All parties, except the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), and independent candidates seeking recounting in the NA-249 constituency boycotted the process on Wednesday over non-provision of Form 46 and counterfoil of ballot papers not being checked.
In a letter addressed to the returning officer (RO), the parties maintained that, "For want of non-provision of Form 46 and denial to allow access to the counterfoil of ballot paper, we cannot participate in [the] subject proceedings."
The signatories to the letter included the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), Pak Sarzameen Party (PSP), Pasban and others.
The parties pointed out in the letter that, "...the first bag [of ballot papers] lying on [the] table was without a seal," adding that all parties were boycotting the recount "under this attitude".
The aggrieved parties maintained that there was no precedent of recounting being conducted without the empty ballots being counted, or Form 46 and counterfoil signatures or seals not being checked.
'All ballot bags unsealed'
According to PML-N's Miftah Ismail, "All ballot bags were unsealed when [they] reached [the] RO office." He also alleged that 167 forms did not have signatures of the presiding officers.
According to PTI's Amjad Iqbal Afridi, the by-poll had been "planned". He said they were not being provided with Form 46, adding that the party will not let the PPP influence results. "There should be a re-poll in the constituency," he maintained.
PSP's Hafeezuddin accused the ROs of siding with those who rigged the polls.
The ECP reportedly contacted the boycotting lawmakers, but they refused to be a part of the process.
'PPP to reclaim victory'
Meanwhile, PPP's winning candidate Qadir Khan Mandokhel said that "defeat is in PML-N's fate, regardless of what they do."
He admitted that the recount was delayed by two hours, but added that the representatives of political parties, except for two of them, were present during the process.
"Why is Form 46 an issue when there's a recount ongoing?" he asked. "It will be generated afresh."
Provincial information minister Nasir Shah said that PPP's victory is not being accepted. Terming the boycott of the recount a "drama", Shah said it is an attempt to pressurise and coerce ECP.
Senior PPP leader Shehla Raza said that PML-N "escaped the recount because it was fearful of its imminent defeat."
لندن فرار قائد کی 'ن' لیگ این اے 249 میں انتخاب کی رات فرار ہوئ اورآج اپنے ہی مطالبے پر دوبارہ ہونیوالی گنتی سے بھی راہ فرار اختیار کیا کے جن نتائج کو خود مسترد کیا تھاانہی کو دوبارہ مانگا گیا ۔تاکہ یہ عمل متنازعہ بنایا جا سکے ۔کیا اب الیکشن کمیشن بھی اپنی مرضی سے چلانا چاھتے ہیں— Syeda Shehla Raza (@SyedaShehlaRaza) May 6, 2021
She asked the party to accept the results. "It is as if the PML-N wants the electoral record to set up its own election cell."
Raza further said, "first, they rejected the results and now, they are making the recount controversial."
However, despite the boycott, the recounting that commenced at the RO office today continued.
According to the returning officer, it would be difficult to complete the process of counting 73,471 votes cast in 276 polling stations of the constituency in a single-day.
“Each and every vote will be re-checked in the presence of all candidates of different political parties and their chief polling agents. We will try to finish the task in a day, but I believe it will take more time,” said a senior ECP official.
On May 4, ECP accepted Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) candidate Miftah Ismail's plea and ordered recounting in the NA-249 constituency.
The PML-N maintains that their mandate was "stolen" in the election, saying it had been leading the polls since the voting started.
The PPP bagged victory in the NA-249 Karachi by-election held on April 29, defeating the PML-N contender by 683 votes.
A copy of the signed document available with The Express Tribune