I envy the British, their panic. The riots in London have made them feel genuine fear and anger. It is something we hardly ever experience anymore. The BBC has been full of interviews with residents who are watching buildings burn and are consumed with fear. Everyone in London is frightened because teenagers have decided that online gaming and reality TV just don’t provide the kind of adrenaline increase they crave and so took part in some old-fashioned looting and pillaging. In Karachi, where I live, over a dozen people die on a daily basis. To me they are just a number scrolling by on the news ticker. In Balochistan, a province of the country I belong to, uncountable many have been killed by the intelligence agencies. To me they are a news story I skim over in the daily papers. I have passed by burnt tires and rock-pelting protestors repeatedly in the last month and my only reaction has been to find a more convenient route home. It used to be that when a bomb blast occurred in the city you live in, you would call everyone to make sure they were safe and then sit staring at the television while mouthing a silent scream. Now, we change our dinner reservations to a later hour.
The only news story that actually affected me on a deeply personal level recently was that of a donkey being killed. The details, if you allow me to summarise, are that last month in Sukkur a man found himself enamoured with his neighbour’s mule. Maybe it was the come-hither looks, maybe it was the way that tail so seductively swished. Regardless, it wasn’t long before the owner of the mule walked in on this man and his donkey in the throes of passion. One man’s bestial rape is another man’s forbidden love. Predictably (in Pakistan) a jirga was called, the donkey was declared kari and the man karo and the donkey was killed. The man, of course, absconded. A million jokes present themselves in this story. Yet, all I can think of is about that poor animal. It led a life full of cruelty, the penultimate moment of which involved rape and then was finally killed. When I heard that story, I was — for the first time in ages — overcome with rage and sorrow. Tribal cruelty towards women has become such a regularity that it often goes criminally ignored. But this story hurt me by being so unpredictable. By catching me without my emotional defences up. I felt like crying for a donkey in a country where humans live and die in worse ways every day.
‘But if you change your way of life, doesn’t that mean the terrorists win’ is a common refrain. Let them win, I say. Because we certainly aren’t winning anything.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 11th, 2011.
COMMENTS (34)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Great piece, Sami! I could cry...
"I envy the British, their panic" - My thoughts exactly.
Good one, some light reading with a healthy dose of reality!
We all felt your strong emotions , it comes as a rain in the barren land of emotionless people, people who burn each other , kill , shoot and blow themselves up. Karo kari and more hideous crimes against humanity need to be talked about but I love the humor and sarcasm merging wonderfully in this piece of yours. KUDOS TO YOU
I felt. Thankyou.
Sad, funny but true picture of our society unfurtunatelly.
I do not belong to any religious Fundamentalist group, neither am I part of any Liberal reforms. I do not belong to any ethnicity,caste, sect or religion and i won't glorify any. I don't speak any language other than our National and Official languages. What am I? I'm a citizen of this state. I have rights and responsibilities. And I believe that I should do my utmost to fulfill my duties before I demand my rights, and even if i can't, its my responsibility to keep trying. Therefore, I am bound to the constitution of the state of Pakistan. My view is that the punishments should be in accordance to the constitution, and practices in accordance to the state's religion. As long as our state is "Islamic Republic of Pakistan", we should respect it as decent, civilized citizens, and if we have any disagreements, we can always voice our opinions and vote for those who may promote our agendas. As far as I know, our debates can show how intellectual we are, but this isn't everything we seek for. Shouldn't we concentrate more on the supremacy of law in the state instead of judging each other on ideological grounds. Every one who talks about religion, is not necessarily a fundamentalist, just like every one who propagates the message of "free Will" isn't a Liberal. To be a nation, we have to rise above those trivial differences. And I hope now people have realized that why religion and culture are different. Because in Pakistan, one is the part of constitution and law thus state, while the other is just a part of society and has no legal significance of any kind. Disclaimer: I am not a student of Political Science, Civics or Law so any positive criticism, regarding my understanding of these topics, will be appreciated.
@mind control: People can't be blamed for following a precept which is inconsistent with Islam, because unfortunately we, ourselves, have distorted this religion. We have always tried to amalgamate culture into religion, and that is why, today we have some of the customs which are quite contradictory to Islam. That is one of the reasons, why I was searching for punishments in Hinduism, so that I may be able to understand the origin of this myth.
Regarding Jirga, I would like to inform you that Jirga System throughout Sindh was banned in 2004, and that ban is still in effect. Therefore, any decision taken by Jirga is a self-evident Contempt of Court. Regarding this incident, any animal rights organization can submit a petition against the owner of the donkey for killing the animal unlawfully, but more importantly, any human right organization can challenge the Jirga for unlawful assemblage and verdict.
