Underlying the belief structure of the political leadership is the arrogant notion that if ‘we’ can somehow make Balochistan like ‘us’, the issue will be resolved. The PPP and its allies came out with the Aghaz-e-haqooq-e-Balochistan package, formulated in a developmental mould; more projects, money, government jobs, etc. It was followed by the new National Finance Commission (NFC) criteria, which gave weight to geographical location as well as degree of backwardness. In addition to the NFC revenue resources, the Eighteenth Amendment allowed part ownership of natural resources. Only the NFC has been implemented in letter though, not in spirit. Recently, Mian Nawaz Sharif offered an apology but no solution; more motorways, Gwadars, yellow cabs, Danish schools and medical colleges are what he must be thinking of when his time comes. The naivete of both the government and Mian Sahib was surpassed by Imran Khan’s offer that “we” would do for Balochistan, what West Germany did for East Germany after unification. West Germany forced a sudden rush into market fundamentalism, destroying the industry and institutions of what was once the most developed economy of the Soviet bloc. East Germany withered away as a political entity but not as a distinct social reality. In this colonial discourse of transformation, its residents were brothers if they transformed and adapted, and fossils of the past if they did not.
The analogy was most unfortunate. The East Germans pulled down the Berlin Wall to the utter surprise of the West Germans. The Baloch have done no such thing and nor do they want to. In effect, they were independent at the time of the Partition, which brought them under direct central control. One Unit submerged them into West Pakistan. In 1970, they were made a province. When the province attempted to exercise its autonomy under the 1973 Constitution, the government was dismissed and a military operation started. Now, it is not under an operation. It is under military rule. A ‘Berlin Wall’ has been raised around Balochistan. Need one be surprised when the Baloch laugh at the “we” in the pronouncements of the political leaders! They don’t want anything from ‘us’. They just want control over whatever is left of their own resources.
Failure to recognise this is no more just an existential threat to the state. It is fast becoming a reality, as Yousuf Nazar’s recently-published book, Balkanisation and Political Economy of Pakistan, so ably argues: “the idea of Pakistan, if not the writ, has become a questionable and a sore topic in Balochistan which constitutes 48 per cent of the country’s land area and despite being rich in natural resources is the poorest of the provinces, with simmering anger and alienation bloodied by a low intensity insurgency”.
Published in The Express Tribune, January 6th, 2012.
COMMENTS (36)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
agreed
@Cynical: hahahaha. not u punjabis ruled sub-continent instead it was ruled by Mughals, Lodhis, Sayeds etc. Britain went gave u a country to rule, u people are not experienced and civilized lost half of the country as Bangladesh and now history will again repeat itself and another half will get rid of u ppl as Independent Balochistan.
@Ali Salman you are living in a fools paradise.
@Pakistani First: oh ridiculous mr, raja is not wrong, ur dream seems to be the same which was seen for Bangladesh ...
@Usman: u seem to be making ridicule of urself, while commenting like this, u have many examples in the history, and the best is the bengladesh, u could not exploit BD resources..... and many other nations in the world expected like u and failed. try to be conscious.
Those who forget that they are muslims first, fall into the trap of the enemies of Islam. They want to divide muslims into smaller and smaller countries so that they can enslave them further. Once the Ottoman empire was disbanded, muslims became a weak force as now they were divided into multiple states where before there was one. Those who want to divide muslims, are enemies of Allah and what a miserable state awaits them.
@iftikhar khan: why isn’t the deliberate killings of punjabi civilians in balochistan given any media coverage? This is because the history is always written by the victor! The reason for this is the same as why the plight of Hindus forced out of Kashmir is never mentioned but the 'atrocitiesz' against Kashmiri Moslems are headlines. And J&K is part of Hindu-majority Republic of India!
Do something before its too late... whence you can do nothing but just sigh......
@Cynical: Are u ok ?
I have lived in Balochistan and most Balochi people are angry because there is no wealth being shared with them while their resources are exploited to the fullest and are fueling the rest of the country. Given them autonomy for god sake!!!
@saleem: "Lousy Stats" never heard of that term, glad you didn't find them inaccurate, because they are not. These are stats and facts and do not include any interpetation . You are free to make any conclusions based on them. These are "post ZIA" if you read my post correctly, thats why they do not include Zia or anyone before him.
