Sadly, their integrity and commitment to the country, the motherland, has always remained questionable. It reminds me of a phrase uttered by a jittery American that some years back created such uproar here; “Pakistanis would sell their mother to get what they want”. Of course, not all Pakistanis will do that and, rightly, the gentleman was widely condemned and rebutted. But I am not sure about those who have been selling Pakistan’s vital interests to foreign powers and such elements have been associated with all types of regimes — civilian, military and hybrid, and not just the present regime and the character or characters involved in the writing of the memo. In Pakistan, many characters, families, groups and power brokers, from the early days to the present, have compromised the country’s interests to capture or stay in power through foreign support, which has come readily for a price — the surrendering of national interests.
The surfacing of this memo is beyond controversy and beyond plausible deniability, as all the thick covers that Mr Haqqani, the Presidency and the Prime Minster’s Secretariat weaved with care have fallen down like straws. Admiral Mike Mullen couldn’t do Haqqani’s bidding, which the great ambassador of the Islamic Republic expected. What he and others supporting him in Pakistan have done is what habitual thieves caught red-handed have done—told brazen lies with a bold, straight face. Don’t forget, the ruling syndicate falls back on ‘conspiracy’ as its last refuge and defence when it find no argument or facts to counter evidence against it, whether it is with regards to systematic corruption or working for foreign powers.
Admiral Mike Mullen has dropped a daisy-cutter on the heads of the trio — Asif Ali Zardari, Yousaf Raza Gilani and Husain Haqqani — busting all the lies and denials. We must admire the integrity and honourable conduct of the Admiral, which presents a contrasting picture of the integrity of honourable men and women.
What ramifications might the memo have for politics of Pakistan? First of all, the issue cannot be pushed under the rug anymore; it is too public, in the open and, through the media, the talk of the town. It will definitely add to the general unrest and disquiet about the present regime, which survives only through trickery and secret dealings inside and outside.
A storm that Imran Khan’s message of hope has inspired is already brewing at popular level. Will he capture this moment to take the movement to the next step — civil disobedience? That is the only way to save democracy from the ‘democrats’.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 21st, 2011.
COMMENTS (29)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Wow, If Dr. Rais sahab can be so blunt; the issue is serious. Civil disobedience is the only way, but I am not sure about the Captain's capabilities with no team. However, thanks for enlightening Pakistanis is such a direct way. You need to do this more often.
Very nice.....& for all those who are thinking that rasul baksh is calling army are totally wrong..rasul baksh is democratic person and thats why he is calling for democratic change..because this govt has done alot of things under the majority rule though not democratic rule
An excellent article...time to take action and take them to task.
@ Ishrat Salim, how sure you are that once democracy is killed, poor people will start getting basic needs of life?
@Doc: Thanks Saif for mentioning my course "Theory and Practice of Non-Violence--Gandhi, Ghaffar Khan, Martin Luther King Jr." in your comments. Most of our readers and general public is not much aware of the intellectual thought that has shaped the modern world, including society and politics, particularly the democratic politics. Therefore, my reference to 'civil disobedience' may be misunderstood. It is a conscientious, peaceful and democratic way of changing a government that has turned against the state, peoples and society. In the present circumstances that face, I sincerely believe that the Pakistani youth and urban middle classes can change the course of Pakistan and its history by peaceful protest and civil-disobedience. If we do it now and throw the traitors out of power, never will they ever be able to capture power again. Your reference inspires me to do the next column on civil disobedience. Thanks. RBR
Sir, reading your very last paragraph reminded me of a course you taught at LUMS: "Theory and Practice of Non-violence: Gandhi, Ghaffar Khan and King". This would be time consuming, but could we have an article on the social features of the era that gave birth to the three movements? Common as well as distinguishing features? I realize now that your course was a treasure-trove of information which can enable us to view our "leaders", their "followers", the armed forces and the comatoze state machinery in a different light. I pray for your health. Your student, Saif Hassan Siddiqui, 09 Batch.
@Akhtar Rao, you have selected provoking lines.Politicians should understand that they are something due to Pakistan.Issue cannot be pushed under rug anymore it must be dig out.
@Akhtar Rao, you have selected the most provoking lines. Politicians should understand that they are everything due to Pakistan.Yes, of course the issue cannot be pushed under the rug anymore,it must be dig out as it can be.This nation cannot tolerate such blunders anymore.
. Wonderful comments by " Sincere".
