Archaeologists ask Sindh govt to bring back Moenjo Daro artifacts

Experts highlight need to study the pottery that has been excavated from the ancient site


​ Our Correspondent January 10, 2020
PHOTO: FILE

KARACHI: Archaeologists have asked the Sindh government to bring back the pottery excavated from Moenjo Daro a century ago, which is currently in Lahore so that more research can be carried out.

“Around 150 translations of the script of the Indus Valley civilisation have been published but we cannot prove which one is correct,” said Dr Jonathan Mark Kenoyer, an American archaeologist. “We are in search of proof, which is only possible through studying what has been excavated.”

In Pakistan, an archaeologist jumps over hoops to pursue her passions

Speaking on the first day of the Indus Script Conference at Moenjo Daro, Dr Kenoyer asserted that the nature of the writing in different contexts suggested that the script was quite versatile and could be used to encode a range of messages which would remain undecipherable until we discover a bi-lingual tablet of some sort.

He emphasised that the inscribed material on the pottery, such as graffiti, is essential for further our understanding of the seals and inscriptions from the civilisation, but it has largely been overlooked.

Meanwhile, Dr Andreas Fuls, an archaeologist from Germany, highlighted the value of the seals, which he said were very special. “There should be a library that we have not yet found,” he said.“More research needs to be done to find more written work and to know what the Indus Valley civilisation was.”

Shifting powers: Assembly enacts law for transferring governor's authority to appoint ombudsperson to CM

He pointed out that nobody knew about the civilisation’s religion or its governing system. “In the future, we will hopefully have more information,” he added. He said that there was a need for a second information system, explaining that with the help of one language, archaeologists could understand another.

Archaeologist Dr Kaleemullah Lashari, starting the discussion, said that many good attempts had been made at deciphering the script. But, he added, they hadn’t convinced scholars because they fell short of answering questions about the ancient civilisation. He was of the view that the approach taken by earlier attempts at deciphering the script missed the archaeological understanding of the chronological distribution of the inscribed material.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 10th, 2020.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