Link for SHC decision, http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story25-4-2004pg7_42
Link to "Pakistan Penal Code" for 340,349 and 350. http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/37/13/46816797.pdf
Link to "Contempt of Court, 2004 Ordinance" http://www.intermedia.org.pk/mrc/medialawdocs/Contempt-of-Court-Ordinance.pdf
This is a good article, written by Mr. Ardeshir Cowasjee in the light of that historic decision, i just mentioned. http://www.rghr.net/mainfile.php/0622/721
@Eraj Khan
Thank you for the research. You have ably demonstrated, punishment for both the beast and the human in such situations is mandated only in Christian religious discourse. Does that make the members of the Jirga, Murtads, as they were following a religious percept other than the Islamic.
And if that be so, what punishment is proposed for the Jirga?
Mr Shah, your column is worth a short story, its beautiful. Thank you
eraj khan rocks
Excellent Article Mr. Shah. Quite amusing i must say. And you pointed out, rightly, something which is utterly wrong with our society. Its probably the ignorance which exhibits itself in the form of savagery. And though it was coined as "Karo-Kari" by the Jirga but we all agree that its an entirely different aspect. I would like to present my views regarding Karo-Kari but right now, i'll prefer to focus on the above issue. Despite my exhaustive research, i could not found any concrete evidence of punishment for Bestiality in Islam, but the common impression is that the animal has to be killed, which is not entirely correct. Scholars, though, approve that the abused animal's meat is forbidden by Muslims, yet there has been NO evidence of slaying the animal. The most authentic Hadith that i found was,
Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas: There is no prescribed punishment for one who has sexual intercourse with an animal. Abu Dawud (38:4450) http://www.muslimaccess.com/sunnah/hadeeth/abudawud/038.html
According to Bible, however,
And if a man lie with a beast, he shall surely be put to death: and ye shall slay the beast. -- Leviticus 20:15 http://bible.cc/leviticus/20-15.htm
I could not find anything regarding punishment in Hinduism. What i am trying to investigate is, from where did we acquire this norm of killing the animal, if it was not in our religion.
According to Pakistan Penal Code, Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which shall not be less than two years nor more than ten years, and shall also be liable to fine. PPC:377 http://www.pakistani.org/pakistan/legislation/1860/actXLVof1860.html
As we have a law against it, so i believe he deserve to be prosecuted.
Hopefully an ordinance will be issued bringing the donkey back to life ! brilliant article Sami.
The donkey got shafted both ways!
Where are you going with this: They shoot horses don't they? thinking? Defeatism, and a sorry state of self pity! Is the cacoon of the Pakistani elite developing a crack?
:(
Excellent
Your words make me laugh and weep at the same time. Perfect. Thank you.
Thank you for articulating this so well.
Excellent piece.
What an impressionistic and sarcastic article in a while! You are right; we do not spare women, minorities and even animals from our animalistic behavior. Sami, you write well and truthfully, please keep it up. Even though it was hilarious but it made me sad as it brings the point(s) home. Thanks & cheers, Mirza
A good one Mr. Shah.
Sami Sahib, kudos to you for enthralling your readers. Sometime back, a similar event took place in Fujeirah (UAE) with two minor. Exceptions the animal was a camel and the lover a Bengali driver. There too, a sharia court passed a verdict for the camel to be killed, wasted as it had been corrupted. The passionate lover was given a a verdict of jail time, Korray and deportation. Love is blind, especially when you are in the desert and there are no airport security officers to pat you down. Love your style of writing, please keep traveling and writing.
Very poignant article.
brilliant piece
but just to point out a donkey and a mule are different animals
As if constant reading about the sick state of affairs was not enough, you went and really disturbed me with this one.
o god !! now we are killing donkeys in honour killings !! this is beyond belief,how low will our people go,we don't deserve to be called humans if we think that a rape victim deserves to be put to death to punish her for getting herself raped.the demented man who murdered the donkey should immediately be put behind bars because he might do the same thing to a human rape victim in the future,i never thought i would live to see the day that a donkey was declared a kari !!!
how low can we possibly go??
Good job Sami.
Well written Sami ..... The first article i felt like reading through till the end. Well observed .... but what can we do except mourn our loss of innocence!
‘But if you change your way of life, doesn’t that mean the terrorists win’ is a common refrain. Let them win, I say. Because we certainly aren’t winning anything. This is my weeks favourite piece