The facts in this matter are black and white and the road ahead is clear, but the country’s vision has become blurred. The facts are that the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), and no one else, is responsible for shooting a girl who dared to go to school. This is about the attempted murder of one Pakistani citizen by another Pakistani citizen. This fact has nothing whatsoever to do with drone strikes. In fact, if drone strikes were to stop tomorrow, the TTP would still exist and it would still be burning down girls’ schools, targeting innocent women and children, brutally silencing anyone who dares to raise a voice. This is not mere speculation or conjecture: they wreaked havoc over Swat in 2008 and early 2009, before the current level of drone strikes began.
It is also a fact that the Pakistani government has not shown a concern for development. Last year, development spending in Pakistan was a paltry 2.8 per cent of the GDP. It is then no surprise that education, let alone girls’ education, has not been a priority. A new UNESCO report shows that Pakistan’s progress in getting poor girls to go to school is less than half of that in India and Nepal and a quarter of that in Bangladesh. Pakistani women desperately want their daughters to be educated, regardless of how poor or illiterate they are. I heard this from each woman I interviewed in a study I conducted in the villages of Punjab and Sindh a few years ago. Girls face enormous constraints in terms of access to schools because the government has traditionally built one girls’ school for every two boys’ schools. Compounding these problems of access are cultural constraints to girls’ mobility, especially once they reach puberty.
However, increasing enrollment through building schools alone is by no means the entire answer. For even the lucky few who go to school, the education they receive is of dubious quality and their learning is very limited. According to a large survey in Punjab, children at the end of third grade are functionally illiterate and innumerate. They are not able to perform basic mathematical operations, unable to write simple sentences in Urdu and unable to recognise simple words in English. We know that our national curriculum is biased and presents a one-sided view of history. It is an understatement to say that it does not promote critical or creative thinking. It also perpetuates poverty by not preparing the population adequately for jobs. All this is not news. But how often have you been in a conversation about how to increase access to or improve the quality of schooling in Pakistan? Instead of getting mired in a murky debate about the world machinating against Pakistan, the nation’s time would be wisely spent in thinking about what precise interventions we need for development. To this end, Pakistan might want to emulate its more developed neighbour to the east. In an experiment run by US academics in India, which suffers from problems of low teacher and student attendance and limited learning in schools just like Pakistan does, teachers were asked to take pictures with their students at the beginning and at the end of the school day. The result? Teacher attendance and student test scores both increased. The lesson? Many of Pakistan’s problems are not unique and the solutions to them are not necessarily expensive.
Recently, one of the two US presidential candidates dealt with a backlash on his views on women’s rights. This is in part because of his unfortunate choice of phrases such as “binders full of women” and “women coming home to make dinner”. This is where the rest of the world stands, and as they watch, Pakistan is blundering in its response to half of its population’s most basic and fundamental rights: to education, to speech, to work, to a dignified and purposeful life. The gap between Pakistan and the rest of the world has never been greater and the country’s problems have never been more glaringly bared in front of the world. This is a time for introspection: it is time to take a long, hard look inwards and to get to work.
Published in The Express Tribune, October 26th, 2012.
COMMENTS (19)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Pakistan is quite simply suffering from the Kashmir and then Afghan wars.These two wars have sucked up all the resources, leaving little for social and economic development.
@Sultan:
Glad to read your reply. I had also enjoyed reading the "synopsis".
You do seem to be a well educated person who has a mind in the right place. I can see you doing a lot of good for the Pakistani society. You have just the right ideas but they must get tempered by experience and maturity. I feel the same about IK too.
What worries me is the burden the younger generation carries due to lack of a well defined national identity, and the ill effects of a closed mind.
I wish you all luck in your endeavors towards making the Pakistan of your dreams.
@wonderer:
I have already joined PTI and hopefully some one high up in the party is reading this as well. I have no personal ambition to run for anything--I just want all of our children--from Karachi to Chitral--to grow up in a safe, happy, and prosperous Pakistan.
Did you read my synopsis of the decisions we made over the past 30 years that have led us astray listed above before your comment? If not, please read it and let me know what you think. It already touches the confession and truth stage you proposed in your comment. And I don't think we need a Mullah-e-Azam--the general population can be easily won back from the darkside as long as they see the promise of a better life on earth, and not in heaven! After all, the behaviour of on the Motorway versus the behaviour on city roads is markedly different by the same drivers in the same cars. The questions to ask: what makse it so? The answer is: the carrot of safety and faster, more comfortable travel and the stick of heavy fine with no safarish to wean out of it. It works like that all over the world--we may have lost some of our humanity to insulate ourselves from the constant barrage of mindless terror but we are still human who can learn and change. Keep the faith.
