Democracy without decorum

Ms Bukhari should be disqualified for slapping a polling officer as she visited a polling station in her constituency.

Editorial February 27, 2012

The image of the PPP candidate for PS-53 in Tando Mohammad Khan soundly slapping a polling officer as she visited a polling station in her constituency, shook everyone who saw the pictures captured on film. Many recoiled with the Assistant Presiding Officer Shagufta Memon, as PPP candidate Waheeda Shah Bukhari’s hand hit her full across the face. The follow-up has not been very convincing either. At a press conference held at the home of Ms Bukhari — who won her seat to the Sindh Assembly through the by-poll — Ms Memon has stated the whole incident was the result of a “misunderstanding” and that the angry candidate had taken her for an agent of her rival, Mir Mushtaque Ali Talpur.

This is absurd because if one goes by the footage that has been aired, it seems as if the slap was more or less unprovoked. Furthermore, even it was a ‘misunderstanding’, as has been now claimed, it does not even remotely qualify as appropriate behaviour, especially of a candidate for a provincial parliament. People who contest elections to become public representatives — and as such models for their communities — should not be using violence at polling stations, or their clout to physically assault polling officers. In this case, of course, the ‘beating’ was quite literal in nature. One doesn’t really need to be a rocket scientist to figure out that the polling official who was slapped is being made to come out with this ridiculous ‘misunderstanding’ ruse. In any case, the candidate, who apparently won the election, has not bothered to explain why she chose to slap anyone at all. In this age of television and with a media that seems to have a hawk eye on such things, it is next to impossible to distort facts.

The new, permanent Election Commission of Pakistan has said it is looking into the incident. The case for it is clear. Ms Bukhari should be disqualified since quite clearly the grounds for doing so are for everyone to see. This will send a signal to all candidates for public office that they cannot get away with such shameful acts.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 28th, 2012.

Our Publications


paki | 9 years ago | Reply

wow maya khan blog have about 215 comments with everyone speaking about ethical and unethical behvaiour . and here just two comments .. so people just like masala stories .. we are debating maya khan apology accepted not accepted no online campiagn for our so called public servent ruthless behaviour here .. did she even cared to explain or apologize .. utterly disgusting ..

Qamar Zaidi | 9 years ago | Reply

This is shameful; there is no need of complainants’ written report to start an action against Waheeda Shah. The written incident report will definitely strengthen the case against the newly elected politician. She does not deserve to be a member of parliament representing the constituents whom she slapped publicly. I was always a PPP voter until I was living in Pakistan. However, I strongly reject such behaviour from the members who claim to be representative of peoples' party. Waheeda Shah must pay the price of her ruthless, uncontrolled reaction towards the polling staff. She should be punished for her crime and as a result should lose the won election.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