I recently returned from Quetta after interacting with couple of nationalist parties for some professional work. Although these parties boycotted the elections, now they seem willing to come back and join the mainstream. The President of National Party, Senator Dr. Abdul Malik, an astute political worker, apologized his people for boycotting the elections. He worked up the political career over 30 years to become the elected president of the party, which is perhaps the only party in Pakistan besides JI, where strict internal democracy is respected. The nationalists are merging in the national discourse, just like the ANP has done already after maintaining greater Afghanistan agenda for half a century. The story of natural resources as we are told is more myth than reality, as I also visited the Geological Survey, headquartered in Quetta, and made an impression that we have lot of false positive perceptions. Anyways the message here is that not all is lost, and it is not all difficult to keep the people from Balochistan with us. They need, more than anything else, an understanding and respect for their independence. 18th amendment is a great milestone towards stronger federation and is greatly admired by political leaders in all the small provinces. There are extremist elements everywhere and more so in Balochistan but I think their influence on Baloch opinion is exaggerated by a great degree. We need more information on ground before we make our assessment. The pessimism reflected in Pervez Tahir article and Nazar book seems not well-founded.
50% of the population of Baluchistan is Pushtun and they WANT TO remain a part of Pakistan. Why do these analysts always ignore the Pushtuns of Baluchistan???
dear usman, you are wrong in stating that the natural resources of Balochistan belong to every Pakistani, your statement is completely illogical and appalling....... I think you are not much aware of the history of Balochistan, people like you add fuel to the fire by saying such non-sense things....Rather then developing Balochistan by federal Government, you are saying that the natural resources of Balochistan should equally be accessible.......... read the history of Balochistan then come to a logical conclusion...
@Uamr, Your stats are just lousy stats, Ayub Khan became GOC in 1953 and since all Govt have been controlled by the Army , including 1958-69 direct Ayub President , Yahya 1969 to 1971 then direct Zia 1977 to 86 and then again Musharraf 1999 to 2008 ( that urdu of musharraf means nothing as he was Army head.), except for 72-77 of Bhutto and earlier 1947-51 by Liaqat were without Army control and look who killed them
Balochistan need freedom from Armed Forces and their Rights From Pakistan.....
@Uamr:
Good job putting statistics together. I would put 3 yrs and 1 month of no PM in Musharaf/Urdu basket because he was "Chief Executive" during that time. So combined Urdu speaking rule goes up to 13 yrs 6 months.
@Ahmed:
Here are some post Zia stats for you, which covers last quarter century.
Presidents:
Gulam Ishaq Khan Pashtoon 17 Aug 88-18 Jul 93 5 yrs Wasim Sajjad Punjabi 18 Jul 93-14 Nov 93 4 months Farooq Leghari Baluchi 14 Nov 93-2 Dec 97 4 yrs Wasim Sajjad Punjabi 2 Dec 97- 1 Jan 98 2 months Rafiq Tarar Punjabi 1 Jan 98-20 Jun 01 3yrs 6 months Pervez Musharraf Urdu 20 Jun 01-18Aug 08 7yrs 2 months Muhammad Soomro Sindhi 18 Aug – 9 Sep 08 less than a month Asif Zardari Sindhi/Baluch 9 Sep 08 till Present 3 yrs 4 months
Urdu : 7 yrs 2 months Pashtoon : 5 yrs Baluchi : 4 yrs Punjabi : 4 yrs Sindhi : 3 years 5 months total and going
Prime ministers:
Benazir Bhutto Sindhi 2 Dec 88-6 Aug90 1 yrs 8 months Ghulam Mustafa Jatoi Sindhi 6 Aug1990-6 Nov 90 3 months Nawaz Sharif Kashmiri/Punjabi 6 Nov 90-18 Apr 93 2 yrs 5 months Balakh Sher Mazari Baluchi 18 Apr 93-26 May 93 1 month Nawaz Sharif Kashmiri/Punjabi26 May 93-18 Jul 93 2 months Moeenuddin Qureshi Punjabi 18 Jul 93-19 Oct 93 3 months Benazir Bhutto Sindhi 19 Oct 93-5 Nov 96 3 yrs 1 month Malik Meraj Khalid Punjabi 5 Nov 96-17 Feb 97 4.5 months Nawaz Sharif Kashmiri/Punjabi 17 Feb 97-12 Oct 99 2 yrs 8 months No PM 12 Oct 99-21 Nov 02 3 yrs 1 month Zafarullah Jamali Baluchi 21 Nov 02-26 Jun 04 1 yr 7 months Shujaat Hussain Punjabi 30 Jun 04-20 Aug 04 2 months Shaukat Aziz Urdu 20 Aug 04-6 Nov 07 3 yrs 3 months Muhammad Soomro Sindhi 16 Nov07-25 Mar 08 4 months Yousaf Raza Gillani Seraiki 25 Mar08-present 3 yrs 10 months
Kashmiri/Punjabi: 6 yr 1 month Sindhi : 5 yrs 4 months Seraiki: 3 yrs 10 months Urdu: 3 yrs 3 months Baluchi : 1 yr 8 months No PM : 3 yrs 1 month
Combined:
Ethnicity Total yrs Percent ruled Population %age (president + Prime minister)
Urdu: 10 yrs 5 months 23.80 % 7.53 % Kashmiri/Punjabi: 10 yrs 1 month 23.04 % 42.15 % Sindhi : 8 yrs 9 months 20.0 % 14.10 % Baluchi: 5 yrs 8 months 12.96 % 3.57 % Pashtoon: 5 yrs 11.43 % 17.42 % Seraiki: 3 yrs 10 months 8.76 % 10.53 %
Avery bold and perfect anyalysis. The only solution so far available to solve the Baloch problem is to give them complete control over their resources and coastal area and do not interfere in their provincial matters. As per Sardar Attaullah's assertions that Baloch is at the verge of "point of no return therefore" and if the government (Military and Civilain establishment) did not realize this fact than there are ample chnaces that history will repeat itself once again. And this time Pakistan is not in a position to afford the separattion of Balochistan. Therefore, I would say that people like Zahid Hamid must come out from the fool's paradise and face the realities. Baloch nation is burning since 2002 and I did not come across a single protest launched by any other ethnic group other than Baloch.