@Sultan:
Glad to see you have done some thinking, but I am sorry, you still do not deserve my vote. I suggest you apply for membership of PTI, and send your plan of action to Imran Khan. They will tell you what chances you have of getting my vote.
Please don't, in return ask me what should be done. I don't know. May be no body does.
We have been on the wrong path for far too long. Changing course will take as long, if not more. It will also be quite painful. And, that will be possible if the nation can throw up a farsighted leader. I am already too old.
In my humble, but controversial view, we must start with openly admitting to all the falsehood we have injected into the very blood of our people. Then we should tell them the TRUTH, even if we lose all our Ghairat in the process. Along with this we should, by an act of Parliament if necessary, get all the Mullahs of the land of the pure under the control of one MULLAH-e-AAZAM.
When and if this much is accomplished, and I am still alive, I shall be available, if needed, for advice on the next few steps.
In 1960's south korea was running on international aid today its 15 largest world economy.Pakistan is on the decline who is responsible for this mess? Its the ruling elite
@Humanity: "Without the courage to examine how and things went so utterly wrong, the resolve to correct the course in an attainable goal. One can not cure a disease without accurate diagnosis. Denying the root of the problem only delays Pakistan from realizing its potential."
Here is a quick examination of how things went wrong: we supported the US in destroying USSR in Afghanistan to satisfy their desire to seek revenge over the humiliation in Vietnam. In return, the US looked the other way and we got the Big Bomb--a brilliant bargain extracted by our security establishment. With this feather in their cap, our armed forces then imported the Jihadi culture--so effectively used in Afghanistan--into Pakistan and the public lapped it up: we all gave donations in mosques and bukray ki khalain for Eid to theses outfits to liberate Kashmir to seek revenge for the humiliation in East Pakistan. It was another brilliant move by our security establishment to weaken indian defenses for as long as it worked--with a handful of "assets", we were able to bog down 500,000 indian soldiers in Kashmir. Unfortunately, the laughter in Rawalpindi stopped after our holy warrior Muslim brother, OBL, decided to flatten the Twin Towers to seek revenge against various real and imagined atrocities committed by the US against the canard called "Muslim Ummah". The world changed after 9/11 and America threatened Pakistan to seek revenge for the humiliation in New York. We obliged under the threat of annihilation and tried our best to tame ours "assets"; however, our assets--who had by now acquired a hero status and deep following within the population--had other plans and revolted against us to become a liability, especially after Lal masjid incident. Now these renegade "assets" are trying to destroy the Pakistani state to seek revenge for the humiliation of Lal Masjid, with their leader being shown on national TV escaping in a burqa! Does this litany of seeking revenge adequately explains the 30 years of trading in coal, which has sullied the hands of the entire nation now or shall I write a Phd. dissertation on it?
Enough melodrama and introspection--this is not a Bollywood tear jerker. We are all adults and know fully well what happened, what we gained and what we lost. It is time now to get out of the coal business, wash our hands clean, say a prayer and charge ahead at full speed. We still have a lovely piece of real estate+a big army+nuclear deterrent and some very smart people to help build us a better future.
@Lose Dhoti:
Yes, mental depression, hopelessness, apathy and general ignorance about what assets we have will take us down the rainbow path. We are all adults, we know what our problems are. All I am saying is we have some assets to fight these problems with.
@Sultan.......the real estate is good no doubt but the security situation is not and is not getting better. Only pure optimism, good hope and faith will take us no where. Whats the plan?????
@wonderer:
The first thing I will do is to look at both the assets and liabilities on the country's balance sheet to see what the balance looks like and not just get overwhelmed by the burden of liabilities--for every posion, there is an antidote. Second, I will devise a strategy on how best to turn deploy the existing assets to create prosperity. Third, I will rank all the liabilities and deloy as many assets as required to eliminate them all, one by one, starting with the most pressing ones like terrorism, education, economy. All three steps will be communicated in clear, crisp Urdu to the population in Pakistan and Queen's English to the world at large so there is no confusion about what we have, what we lack and how we are going to use what we have to get we lack. Now, please vote me in ;)
"All we need is to develop it and enjoy living there as Pakistanis first and everything else after that. All we are missing is education and justice for the masses; hopefully, our new aspiring politicians have a good grip on this reality and will use their best minds to evolve a strategy that takes us away from the path of war to the land of peace". Hope springs eternal in the human heart.
