US judge rejects call to ban YouTube from showing trailer

Published: September 22, 2012
Actress Cindy Lee sues YouTube, its owner Google for releasing excerpts of amateurish film ‘Innocence of Muslims’.  PHOTO: REUTERS

Actress Cindy Lee sues YouTube, its owner Google for releasing excerpts of amateurish film ‘Innocence of Muslims’. PHOTO: REUTERS


A US judge on Thursday rejected a request by an actress in the sacrilegious video, which set off violent Muslim protests, to ban YouTube from showing its trailer.

Lawyers for actress Cindy Lee Garcia requested a restraining order to prevent the online video-sharing service from continuing to show the low-budget movie trailer after claiming that she was duped. Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Louis Lavin refused the request.

Garcia is one of three actresses in the film to have come forward with similar accusations since the explosion of violence that ripped through Muslim countries in the Middle East, Africa and Asia last week.

She sued YouTube and its owner Google for releasing excerpts of the amateurish film ‘Innocence of Muslims’. Her lawsuit, filed Wednesday, alleges that the the movie’s director, identified by the pseudonym Sam Bacile, presented it as an adventure film about ancient Egyptians, called ‘Desert Warrior’.

Garcia has suffered severe emotional distress, financial setbacks and the ‘destruction of her career and reputation’, the lawsuit says. The actress’s lawyer Cris Armenta said she was duped by the producer and now her life is in danger. “Clearly she was defrauded,” he said.

Speaking before the hearing, Garcia said she hoped the court would take immediate action to ban YouTube from hosting the video trailer, arguing that its continued availability puts her at risk of attack.

“I think, yes, we have a right to free speech, but what they did was wrong,” she said, calling the movie ‘degrading and demoralising’. After the court ruling she told reporters: “I’m not giving up.”

The US actress also filed a lawsuit against the reported producer of the film, Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, on grounds of invasion of privacy, fraud, slander and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The 55-year-old convicted fraudster – out on parole – lives in Los Angeles and has admitted to working on the film. US media says Nakoula wrote and produced the film, using the pseudonym Sam Bacile before being identified. He was questioned overnight on Friday by police before going into hiding with his family.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 22nd, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (4)

  • FAZ
    Sep 22, 2012 - 1:14PM

    Cut the crape!!
    She exactly knew what she is upto and now she feels terrified. Atleast the positive side of all the destructive protests is that people like these are terrified..


  • M. Ahmed
    Sep 22, 2012 - 2:47PM

    Nakoula Basseley Nakoula you may be alive but actually you are dead!


  • rab nawaz leghari
    Sep 22, 2012 - 6:19PM

    The musilm world should not have any expectation from a JEW & a christan Judge. AS in quaran the JEW & christian can never be friends of musilms. so the judgement of US judge is not surprising.Recommend

  • Wipe Out
    Sep 23, 2012 - 10:25PM

    I think she sued the wrong people didn’t she? Youtube and google are not responsible. It is the film-maker she should be suing – I would be surprised if that were not successful; the man has destroyed her life.Recommend

More in World