Why charge Dr Shakil Afridi with treason?

Punishment for conviction of treason is the death penalty, this would be harsh given the individual he helped capture.


Letter February 16, 2012

JUBAIL, SAUDI ARABIA: Nations and countries decide their policies keeping in mind the national interest. In this regard, I would like to ask your readers, as well as those sitting in government and in other institutions deciding policy matters: how can Dr Shakil Afridi be accused of treason?

Will someone please tell me how helping catch the world’s most sought-after terrorist amount to betrayal of the state? Was Osama bin Laden not responsible for the deaths of several thousand people and have not al Qaeda and its affiliates created havoc inside Pakistan and killed thousands of innocent Pakistanis? There must be many Pakistanis who are angry with efforts by a Republic member of the US Congress to confer America’s highest civilian award to the doctor, who allegedly helped the Americans track Bin Laden in Abbottabad.

The punishment for conviction of treason is the death penalty. It seems, however, that this would be too harsh given the individual that Dr Afridi helped capture.

Masood Khan

Published in The Express Tribune, February 17th, 2012.

COMMENTS (6)

Saleem | 12 years ago | Reply

He had used a very noble profession to cover up espionage for a foreign country without caring the aftermaths for his own country. Many people in Pakistan especially in tribal areas believe that the people who are aid workers are in fact CIA agents and they are attacked and made hostage in these areas. This incident has made the work of these people very difficult and more dangerous as it confirms their suspicions. Many people believe that these vaccinations are in fact a conspiracy of the western countries to make Pakistanis impotent. This is the reason many people do not give their kids Polio vaccinations. He must be tried on these charges also. This is the position we need to take as a nation to reduce the pressure on Pakistan for his release.

Rana Amjad | 12 years ago | Reply

Khan Sahib, You are 100% correct but who would tell our "ARMY GENERALS" and beloved :MULLAHS" who think they know what is good for the country.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