“We are clear that economic engagement, removing barriers to trade and facilitating land transport will help the region. Eventually, economic and industrial activity will bring prosperity and stability. It will generate jobs and help the South Asian region,” said Commerce and Industry Minister Anand Sharma.
The Punjab, Haryana and Delhi Chamber of Commerce and Industry (PHDCCI) said the move “will herald a new era in economic relations between the two countries”.
However the trade facilitation organisation, Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), added that outstanding issues which acted as trade barriers needed to be addressed. “Roadblocks like stringent visa rules, non-tariff barriers, communication difficulties and the opening of more trade routes like Wagah still need to be addressed,” said CII Director General Chandrajit Banerjee.
PHDCCI President Salil Bhandari said there was a need to bridge the information gap between the two countries. Investors from both the countries need to have greater awareness about the goods/services and markets of the other. “The governments of both sides should think of setting up of bonded warehouses cum-display centres at the border where goods from both sides could be available. Permission for ‘on-the-spot-sales’ of the displayed goods would further enhance its utility and help in increasing mutual awareness, Bhandari pointed out.
He suggested that one day in a month should be dedicated to each country for such sales. “People from Pakistan can come across the border on a particular day and vice versa. This can happen at the Wagah border,” he suggested.
Trade lobbies in India are assessing how to take advantage of the move.
China, US hails move
Meanwhile, the move by Pakistan was hailed by the United States on Thursday, saying it is a “very, very big deal” that could open up great economic opportunities.
However, US officials said they understood that the Pakistani cabinet had approved a negotiated path to reach MFN – a move they still described as a major development.
“We don’t yet have most-favoured nation status,” State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland told reporters.
“We have a decision unanimously approved by the Pakistani cabinet to open a path for full normalisation of trade relations with India” as the commerce ministers of both countries agreed in Delhi in September, Nuland said.
“This is a very, very big deal, very important, could lead to really great economic opportunities for both India and Pakistan,” Nuland said.
It “sets the kind of example” that other countries in South and Central Asia should follow toward building an integrated regional economy that Washington has pushed under its “New Silk Road” project, she said. Washington has sought to put Afghanistan at the center of such a project in a bid to ensure the war-torn nation becomes peaceful and prosperous in the long term.
“We really applaud Pakistan and India for taking this concrete step to improve their relations. It’s the most tangible thing that they’ve done yet,” Nuland added.
China also applauded the move on Thursday saying that improved Pakistan-India relations were vital for peace, stability and development in the region. Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Hong Lei made the remarks at a press briefing in Beijing, adding that as a neighbour and friend of India and Pakistan, China will continue to support the two sides to improve relations through dialogue and cooperation and accomplish collaborative development.(Additional input from Agencies)
Published in The Express Tribune, November 4th, 2011.
COMMENTS (25)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@goggi:
The same is applicable to indians visiting pakistan.
Already Indian are feeling the heat of opening this bilateral trade. They are purchasing tomatoes at Rs 25-30 per KG, According to TOI report this is due to export of tomatoes to Pakistan. Truck load of tomatoes are going to Pakistan from Nasik area of Maharashtra which is the main provider of this vegetable in these time to Asia's biggest mandi at Azadpur mandi in New Delhi. But instead of selling these tomatoes at Rs 8-10 per Kg at wholesale market these people are sending across the borders where demand is hight because crops have been destroyed by floods.
Actually P.O.K is an illegally occupied therefore disputed territory. Balochistan is clearly unfinished business and baloch aspirations cannot be suppressed forever. Human right violations and brutal violence against the noble baloch race have reached a breaking point. The baloch will become a free nation as Pakistan spirals into chaos, anarchy and disintegration. The mullahs and the isi army combine will make sure of it.
Sensible reaction from Indian govt and businessmen. Why is that some Pakistanis are against trade relations with India.
Dear friends,
Pakistan and India both benefit from this trade. By the way, trade always increases options for consumers.
Chief Executive Kamran Y Mirza of Pakistan Business Council (PBC), a group of top 35 nationals and multinationals has informed government that Pakistan's GDP growth will increase by 1 percentage point if we open trade with India.
Similarly, Indian people will also benefit when they get cheap cement, worlds best marble raw material, commodities etc etc.
Pakistan can import cheap machinery, cheap tea compared to Kenyan tea, pharmaceutical raw-material etc etc etc.
