Of course, it is not just the Hindu community that faces public discrimination and official apathy. Christians and other minorities live in constant fear of being attacked or hauled off to jail after being accused of blasphemy. Often, their ‘crime’ is nothing but a property dispute or a misunderstanding. But their religion ensures that only the Muslim point of view will be heard. Christians are given the most menial jobs in the country and end up living in poverty-stricken ghettos. And yet, come Christmas or Easter time, all our politicians will be posing in front of the camera reading out their rehearsed statements.
If the plight of minorities is indeed something the political class cares about, there is a lot that can be done. A simple reform of the blasphemy laws alone, making it much harder for cases to be registered without proof, would make minorities feel incalculably safer. Now is also the time to treat every citizen of the country as a Pakistani, regardless of caste, creed or religion. It is scandalous that non-Muslims cannot be elected as president. This is not the Pakistan that Jinnah fought for.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 14th, 2012.
COMMENTS (24)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@zeeshan sheikh: and what is so bad about that. Some pagans did what they feel is correct and it did not harm anyone. Why do you have a problem with that?
Why dont you introspect on these lines: "Why do I have a problem when someone else does something that has nothing to do with me, and does not harm me in any way?"
First of all I appreciate the editor and salute his courage and professionalism that how beautifully he highlighted this very core and important issue. I fully agree with the editorial that the discrimination, persecution and official apathy to the Hindus or other minorities living in Pakistan has reached its limits, since Pakistan has came in to being. I feel the editor is still look bit optimistic about our leaders and politicians , mentioning that they will greet Diwali to Hindus or Christmas to Christians, but for his kind notice that this courage and curtsy in even not resist in a large number of our present leaders. I remember very well in 2009 when two very barbaric attacks were carried out on Ahmadiyya Community places at Lahore where around 80 Ahmadiyya community members were shot dead and scores were injured, but the reaction of the state was seldom, very few leaders of Pakistan even bother to condemn that or pay condolence or to showed any kind of sympathy to them. The one who dared to show some sympathy to them, late Governor of Punjab Mr. Suleiman Taseer, he was made silent forever. This is really not the Pakistan what for dreamed or struggled Mr. Jinnah. Pakistan doesn't have a pleasant impact internationally regarding human rights and it's more deterring by each passing day. The impression of Pakistan internationally is not more than like a hostile and hijacked society. The Ramsha case should be an eye opener for our legislators to know that how common and how badly the blasphemy law is being practiced in Pakistan. May Allah give courage to our nation and leaders to call spade a spade.
@Toticalling: I am an Indian Hindu living in US.We have grown up singing this aarthi and know it verbatim. Thanks again for being open minded.
pagan pagan rituals everywhere
@gp65: Thank you. If you are not in Pakistan, I attach a clip which we heard yesterday evening: (Arrthi) as Youtube is banned in Pakistan). It is so soothing and calms your nerves. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnfxQSNTsno&feature=related
@Toticalling: Thank you. Hope the festival of lights brings happiness and peace in your and your family's life.Wish you a happy Diwali.
@Pir Lulleh Shah:
Please don't use name of Bulleh Shah to hide your hatred for the fellow human beings.
@Pir Bulleh Shah:
Ironically, Hajj (which presumably Haji Ghiasuddin himself went on) itself is a pagan ritual. And no religious observance can possibly be more dangerous than a "Ghazwa".
I would say no Pakistanis love their country . Because the minorities who are there are very enterprenual in nature and they have that gene . If those minorities were protected , they could have helped pak economy in a much better way .
No One is safe here.
Pir Bulleh Shah for President!!! Just Kidding.
@Mirza
All of us shoud share your spirit. God bless you.
The extortionists do not check ethnicity or faith, they just ask for money or whatever valuable you possess at the crucial time. The majority is as unsafe in here as is the minorty, why make the difference. My christian colleagues have no complaints what so ever. They are as much petrified as I am.
@ Mirzaji, May your tribe grow........greetings to you and your family ............I pray that you progress and prosper in life.......
@Pir Bulleh Shah:
Feel free to stay away.
@Pir Bulleh Shah: Glad I did not follow your advice. I went to a Divali invitation and enjoyed the way they celebrated. Aarthi was played and they did puja. It was simple and I loved it. You should go and learn how to respect each other. No wonder one faith is considered so intolerant.
@Pir Bulleh Shah: Those who came after -how can they question the culture that came 2000 years before?
@Pir Bulleh Shah: " ... Please read about Haji Ghiasuddin who stopped this dangerous pagan revelry so-called ‘festival’. ... "
Better pagan than Muslim, bro.
Hindu community in Pakistan is like sugar in milk. It only enhances the flavor of the society without altering its structure. What a peaceful celebration!
@Pir Bulleh Shah: If your Haji is not capable of respecting others and their rituals then he does not deserve any kind of respect. Its a different thing to not agree, but its totally unacceptable if something is imposed on the other against his wish. And you better stop idolizing him because in that case it will be termed as hypocrisy.
@Pir Bulleh Shah: I sure do hope you know Bulleh Shah said something along these lines in one of his poems: ... "Bullah is neither Rafzi nor Sunni, nor learned nor an intellectual nor a Jaini. I have learnt the lesson of love of God alone. People say : Bulleh is an Infidel (Kafar) and an idol-worshipper. But in the Lord’s court, both the Momin and Kafar (Believer and un-believer) are treated alike."
@Mirza: Thanks Mirza and may this festival of light bring joy, happiness and prosperity in your and your family life..
It is a nice and fair editorial and thanks for that. It is heart wrenching to see and know what is going on in this land of pure at the name of religion. Dewali is the festival of lights and let us hope and pray that it lights up our country. The fact is with the rise in fanaticism and extremism there is no hope for common Pakistanis let alone minorities and women. Happy Dewali to all my Hindu countrymen.
Just tell me who is safe in Pakistan. Now everyone feels the phrase"then they came for me and there was no one"in their bones now!