'Chernobyl' gets mixed reviews from real life survivors

Some of the reactions are less rose-tinted about the popular show's depiction of the world’s worst nuclear accident


AFP / Reuters June 20, 2019
PHOTO: FILE

CHERNOBYL, Ukraine: Critics and viewers on both sides of the Atlantic have lined up to acclaim Chernobyl, a dramatization of events surrounding the world’s worst nuclear accident - but the reactions of some of the survivors are less rose-tinted.

The fourth reactor in the Soviet plant north of Kiev exploded during a botched safety test, releasing more radiation into the Earth’s atmosphere than any other man-made event in history.

The accident killed 31 within weeks and forced tens of thousands to flee. The final toll of those killed by radiation-related illnesses such as cancer is subject to debate, and estimated by the World Health Organization to be in the thousands.

PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: FILE

The series blames the excessive bureaucracy and secrecy of the Soviet Union, and Parashyn said there were flaws in the way it depicts the plant’s workers, in particular its management.

Chernobyl’s Deputy Chief Engineer Anatoliy Dyatlov, interpreted by English actor Paul Ritter as tyrannical and arrogant, “did not behave as terribly with people as the show portrays,” Parashyn said.

“He was harsh, yes, everyone obeyed him unquestioningly... But he was fair.”

PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: FILE

Parashyn, appointed as the plant’s director from 1994 to 1998 and later chief of the 30 kilometer exclusion zone that surrounds it, said Viktor Bryukhanov, the man then in charge, was also inaccurately depicted.

Instagram influencers slammed for taking 'inappropriate' selfies Chernobyl 

“Bryukhanov is a composed, calm, intelligent man, who never denied his responsibility,” he said.

This view is backed by Oleksiy Breus, the senior engineer of the 4th reactor in 1986, who arrived as part of the 8:00 a.m. shift change on April 26.

“The plant workers are shown as though they are scared of everything... This does not reflect reality,” Breus insisted. “In reality, they were quite decisive, very decisive, not one of the operators fled after the explosion.”

PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: FILE

However, he praised the portrayal of Chernobyl as a global, rather than a regional, catastrophe.

At 9.6/10 the highest rated TV series of all time on the IMDb website, the show also has caused a surge in visitor numbers to the plant and the nearby ghost town of Pripyat.

Tour guide Sergii Myrnyi believes that the show, whose final episode screened on June 3, was wrong to portray the events in 1986 only as a tragedy, calling Chernobyl “the story of global learning... and eventually the story of victory.”

PHOTO: FILE PHOTO: FILE

Its creator, Craig Mazin, said deviations from the historical record were undertaken in good faith.

“There’s a difference between the perfect way of doing something in terms of historical accuracy, and the perfect way of doing something so that people will watch it and appreciate what matters. You can’t have both, at least in that format,” he told Vice magazine in an interview this month.

Chernobyl Tour invited Parashyn, Breus and Myrnyi to the official launch of the agency’s new tour, which takes visitors around locations depicted in the series.

Have something to add to the story? Share in the comments below.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read