What is the reality, no one can sepress the peoples voice by guns or force. do not mis calculate baloch 5%. the watch nidle is clicking and the time is getting out of hand. pls relise the fact balouch are also human being and do not treat them as animal. you hate and need our land.. this is unpossible.
Neither the mutaliated bodies Of the balochs have been given coverage. Don't count yourself innocent in this platform, balochs have suffered a lot due to existance of punjabi led government.
This article is an eye opener. With only 5% of population and 44% of land mass (which contains vast natural resources) as @Naseem Islam suggests, Balochistan has the possibilty of having highest per capita income in the region.The temptation of going separate can be overwhelmimg.
@Akbar Ismail
You fail to see the optimism and ambition in @Zaid Hamid's post.Instead of ridiculing him you should encourage all Pakistanis who have greater vision and a matching ambition, if you want to see Pakistan as the ruler of this sub continent.Don't forget that we have ruled this sub continent (including Afghanistan) for many hundred years.
A perfect and bold analysis on Balochistan issue. The author has in depth knowledge of Balochistan conflict unlike other so called analysts and anchors. Its also a slap on the face of those who blame Baloch for whatever wrong is taking place in Balochistan
There are only 66 lakh Baloch i.e. less than 5% of Pakistan's population. The province forms 44% of land area rich in natural resources.Talk of development by politicians to the Baloch, means influx of non Baloch and ''Red Indianisation'' of Balochi in Balochistan. The nationalists see their situation as similar to say Dubai, where the local population is in a minority. They want via the constitution guarantee that Baloch remain in control of Balochistan, while outsiders may share economic benefits yet have no political role.
But big business in Pakistan (they need energy and natural resources of Balochistan) among others may have calculated that subduing 1 or 2 lakh rebel baloch is doable, hence the conflict.
@Zaid Hamid: And by the way, how will you make Greater Pakistan by 2014? Dreams of ruling over and India and Afghanistan will always remain dreams. Wake up and understand the realities of the world.
Balochistan should be given freedom from pakistan or else we may face 1971 from indians again
@Raja: Mr.Raja your dream will never come true. Baluchistan will always remain the fourth wheel of Pakistan. You might want to focus on the multiple insurgencies going on in various parts of India and leave our country alone.
Thanks. Until the independent free country of Balochistan is established there can be no peace in South Asia.
Balochistan, Afghanistan, Hindustan...everything belongs to Pakistan....The Greater Pakistan...by 2014...wait and watch
Balochis are free to live and work anywhere in the country including Punjab, just like in any other normal country. Similarly Balochistan is part of Pakistan and it's resources are every Pakistani's and that is how will remain. Get used to it and start working for a solution to quell is ridiculous insurgency which.
What about the Baloch feudals who set new records of oppression and torture even among Pakistani feudals ? Baloch people themself are stuck between a rock and a hard place. An indifferent and exploitive Government & Brutal and backbreaking Feudal lords.
Dr Sahib, I hope Imran Khan reads your piece, as he is not thinking just speaking and neither are the target recipients of his messages.
why isn't the deliberate killings of punjabi civilians in balochistan given any media coverage? why don't our tv channels ever take the interviews of the families of the punjabi teachers,doctors,labourers who have been killed in their hundreds in balochistan in the last few years? no condemnations,no tv anchors taking to task the killers of these civilians.people have been killed after checking the ID cards on buses and upon finding punjabi names,the people were taken off buses and shot dead.no columns in newspapers,no talk shows,no tweets for these innocent civilians murdered.