The Golden lines: The power cliques and their minions have played every possible trick to grab power, stay in power and use power for personal ends.Never had they any feeling for the people who apparently ‘voted’ for them, or the country that has raised them, given them the social standing, power and prestige that they enjoy, which allows them to move around the country and abroad, mighty and tall."the issue cannot be pushed under the rug anymore".
Sincere@ I wonder who you are? I cannot differ whatever you have lucidly said in your comments.We really do not need to test the old politicians,but should give opportunity to the new leadership. I agreed, Imran Khan has to realize the people's pain.Once he has able to convince the mass that he would be the next fair leader believe me the fate of country would be different.
Mr. Clean, Imran Khan, is having heaps of the hopes from the same AZMOODAs politicians.They can change the destiny of this country.Let him spend his life as an ordinary person first,has to leave luxary life styels, will have to be practicle. He should go to visit the small towns,villiges,huts and hubs of Pakistan.Change cannot come with Stage Shows,he has to see the bitter realities of the people those are suffering and living with sufferings for the last many years. Corruption is rooted in all fields,amazingly majority of corrupt is joining him. Rasul Bakhsh, we can pray for our beloved Pakistan but we cannot trust these politicians anymore no matter who is who?
Agreed 1000,000,000 % @Jee
@ Jee, even if its not real democracy, it has saved us from total destruction. Imagine, if Kargil, Mumbai attacks and OBL drama were staged in a dictator's regime.
I have never read anything so blunt and 'nationalistic' from Mr Rais before.He is usually cautious in his comments for him to say these things he has to be quite sure about the culpability of the authors of the memo.
Mr Ijaz maybe controversial however his arguments he has given till now make alot more sence then the weak and unconvincing response from Haqqani and his party leaders.
These people need to be probed sooner rather then later for the interest of Pakistan and credibility of their leadership.However they need to be given a fair chance to explain them selves,If found guilty Pakistan needs to seriously question all those at the helm of its affairs and weed out the traitors before they fatally damage this nation.
One odd thing one notices about Mr Haqqani still finding time to tweet with his buddies on Twitter till Nov 19th.Odd considering he was clarifying some remarks he had made more then 10 yrs ago about some security issues reg India.
It speaks of arrogance and misplaced priorities at the wrong time.
@Ch Allah Daad - What democracy??? It has always been a wolf in sheeps clothing for many decades. How can one kill democracy when in reality it never existed!!! It just a facade, a form of deception and betrayal against its people!!
Traitors are those who are asking army and other immature forces to kill democracy in Pakistan. Americans cannot wage a war against a democratic country. Its American wish to kill democracy first, once its done, murderers of democracy will be begging Americans to forgive them.
Looks like you see a window of opportunity to bring in establishment man via backdoor. The paid govt servants (ISI) which acts as master of Pakistani electorate and the owner of all resources always raid the elected govts of Pakistan with regularity and without any punishment for high treason. The memo is not worth the paper it is written on and already the "educated" people are taking it with the words of US Admiral as page from a holy book. The good Admiral cannot lie and is patriotic to US interests in that you are right. However, what does the same admiral say about the army and ISI's harboring the terrorists? You cannot "use" the Admiral only when it suits the undemocratic forces and their touts.
Looks like AZ's is going to get the "Bhutto" treatment from the establishment! AZ should avoid visiting Liaquat National Bagh or Rawalpindi any time soon.
The dirty tricks brigade of isi including rasul baksh is out with daggers at HH. Shame on this ghairat brigade.
@Max True, both are in trouble, Mansoor also has to save his position in Washington (and ensure his word gets taken seriously) and Haqqani has to save his job. Between the two whoever gets the chopping block will only be an advantage for Pakistan.
zardari has committed treason.
The chickens have come home to roost. . There is no presidential immunity for acts of treason.
Hats off to your sir for being blunt and saying it out loud on ET! It won't go down too well with our progressive policy and 'defence analysts'on Twitter.
VERY NICE!
Rasul Bakhsh my dear, I agree with you on every word but the last paragraph, and please keep in mind that Mansoor Ijaz is is no angel. This guy was spitting venom for last several years and all of sudden he becomes a champion of Pakistan' national interest (if there is one). Is it change of heart or someone is pulling his strings from behind the scene. I do not agree with you on the last paragraph as I do not expect this coming from a political scientist. Please, for God sake, do not mix up popular aspirations/frustrations of the people with populism. We have seen so many Messiahs and with lot more charisma.