Families denied accurate compensation

Families of the victims of Fokker plane crash in Multan four years ago denied accurate compensation.

Qaiser Zulfiqar September 05, 2010

ISLAMABAD: Misery and pain in a society where the slogan “Justice for All” is held by the Supreme Court, but denied by its subordinates, is all that is left for widow Dr Naheed Fatima who lost her husband in a Fokker plane crash in Multan four years ago.

Her husband, Dr Abdur Rauf, who was an assistant professor in BV Hospital Bahawalpur of Psychiatry, left for Turkey via Lahore on July 10, 2006 to attend an International Conference, unaware that it would be his last journey.

Flight PK-688, a Fokker F-27 twin-engine aircraft, took off from Multan Airport at around 12:05 pm and within a few minutes burst into flames after spiralling in the air and crashing into a wheat field, about three kilometres away from Multan airport.

All 45 passengers – 33 men and eight women – were killed. Two army brigadiers, two judges of the High Court in Lahore, Justice Muhammad Nawaz Bhatti, and Justice Nazir Ahmad Siddiqui and the former principal of the King Edward Medical College were among the passengers.

On the orders of then Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz, Director General Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) formed a board of inquiry to investigate the cause of the crash. However, four years have passed since the tragic incident but the investigations have still not been made public.

A few days after the crash Pakistan International Airline Company (PIAC) announced Rs0.5 million as compensation for each passenger but when the aggrieved families decided to go to court, the PIAC lawyer offered Rs2 million as a lump sum compensation for each deceased passenger.

Many who were unaware of the law received the compensation money but Dr Naheed Fatima refused to take the compensation amount and demanded the original compensation under the “Montreal Convention”.

Dr Naheed filed a civil suit in Sindh High Court against PIAC and CAA in 2007 but due to the judicial crisis the same year the case was never fixed for hearing.

She claimed that under the Montreal Convention, PIAC is under obligation to pay 114231/00 SDR (Special Drawing Rights – an IMF devised currency unit adopted by the Montreal Convention in 1999) which is equivalent to Rs14, 760,701.

However, according to her, PIAC and CAA continued to defy this national and international law and even failed to fairly advise the victims about their lawful rights after the crash.

Dr Naheed told The Express Tribune that she is unaware how much amount PIAC and CAA claimed from the insurance company. “Obviously it would have been a huge claim, but they disbursed peanuts amongst the families and put the rest of it in their own pockets.”

She appealed to the Chief Justice of Pakistan Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry to take suo motto notice of the crash and prayed to the court to direct PIAC to pay the owed amount of SDR 114231/00 and also direct PIAC and Civil Aviation to make the inquiry report conducted after the Fokker crash public.

She has also appealed to the Supreme Court CJ to direct the Sind High Court to decide her civil suit – which is pending before the court since 2007 – within six months, and to direct PIAC, CAA and rest of the Airlines to advertise the rights and entitlements of travelling passengers.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 5th, 2010.


abrar | 11 years ago | Reply This injustice to survivors of air crash is being done in collaboration with CAA, who have withheld the publication of the crash report to facilitate the airline operator and those responsible within CAA. It is again happening with the Air Blue crash victim survivors. Airlines receive handsome compensation for crash accident victims, which should be disbursed to the survivor families as the least of compensation. It is inhumane of the airline operators in Pakistan and the Government of Pakistan to allow them to profit from the crash. Unfortunately this is exactly what is happening. Fokker crash occurred during martial and the Air Blue crash occurred under a democratic setup. However for the families of the unfortunate victims of these crashes, there is no change. This is the stark reality. There is no such thing as consumer rights in Pakistan, nor does the government or the elected parliament seem to be interested in protecting consumers. This is what happens when business man dominate a government and corruption thrives..
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read