Sectarianism and non-state actors

There is a pattern in sectarian killings in Pakistan whether one likes to see it or not.

Editorial April 04, 2012

In Gilgit-Baltistan (GB), the cities of Gilgit and Chilas have suffered sectarian violence, and so far 16 lives have been lost and dozens injured. Gilgit city experienced reactive violence from events taking place in Chilas suffering 6 killed and 40 injured. And Chilas avenged the Gilgit violence through frenzied mobs that killed nine innocent citizens. It was the banned Sipah Sahaba in its new incarnation of Ahle Sunnat wal Jamaat that started the violence in Gilgit while protesting the arrest of one of its leaders. A mob of thousands marched to Karakoram Highway, intercepted a convoy of buses heading towards Gilgit, and killed 10 passengers after a show of ID cards. This was a repeat of what had happened earlier in Kohistan in neighbouring Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa when buses travelling to Gilgit were intercepted and 16 Shia passengers were asked to disembark and then shot dead.

There is a pattern in sectarian killings in Pakistan whether one likes to see it or not. The minority sect of the Shia is first apostatised through fatwas by extremist clergy and then targeted by armed men, some of whom may have served as ‘mujahideen’ and fought the state’s proxy wars. GB’s administration is helpless, and the military moves in with its usual curfew and shoot-to-kill orders. The region has always been under the tutelage of the military because of the proximity of the Kashmir border and because non-state actors are usually affiliated with Sunni outfits. A similar situation exists in Kurram Aagency where the headquarters of the agency, Parachinar, is Shia-majority but gets in the way of the foreign terrorists (most of whom are Sunni) who take shelter in Pakistan and the local Taliban warlords going into Afghanistan. The Shia Hazaras of Quetta are being targeted by the same elements while in Karachi the steady rise of the sectarian Sunni terrorist outfits is having the same effect as well. Since the non-state ‘warriors’ are anti-American, the blame is put on a “foreign conspiracy” — something that all sides buy into because of a shared revulsion for America.

The demography of the region is as follows: Gilgit has approximately one million inhabitants equally divided among Shia, Sunni and Ismaili populations. Into this map walked in the jihadi-religious parties. What was changed by the intrusion of Pakistani religious conflict was the cement of qawm (caste), language and region which had kept Gilgit peaceful for many years and had help maintain a sectarian balance.

The Shia have been squeezed a bit by the increase in the Sunni-Pakhtun population through ingress and through unrestrained jihadi radicalisation. The war against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan set the ball rolling because the Shia were not accepted in Pakistan as mujahideen and there was a difference of approach to the Afghan war between Iran and Pakistan, the latter being allied to Saudi Arabia which headed an Arab reaction to Revolutionary Iran.

The Shia majority in the Northern Areas in no way disadvantaged Islamabad as it faced Ladakh on the Indian side. But the population began to be seen by General Zia’s regime as posing a potential threat after 1980. Sectarian violence began there in 1988 as a result of Islamabad’s Iran policy. In 1988, a Shia-Sunni dispute in Gilgit over Eid led to a Sunni lashkar that comprised thousands of people from Mansehra, Chilas (GB), Kohistan and other areas in the then NWFP. In the rampage that followed, hundreds, mostly Shias, were killed, scores of villages were pillaged and burned, and even livestock was slaughtered.

In 1999, it was on General Musharraf’s watch as army chief that Pakistan’s Kashmir jihad policy increased the ranks of Islamic extremists in the Northern Areas. The Kargil conflict resulted in the influx of Sunni jihadi elements into the region. Extremist organisations like Sipah Sahaba, Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Muhammad, Al-Ikhwan and Harkatul Mujahideen opened their offices there, upsetting the demographic balance.

Today the sectarian conflict — together with the rise of the 40-party Difah-e-Pakistan Council — is the most glaring symptom of state implosion brought on by internal loss of writ of the state and wilful international isolation.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 5th, 2012.

Our Publications


Hussain Nagri | 9 years ago | Reply Dear Shabir Mir Sahib… Express Tribune is a wide reading news across the Globe for reliable news……But the problem is some journalists r vocalizing the Sectarian volatile scenario of Gilgit Baltistan at one sided…….There should be truth regardless cast, creed and religion as you a journalist from Gilgit Baltistan. You are an eye witness of the Gilgit Violence. You know well that No Hand grenade was thrown on Rally but some culprits were trying to throw it on Police man and it burst out in the hand of a culprit himself. There should be a code of conduct to provide information from print and electronic media to uphold standards of morality, fairness, accuracy, respect of privacy. All the journalists should avoid slanderous, libelous, biased and unconfirmed reports. The content that encourages terrorist or incites discrimination or hatred on grounds of religion, or sect which again disgrace the journalist or tends to undermine the integrity of Gilgit Baltistan should be avoided. In above picture you are trying to show nothing except protection to Terrorists of Kohistan and Chilas Killings………What Else….Can you please answer me whether in Kohistan on 28th February, 16 Sunnis Killed? Or Yesterday (3rd April, 2012) in Chilas, District Diamer 24 Sunnis after checking their ID cards and identifying with names like Ali, Hussain, Hassan, Abbas Killed…or in Konodas the street walker who were on way to their home to Danyore, Jalalabad and Nagar had been shot dead………..Nooo.. they were all Shia Istha Ashries…….Even in Gilgit What is going on/or to be, due to discrimination or one sided news. I appreciate there should be freedom of expression and public awareness on the real issues…..I am not favoring Shias or Sunnis terrorist activities in Gilgit Baltistan……….But we should provide the true and existent stories to discourage the extremist of any sect. This should be our Mission to create harmony among all sects who are tenants of Gilgit Baltistan since many eras. Thank you.
Zaigham Abbas | 9 years ago | Reply

The State is equally responsible for the hatred people feel for the other sect. When people feel that they are being denied opportunities, they will definitely develop hatred. The State has been using the Jihadists for its dirty work in Kashmir ad Afghanistan and in return , has turned a blind eye to their activities and atrocities against the other sects, which they deem worthy of being killed.This has led to a general perception among the minority sects that the state is not safeguarding their rights and they have to do it themselves.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