The comedian, who has worked in Akshay Kumar’s Indo-Canadian venture Breakaway, was recently in India for a short visit to promote Speedy Singhs — the Hindi version of the film. During his press conferences Peters was funnier than Bollywood fans could handle.
“I hate Bollywood. The films are all garbage, just terrible. It’s my opinion — obviously there are billions who love them. I have never seen a Bollywood film in my life. I have refused to do them earlier and will do so in future,” Peters claimed at a press conference.
As per few media reports, Peters allegedly also cracked some jokes about Aishwarya Rai-Bachchan’s mediocre acting skills and even joked about her pregnancy. According to sources, he however retracted his statements on Bachchan later. Whatever the case be, Peters is nonchalant about the angst he seems to have evoked amongst Bollywood fans.
Standing by his opinion, Peters tweeted, “There is no reason for me to like everything you like, my opinions are just that — my opinions. There are plenty of things I love that you won’t! The fact that my words have upset some of you so much only makes me victorious!”
The political wings of India also condemned Russell’s alleged statements on Bachchan’s pregnancy. Shalini Thackeray, cine-worker’s union president of Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) commented, “Bollywood is a vast industry, which churns out more films than anyone else in the world and Peters has no right to talk ugly or disgrace our industry or its actors. His comment on Aishwarya Rai-Bachchan is indeed in a bad taste, but I think his irrelevant comment should not deter or affect an actor of her calibre.”
A leader from Shiv Sena, on the condition of anonymity, said, “Who is this Russell Peters and why should we entertain him? I think he should be banned in the country if he doesn’t respect our traditions and films.”
Meanwhile, Sundari Thakur, the President of Nari Samman Sanghathan, a Mumbai-based NGO retorted, “He should mind his language and remain in his limits, as she (Bachchan) is a woman first and actor later. I think he (Peters) has lost his values and respect for women.”
In Peters’ defense, amidst his derogatory comments he did talk about the positive impact of Hollywood and Bollywood collaboration and expressed the hope to see more projects like Breakaway. “Collaborations between India and the West are going to be fruitful. The love affair of Bollywood and Hollywood ought to grow and I think Speedy Singhs is a good move from both the sides.”
Peters kick-started his career in acting with “Show Me The Funny” in 1997 and has since starred in films like Lord Have Mercy and Comedy Now among others. Breakaway is his first film with an Indian production team and an Indian star cast; featuring Anupam Kher, Vinay Virmani, Gurpreet Ghuggi and Hollywood actor Camilla Belle. He is now looking forward to a star on the Walk of Fame which will be inducted October 1 in Toronto.
Till a few days back, the 40-year-old comedian felt Non-resident Indians (NRIs) should get a taste of modern India and reconnect with the fast developing Indian culture. Maybe now, after the Bollywood ramba his comments created, he will recheck his notes on fusion and harmony.
(With additional information from TOI and IANS)
Published in The Express Tribune, September 26th, 2011.
COMMENTS (22)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Russell Peters has too many question about Indians including Aishwarya Rai and who not ..... We too have a question for Russell Peters - frastu singh Please watch - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2MaTnlCXKQ
i agree with him about Bollywood being cheap and crap in the words of the lady who said they take out the maximum movies in the world it is true - but emphasis has been on quantity and not quality . for every 1000 movies we probably will get 1 movie that has a plot that could stimulate the mind. Regards Ash being a useless actress he is 100 % correct - she should just do commercials not movies she is good looking for that. We dont need to get sensitive but in fact recognise the truth . i agree our egoes are hurt but the truth does do that to everyone of us . Bring back actors like Nargis , Saira banu etc they were actors not these cheap botoxed plastic women like Ash
@Naeem Siddiqui: It's ok
That kind of thinking is expected from a terrorist browsing a .pk site.
He could have been more tactful with his language, but that's just the way he is - outspoken and reckless. Besides, I think what he said was true - Bollywood (at least mainstream Bollywood) is essentially the same dumbed-down entertainment over and over again. Indians need to learn to take it in good humour and stop bobbing their heads up and down to defend that crap. And stop getting so serious over "how can he judge Bollywood when he's not seen a movie", he's a comic.
@Ranjit: Agree; I watched 5 minutes of this guy on Youtube; 5 Minutes of my life that I will never get back; He is not Indian and he is not funny; Plus one minute wasted for this comment
Ever heard of "any kind of publicity is good publicity!"? lol - he obviously achieved what he wanted to..
Russell Peters is very popular comedian (especially in the West). I have many friends of Chinese/Vietnamese ancestry who also find him very amusing.
We Indians will cry at anything. Grow up, where did we loose our sense of humor?
By the way I hate so-called Bollywood; I simply can't stand any of the Khans...
@Naeem Siddiqui: Did I say anything about Patriotism? Some people can't get far away from conspiracy theories
he'z a great comedian and i love his shows,but i dont understand one thing about his comments,he says he's never seen a bollywood movie but then how can he hate them,u first have to see and experience something to hate it.dues to this his comments just seem like some old prejudice he might have.
@Ranjit
So as per your logic anyone who mocks indian movies and actors become a traitor :)
@Paras Vikmani
I dont see any thing wrong on his comments about Indian movies and about Ashwaria's Pregnancy. I myself rarely watch indian movies even those on insistance of my friends. Most of bollywood movies lacks plot, quality direction and extreamly cheap and gutter jokes.
its the Bachchan family who have made the pregnancy of Ashwairia a public property so puplic has the right comment on her pregnancy. all kinds of good or bad comments will come.
If you dont want comments on your pregnancy then dont market it.
@Leanne:
I think so too. I am not enamoured with Bollywood, too much melodrama. That doesn't make me anti-india. I just don't like the melodrama. Most Indian movies are made for the lower middle class, those are the ones who counts Bollywood as religion. I don't have any problem in Russsel peters not liking Bollywood. Some of these movies are so childish and the actors look like low level thugs. Don't take it so personally, it is his opinion.
Some one here cares too much of his opinion. He is a comedian for god sake. Giving too much value to his wits is no go.
What a way to burn bridges. He is entitled to his opinion but to trash Bollywood in a Bollywood actor's birthday is sheer arrogance.
Anglo-Indians are not real Indians; There are lot of others just like him who are physically in India but mentally somewhere else; If you do an informal survey you will find that Indians who really love India are Jains, Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists
Check out the 45 mins Russell Peters performance from Comedy Now on YouTube. The funniest comedy show ever done!
He is a cheap maniac,nothing else.
I don't understand Russell's comments: “... Bollywood. The films are all garbage, just terrible... I have never seen a Bollywood film in my life." How can he have a strong opinion that the films are garbage if he's never seen one? It doesn't seem very intelligent to judge with no foundation or reference point on which to make that judgement. I am a RP fan, he says its his opinion, but I don't agree with critiquing something you having seen. That's not a valid opinion.