operators are JERKS. They have even stopped providing Disney Channel India.How on earth DCI have bad impact on our children?Disney Channel don't even air mythological shows then why to pull it off?
Hari Motwani | 11 years ago | Reply I need to correct Miss. Shanaz Ramzi who wanted my comments on phone. I informed her that AMAR CHITRA KATHA is a series of publication probably owned by India Book House who has printed more than 500 pictorial stories in nutshell of Hindu Gods & Godess, saints, Heros and Heroines of India including Guru Nanak, Kabir, all Sikh Gurus and many other may be some muslim saints without any discretion of cast & creed The picture appeared that day was of Shivaji Maharaj. These are part of Histrory every one must know and there was no harm if the children see them on TV. If we allow Indian chanells in the country naturally these things cannot be stopped. I also informed her that Amar means immortan=permanent, Chitra means in pictures and Katha means stories but religious..Some muslim stories, I quote here while going through the list viz.Chand Bibi:SherShah:Sultana Razia:Babur:Humayun:Noor Jehan:Tipu Sultan:Akba:Shah Jahan:(a few of 210 list Given on the book which I purchased in 1980) In Lahore I remember & read four volumes of TAREKH-E-GUJAR, printed till 1975, when I lived there. Punjab Govt cannot ban them. History cannot be denied. Facts are truths of time.Bias thinking is harming the sovereignity of the country. We must change our approach, should not pull leg of one another.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read