Afghan corruption feeding unrest: Experts

Published: April 13, 2012
Corruption is enabling the drug trade to thrive and pushing Afghans towards the Taliban, analysts warn.

Corruption is enabling the drug trade to thrive and pushing Afghans towards the Taliban, analysts warn.

KABUL: After a decade of war and billions of dollars in Western aid, Afghanistan is drowning in a tide of corruption that is exacerbating conflict and stifling economic development, experts say.

Corruption is enabling the drug trade to thrive and pushing Afghans towards the Taliban, analysts warn — fuelling the two drivers of instability in the war-torn country.

Mohammad Shafiq Hamdam, head of the Afghan Anti-corruption Network, said graft lies at the heart of most of the country’s problems.

“If there are cases of infiltration in the army, it’s corruption. If there are cases of smuggling heroin out of the country, within the country, it’s corruption,” he said.

In January, an Afghan soldier killed five of his French trainers at a base in Kapisa, in the country’s northeast. According to the US news website McClatchy, he bribed a recruiter first to join the Afghan army and then again to rejoin after deserting.

Corruption among the security forces is rife — the interior ministry recently sacked 70 police officers in western Afghanistan.

“I’ll never say that the first problem of Afghanistan is security. The first one is corruption,” said Mohammad Qasem Halimi, of the Asia Foundation NGO.

With checkpoints at the entry to built-up areas, militants can only get in because of corrupt police, he said.

Around 3,000 Afghan civilians were killed in the conflict last year, a third by the Taliban’s improvised bombs, according to the UN.

“Police officers don’t catch the insurgents because they’re corrupt. If they do, these guys are released as they pay for the judge.”

Halimi is a former official with the Supreme Court, and said he had ordered the arrest of 182 judges in the five years he served there.

“In the last five years we have sacked 207 Supreme Court employees, including 65 judges and 70 administrative staff, for corruption,” Supreme Court spokesman Abdul Wakil Omari said.

In a country that produces 90 percent of the world’s opium, drugs are another huge problem.

Sayed Habib, head of drug addiction problems at the health ministry, in February denounced what he called the “linkages” between organised criminals and the ministry for counter-narcotics.

“There is widespread corruption within the government organs,” said Azizullah Lodin, the chairman of the High office of anti-corruption.

Gesturing through his office window, he lamented the impunity enjoyed by criminals with political connections.

“Look! This is government land, but powerful people came here and built houses,” he said. “I see people coming back from Iran and Pakistan and they don’t even have a small room whereas the powerful ones capture this public land.

“If you can’t deal with those big buildings, how can you deal with the people under the bridges?”

The near-collapse in 2010 of the Kabul Bank, the country’s biggest private lender responsible for paying 80 percent of government employees came to symbolise the extent of the country’s graft problem.

Its owners, including brothers of Karzai and his vice-president, were accused of pocketing $900 million in illegal loans, prompting the International Monetary Fund to suspend hundreds of millions of dollars of international aid.

More recently, the disappearance of $42 million from the budget of Kabul’s main military hospital and the $60 million missing from the coffers of customs in Herat caused a national scandal.

Even junior officials use whatever power they have to squeeze extra money for doing their job. The going rate for a passport is $100 to $500 and the public health system works on the same basis.

An Asia Foundation survey of 6,500 people around the country last year found that corruption was the number three concern among Afghans, after employment worries and Taliban attacks.

In 2010 Transparency International named Afghanistan as the world’s second most corrupt country — tied with Myanmar — behind Somalia.

Corruption “represents one of the main obstacles to sustainable peace in Afghanistan,” Wolfgang Weisbrod Weber, a UN envoy formerly in Afghanistan, said in December.

Hamdam of the Afghan Anti-corruption Network, said frustration with corruption was driving people to side with the militants.

“The reason why people are joining the Taliban is because of this fake legitimacy which is linked to corruption. The Taliban have no other legitimacy in this country, no other excuse,” he said.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (2)

  • Apr 13, 2012 - 6:14PM

    Completely agreed with Mr. Halimi. Corruption is even more contiguous in the Afghan justice system in which prompts people to refer to the clustered “Taliban Justice Commissions” for getting their disputes resolved in the areas where both the Taliban and government struggles to take control. In contrast to the government’s painfully slow legal procedures and corruption; the Taliban deliver a swift and transparent justice to the people and above all; the justice is always guaranteed in the cases they resolve.

    The Afghan Taliban and TTP should be officially allowed to run their Sharia based justice systems in their areas of control, if both governments can’t really implement the Sharia law completely.


  • j. von hettlingen
    Apr 14, 2012 - 3:57AM

    Rampant corruption among government officials at a time when millions of Afghan refugees returend from Iran and Pakistan, led to widespread disenchantment and fuelled the support for the Taliban. Members of Karzai’s clan have Kandahar as their realm of influence and nothing can be done without paying bribes to his siblings. Despite foreign aid for reconstruction and infrastructure, the money seeped away into their pockets.


More in World