Breaking free from colonial governance legacy

The British Empire, at its zenith, ruled over a vast array of colonies and territories across the world, leaving behind a legacy that continues to shape the political, social and economic landscapes of former British colonies. One of the most profound aspects of this legacy is the governance models established by the British colonial authorities, primarily the Northern Ireland and London models. As these nations gained independence, they faced unique challenges and opportunities associated with these governance paradigms. The two primary models of governance employed by the British were based on Northern Ireland and London, each with its unique characteristics. After gaining independence, former colonies such as Kenya, India, Pakistan, Burma, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, Uganda and Fiji continued with slight variations of the Northern Ireland model, while countries like Australia, New Zealand, Zimbabwe and white-majority South Africa were more closely aligned with the London model.

The Northern Ireland model — characterized by authoritative control, limited public participation and an unwavering focus on loyalty to the British crown — had far-reaching consequences. All these countries where the Northern Ireland model of governance was installed by the British share similar kinds of institutional diseases and governance problems embedded in government culture. Administrative structures often prioritised the interests of colonial masters, leading to extractive policies and governance systems. Landlords and political elites, cultivated or influenced by the colonial administration, wielded disproportionate power, and corruption became pervasive. The judiciary and police, originally designed to protect the colonial elite, struggled to transition to serving the broader interests of newly independent nations.

In contrast, the London model adopted a more inclusive approach, incorporating elements of parliamentary democracy and representation. Countries following this model tended to have institutions that were somewhat more accountable to the local population, and political processes were influenced by democratic norms.

However, even decades after gaining independence, many former colonies still grapple with the enduring governance issues stemming from these models. Challenges persist in land reform, political representation, corruption and the effectiveness of public institutions. Transitioning from extractive governance to inclusive and accountable systems is a complex and ongoing process.

To address these challenges and build strong, resilient post-colonial nations, we must embark on a multifaceted approach:

Long-term Vision and Commitment: Recognise that addressing the legacy of extractive governance is a long-term endeavour. Sustain political will and commitment to reforms, even in the face of challenges and setbacks.

Civil Services & Political Reform and Inclusivity: Promote political and civil services reforms that encourage inclusivity and participation among all segments of society. Implement electoral systems that ensure fair representation and reduce the dominance of political elites.

Land Reform and Resource Redistribution: Prioritise land reform programmes to address historical land injustices and inequities. Develop transparent mechanisms for land redistribution to benefit marginalised communities.

Anti-Corruption Measures: Strengthen anti-corruption agencies and institutions to combat graft effectively. Encourage whistleblower protection and citizen engagement in monitoring corruption.

Judicial and Police Reforms: Revamp the judicial system to ensure impartiality, efficiency, and accessibility for all citizens. Train and professionalise the police force to focus on serving and protecting the broader population.

Transparency and Accountability: Enhance transparency in government operations, budgeting and public spending. Establish mechanisms for citizens to hold public officials accountable for their actions.

Public Education and Awareness: Promote civic education and public awareness campaigns to inform citizens about their rights and responsibilities. Encourage active citizen engagement in the democratic process.

Civil Society Empowerment: Support and empower civil society organisations to advocate for good governance and social justice. Foster an environment where civil society can collaborate with the government to drive positive change.

International Support and Partnerships: Seek international support and partnerships for capacity-building and technical assistance in governance reforms. Engage in peer learning and knowledge exchange with countries that have successfully transitioned to inclusive governance models.

Youth Involvement: Actively involve youth and women in political and governance processes to diversify leadership and decision-making. Create opportunities for mentorship and leadership development among underrepresented groups.

Constitutional Reforms: Consider constitutional amendments or revisions that reinforce democratic principles, human rights and equitable governance.

Monitoring and Evaluation: Establish mechanisms for ongoing monitoring and evaluation of governance reforms to ensure their effectiveness and adaptability.

Overcoming the legacy of the Northern Ireland model of governance in former colonies like Kenya, India, Pakistan, Burma, Sri Lanka, Nigeria, Uganda and Fiji is a complex and challenging task. However, with a concerted effort from governments, civil society and the international community, these nations can transition towards more inclusive, accountable and equitable governance systems that better serve the interests of their citizens and foster sustainable development. It’s time to break free from the shadows of colonialism and forge a brighter future for these nations.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 12^th, 2023.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.