Beautifully said! Is there anyone listening! Pakistani rulers (I don't know who they are actually) have eyes that don't see, ears that don't hear, and mouths that shout at the neighbors.
@Ishrat salim:
I am in complete agreement with you Sir, but kindly consider the view I heard a wise and experienced Pakistani, who considers the Army as a hurdle, pronounce once. It goes like this:
The day Pakistani Army understands, and accepts, that what is good for this unfortunate land of the pure, may not be necessarily good for the Army, we will be on the way to complete recovery and progress.
Unless we the intellectual bunch pool our resources , change mindset, force the govt to provide education to the masses as per constitution and support govt effort in this respect, pay taxes honestly, this country can never go forward....
@Sultan: I wish more people like you were given the podium to write for the opinion section of the Tribune.
@Sultan:
You write very well, but do you make sense? Ask yourself the following question:
How, with what practical steps, will I make the Pakistan of my dreams if I were the Prime Minister of Pakistan?
Share your answer with us. Thanks!
@Sultan wrote "All we are missing is education and justice for the masses; "
You seem to be hoping to serve water from a mirage in the desert. With uneducated masses waiting for justice to drop from the sky, the resources you have listed might as well be on Mars.
Without the courage to examine how and things went so utterly wrong, the resolve to correct the course in an attainable goal. One can not cure a disease without accurate diagnosis. Denying the root of the problem only delays Pakistan from realizing its potential.
i liked your view of lookin at oneself than pointing angrily at the world ... but dunno where u wanted to take me after first few paragraphs ... u urself blamed TTP, and at not wat made ppl join the damned TTP or whoever enables the reach of TTP or wat enhance TTPs actions inside Pakistan or who heads TTP and how TTP are using local disgruntled people ... i think u read news only, and never went to TANK whn al lthe journalists went. it might nt be easy for you ... wat i dint like was ... the comparison u put right in the last para, with the US presidential campaign ... maam, Pakistan is a third world country, plz compare it with the likes, the practical examples, like BRIC countries, or with solutions to our problems ... comparing with Europe or US or Japan or Mid East is by those only who dunno themselves ... macro socio economic solutions are nt comparable to 1st world ... come out of your shell of wide roads, subways, condos, tabs, BMWs ... address out problems whether micro or macro ... article wud have looked good in a Youth magazine, or maybe im too mature
God, another treatise on self flagellation. It is not time to look inward-- it is time to look forward. There is no point continuously discussing the ideology of Pakistan–it is like asking how long is a piece of string? Everyone will have a diffrent answer–we need to resolve our existing differences, not create new ones. The fact is that Pakistan exists and we should get on with it. We are fortunate enough to have one of the best pieces of real esate on this planet, loaded with resources: highest mountains, largest glaciers, stunning meadows, fertile plains fed by some of the mightiest rivers on this planet, the bluest seas, the prettiest beaches, the loveliest deserts, the fours seasons, snow, monsoon, fog, birds, animals, gems, gold, copper, rare earth metals, coal, oil, gas, dams, canals, roads, railway tracks, telecommunication infrastructure, nuts, fruits, vegetables, fish, livestock, grains, rice, cotton, sugar cane, art, literature, music, culture, history, a well-equipped and sizable army, a nuclear deterrent, an entrepreneural spirit, an army of overseas forex earners bringing in $15 billion per annum, a geostrategic position and a large working age population. How many countries on this planet can you name that have even half of that? So many nations will give an arm and a leg to get what we have but do not realize. If that is not enough to build a good life for us, only God knows what else will be? What does it matter how Pakistan came to be? What matters is it did and we got a good piece of property–think of it as a gift inheritance. All we need is to develop it and enjoy living there as Pakistanis first and everything else after that. All we are missing is education and justice for the masses; hopefully, our new aspiring politicians have a good grip on this reality and will use their best minds to evolve a strategy that takes us away from the path of war to the land of peace. It has all the ingrredients to be one of most vibrant countries on earth and it will be absolutely fantastic to live in a new Pakistan.