Actors in Karachi

PPP’s decision's to revive commissionerate system and bring the FC adds combustible element to the Karachi bonfire.

Nadir Hassan August 03, 2011

Follow the urban warfare masquerading as democratic politics in Karachi for long enough and you will see the ridiculous, eventually morphing into the acceptable. The killing of nearly 400 people in the past month demands some kind of response. It is unfortunate then that the responses offered traverse the space from the merely undemocratic to outright fascistic.

First, let us acknowledge that no grand plan can entirely work so long as the two political parties who are inspiring, if not outright ordering, the violence in Karachi continue to consider guns the best tool for addressing their demographic concerns. One of these parties, generally referred to euphemistically in print by terrified journalists and editors as ‘a Karachi-based ethnic party; or ‘the city’s custodians’, is worried about losing its iron grip on the city as the mass migration of Pakhtuns threatens to upset their electoral supremacy. In the interest of fairness, let’s adopt a euphemism for the opposing political party too. The Northern Nomads want their share of power in the city, do not like being collectively tarred as Taliban and would like nothing more than to drive their buses and trucks without becoming the victims of arson.

Stepping into the breach, to the extent that fumbling around can be counted as stepping into anything, is the party that rules the centre. Let’s call them the Dynastic Daddies. They have come up with two plans, both of which are so unlikely to succeed that those of a conspiratorial bend would think they were actively trying to worsen the situation in Karachi.

On August 2, Interior Minister Rehman Malik announced that the 1,000 Frontier Constabulary (FC) personnel brought to Karachi would be given full police powers, which presumably includes shoot-on-sight orders. Quite apart from the wisdom of deploying FC jawaans, who are primarily recruited from Khyber-Pakthunkhwa and Fata, to tackle what is essentially an ethnic conflict between those drawn from the city’s Muhajir and Pashtun communities. Past experience has shown that military and paramilitary forces ignite conflict rather than subduing it.

The military had free reign during Operation Clean-Up in 1992 to deal with the MQM ‘threat’, a threat that at the time was exaggerated. They responded by going on a killing orgy that would have made Charles Manson blush. Nearly 20 years later, the psychic wounds caused by that operation have yet to heal. Giving the same power to a different paramilitary force will be as effective as giving a painkiller to a cancer patient.

The other cunning PPP plan was to reintroduce the commissionerate system, another move that seemed calibrated to annoy the MQM as much as possible. The local government scheme has been far from perfect, even in Karachi, but is vastly preferable to transferring power back to unseen, unaccountable bureaucrats. Quite apart from the merits of the commissionerate system, the PPP’s decision managed to add yet another combustible element to the Karachi bonfire.

Adopting a stick-and-an-even-bigger-stick approach to Karachi, as the PPP as has done, will only lead to more violence, disenchantment and alienation. The sticking point is that a workable solution is all but impossible when the primary actors in the drama have memorised the same violent dialogue and refuse to adapt. Anyone who thinks deweaponisation will force political parties to trade in their guns for butter is taking optimism too far. Figuratively, arming the police with all the tools it needs to combat violence is often suggested but carte blanche authority is likely to lead to more ‘encounters’.

If Karachi truly is the City that Never Sleeps it is only because the sound of gunfire and the illumination provided by burning buses does not allow its residents to doze off for even a second.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 4th, 2011.


Irshad Khan | 10 years ago | Reply

City Nazim Karachi and Hyderabad changed both Metropolitan cities from scrap to modern areas, very clean and very organised, within a short period of about four years. It looked like doing miracles because they were intelligent, properly educated, devoted to their work, hard working, good planners and capable of leading big teams for different works. They proved their capabilities and capacity to do enormous works with good planning and team work. Both proved to be the great and able sons of the country and Sindh. Both of them are young people and it was thought that they would be given at least Ten Cities of Sindh to develope them on the same lines as karachi and Hyderabad. During the past three years they would have completed these Jobs and province of Sindh would have been a different land. Still there is time that they are given this task, with proper funds and free hand under either governor or chief Minister in the sole interest of country and province of Sindh, if both these young men are prepared to accept another challenge. As far as problems of Karachi are concerned; It used to be a small town, without any industry or having work for large labour force. The Migrants from India established industries and started banking and other systems and also a largenumber of cottage industries, supported with mega housing schemes; Thus it needed a large industrial and other raw type labour force for which a gap was created, this gap was filled by the people of northern areas. In their own areas and also In Sindh interior, this trend of Industrialisation was not only avoided but discouraged as Maliks, Sardars and Jagirdars feel industrialisation as a threat to their unchallenged authorities and interests. This type of migration, inside the country, is highly painful as they have to leave behind their families/relative and have to pass a hard life at a ne place with a different atmosphere. Every citizen has the right to get employment in his own area and live with his family and clan which fact is still being neglected and nearly no jobs are being created in those areas, further, people are also migrating from there due to prevailing unsafe atmosphere. These matters need attention and some immidiate practical actions instead of exploiting these simple people to grab lands and also grab other facilities without any cost in Karachi and also not abiding any law of land but establish out-dated Jirga system. May GOD,THE ALMIGHTY give us a kind heart and an insight to live together without any distinction.

Munsif Ali | 10 years ago | Reply

Commisssionerate system is already working in other provinces even in Punjab.No body made any such violent response to it in those provinces,why it's different in Sindh.Secondly Local body system is provincial system and MQM has right to challenge this system through political means and going back to public and if they succeed convincing people of Sindh about their favorite system then no body will have any problem.But if any one thinks dictating their favorite system's revival based on hate and violence,they are completely wrong and it will only defame their already defamed credibility.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read