@JJ: Never expect a rational response from him
Peace 'n trade euphoria is fine and dandy, but its amusing to see how pakistanis are coveting the indian market now by according india a status that was already long overdue. Doobte ko tinke ka sahara bhi gavar hai. Greed is a strange motivator, and so is desperation. Many pakistanis are are also talking about "resolving" the kashmir problem through trade but do they even have any clear and perspicacious thoughts on this? What kind of resolution are they hoping for? Are they willing to let go? They are naive if the expect they will "acquire" kashmir through enhanced trade with India. As far as india is concerned the only problem pertaining to kashmir is pakistan's pathological obsession and perfidious meddling. But trade will probably check pak's meddling and obession for indian territory. Pakistans internal social and economic problems will not get solved and its thirst for peace and prosperity will not be assuaged simply by trading with india but rather by loosening the stranglehold of a desert religion and bringing about a cultural, social and religious reformation. This is the only route to come out of the mess.
@punjabi zubaan: Another link which reinforces my point http://www.indianexpress.com/news/loud-cheers-for-pakistan-british-team-sport/692086/
@punjabi zubaan: Shri Vajpayee is not a punjabi is was born in Shinde Ki Chhavani, a town in the Gwalior district of Madhya Pradesh.It is not only the punjabis in India who want better relations with Pakistan . Remember the lap of honour the Pakistan cricket team took at Chennai here is the link http://www.espncricinfo.com/india/content/ground/58008.html . Hope for better times.
@andleeb:
Sir, thanks for all the laughs
A mature move that should bring peace and prosperity for Pakistan and India. I fully endorse and support the decision.
@let there be peace: oo yes ,belt the punjabis whenever things dont go ur way,atal bihari vajpayee started this peace process in 2004,guess he was a punjabi.
The discourse to defuse tensions between India and Pakistan is simply the best recipe for peace and stability in the South Asian region. Giving India the status of MFN is one very important concession and step that Pakistan has taken to restore ties with its ever growing neighbour. The next step as this news item points out is to "remove non-trade barriers against Pakistani goods", so that Pakistan’s economic progress return to its grace. This initiative will put Pak-Indian relations on a new path, and thereby pave the way to resolute all the standing issues through dialogue and mutual understanding. Currently, the US and international community are trying to balance the lead role of Pakistan with crediting India an enormous strategic importance. By all standards, growing trade ties will not address this approach, but it would improve only one aspect of this complex system of relationship. Most importantly, the "New Silk route" project is constructed in the backdrop of enhancing Indian influence vis-à-vis China, a policy that may divert the “stability project” of Afghanistan, if not considered in perspective of Pakistan’s own Silk Route and its importance. One must remain cautiously optimistic and work toward strengthening economic ties with India, in order to achieve maximum economic progress.
Give peace a chance. India is growing at 9% a year. All Pakistanis should understand that they will benefit more than depending upon USA aid. Learn to stand on your own feet which you have failed since 1947. Just see European countries like Germany , France , UK etc. They had fought very long and bitter world wars. Much bigger than india and pakistan. But they realized soon that its best to live in peace. They turned around their economies within 20 years after 2nd world war. Our future generations will curse us if we continue as an enemy and deprive them of development. I feel its our responsibility to build both countries and bring prosperity for general public. Politicians and rich people will always enjoy in any condition . Its only the general public that will suffer. Hopefully sense will prevail.
The article has missed a significant point : Pakistan is a major nuclear power and both China and America are dancing to our tune. Who needs India????
@Umayr Masud: that's no Manmohan Singh. Thats Montk Singh Ahluwalia -- Planning Commission. ( and for the benefit of the Pakistani right wingers - another member of the 'persecuted minority' in India running the country!!
Really a very good move.Trade between Pakistan and India is beneficial for both the countries.Kashmir issue will also be resolved with time.I hope one day both the nations will be enjoying good relations.Masses will reap it's benefits in future.
It is a good move in the right direction, it may not prove itself to be a panacea for all the challenges faced by the neighbors but I am certain the peace dividends and the economic benefits that shall follow be enormous.
Bye! Bye! Kashmir.
Yeah right. Is India stopping building dams?
Enough of this Punjabi melodrama and Aman ki asha. we are separate nations now. Violence and hatred of india is in Pakistan's DNA. Nothing is going to change it because that is the ideological basis of Pakistan. Keep safe distance from Pakistan. Be alert and improve security. Then if any space left do this bhai bhai drama.
If you travel to India then you have to be prepared for the worst. For instance you get a 2 weeks visa which is restricted to one city! And then "everyday" you are forced to report in the unfriendly police station your presence! Lo karlo dhanda!
What is the reaction of MR.BAL KESHAV THACKERAY????
What a joke!
Manmohan singh has gained some weight .. hmmmm
Lets see how india will abuse the MFN.. Singh is King!