Why has power shortage soared?

Published: June 21, 2012
Inefficiency, ad-hoc policies, shortage of oil and gas, poor energy mix to blame for the crisis. PHOTO: ONLINE/ FILE

Inefficiency, ad-hoc policies, shortage of oil and gas, poor energy mix to blame for the crisis. PHOTO: ONLINE/ FILE


The irrational electricity rationing has triggered countrywide protests as mobs angered by daily blackouts – 22 hours a day in some cases – have rampaged, burning buildings and offices.

This has happened consistently over the past five years in sweltering summers. A myriad of problems are to blame for the country’s chronic electricity crisis.

These include inefficient governance, lack of forward planning, ad-hocism and failure to implement policies.

The electricity shortage, which has ballooned into a gruelling crisis, resulted mainly from a shortage of fuel – furnace oil and gas. The government failed to ensure adequate, uninterrupted supply of fuel to gas-powered generation units.

Gas was sold to CNG stations and fertiliser units, bringing power plants either to a grinding halt or forcing them to generate less than their capacity. This resulted in an energy crisis and sent tariffs spiralling upwards.

The power sector was receiving 750 million cubic feet per day (mmcfd) of gas in 2000 that has now come down to 300 mmcfd. Now most thermal plants are powered by expensive furnace oil — compelling the government to operate plants at a low capacity to avoid billion of rupees subsidy for power consumers.

Power plants can generate 15,600 megawatts (MW) of electricity if water is available to tap the maximum hydropower potential. But the generation remains low as part of the government’s strategy to maintain low volume of subsidy for power consumers.

Power capacity

Several other factors have also perpetuated this crisis. Low power availability out of the total capacity is also one of the main reasons. The government has claimed to have added new installed capacity of 3,394 MW between March 2008 and March 2012 with 400 MW power output by rental power plants (RPPs). Despite the total installed capacity reaching 23,000 MW, the country is still able to generate a maximum of 15,600 MW due to the poor rate of power availability out of the total capacity.

According to international standards, power availability out of the total installed capacity is usually about 80% whereas in Pakistan the system availability is only 65% due to inefficiencies.

Recovery of bills

Another reason that contributed to the power crisis is outstanding dues. The government faces losses worth Rs7 billion every month due to non-recovery of electricity bills. Non-cooperation on part of the provinces and government departments is not helping improve matters — Sindh owes Rs51 billion and Punjab is yet to pay Rs15.6 billion in bills. The billing collection was 104% in year 2010 and in 2011 the situation worsened with the collection rate plunging down to 83%.

Poor energy mix

Poor energy mix plays a crucial role in this equation. Power costs have increased significantly owing to a gradual shift from hydel to thermal (share of hydel has fallen from 70% in the 1980s to 30%) and the recent shift from natural gas to furnace oil owing to gas shortages. Due to oil-powered expensive power production, the government intentionally switches to operating thermal plants at low capacity to avoid the subsidy leading to load shedding.

False promises

The incumbent government pledged to bring reforms in the power sector to plug the holes but failed to achieve much. Since 2008, the government has increased power tariffs by 94% in addition to the massive price hikes on account of fuel adjustment. The major purpose of these reforms was to efficiently manage the power sector to end subsidies which continue to spiral upwards. It had allocated a subsidy amounting to Rs122.7 billion for the power sector in the ongoing financial year which swelled to Rs419.018 billion due to inefficiency in the power sector.

Under the reform programme, the government was to dissolve the Pakistan Electric Power Company (Pepco), reconstitute the board of directors of power companies and hire new professionals from the private sector and appoint chief executive officers (CEOs).

Pepco has not been completely dissolved so far. Board of directors were reconstituted in 2009-10 but the power distribution companies (Discos) are still being run through ad-hoc arrangements.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 21st, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (10)

  • mr. righty rightist
    Jun 21, 2012 - 10:01AM

    The main reason is, India is curtailing the flow into Indus river by violating the treaty.


  • feedback
    Jun 21, 2012 - 11:20AM

    This article is a good start but obviously does not analyze the problems in a holistic manner. Gathering all the facts about electricty generation, distribution and losses and presenting them in an easy to under tables and graphs would be a start. Which province is getting how much electricity and owes how much, omc receivables, … so much data missing.Recommend

  • Polpot
    Jun 21, 2012 - 12:11PM

    @mr. righty rightist: “The main reason is, India is curtailing the flow into Indus river by violating the treaty.”



  • Raj
    Jun 21, 2012 - 12:29PM

    @mr. righty rightist……nice , blame it on India now……its ur government wrong policy…..


  • Jun 21, 2012 - 12:46PM

    Government is rationing fuel since it cant pay by printing money.


  • ishrat salim
    Jun 21, 2012 - 12:57PM

    The most crucial element of circular debt has been missed in this artilce.This one of the most important factor which is playing havoc.Unless, this issue is resolved, adhocism will continue & the population will suffer.The govt has no longterm policy except firefighting on short-term basis.This wil lnot help nor it is helping.If this govt wud hv been sincere, 5 yrs was a longtime to bring Thar – coal project online.They did not prioritise anything…only riding the ” democracy bandwagon “….trumpting their achievements on the grave of BB….what happened ? – soon we will be declared a failed state.We will be worse than many African Countries….Recommend

  • Amir
    Jun 21, 2012 - 1:59PM

    Blamming india is ridiculous. It is our own fault.

    With consumption and requirement going up, hydel power share has obviously dropped due to generation shifting to gas/fuel plants. And how many more hydel dams/plants have we built? Our two largest are Tarbella and Mangla.

    There has been no policy as to what alternate energy sources could be tapped. There is potential in coal (Thar), wind and solar. Have we even considered investing in this?


  • Imran
    Jun 21, 2012 - 2:14PM

    @Mr. Righty Rightist

    Most of the Pakistan’s electricity generation depends on oil and gas, not Indus water. There is also agriculture lobby which consumes most of the water leaving only little for power generation.


  • Jun 21, 2012 - 3:09PM

    How many ACs, machines, fans, refrigerators, TVs, grinders, mixies, lights are purchased in a year without a provision for their electricity consumption.


  • Cautious
    Jun 21, 2012 - 6:24PM

    I wonder how many of the protestors don’t pay their utility bills?


More in Pakistan