Engro Coal Mining Company responds to researchers' critique

Refutes claims that the income of locals has been adversely affected by the project

Our Correspondent September 14, 2018

KARACHI: In response to a news article, titled "CSR activities cannot hide plight of people affected by Thar coal project", which appeared in the September 12 issue of The Express Tribune, the Sindh Engro Coal Mining Company (SECMC) issued the following rejoinder.

The news article quoted Karachi Urban Lab (KUL) director, Dr Nausheen H Anwar and Dr Amiera Sawas, who presented their findings from an 18-month research study involving the Quaid-i-Azam Solar Park in Bahawalpur and the Thar Coal Project on largescale fossil fuels and green energy projects and their impact on land access and livelihoods of ordinary citizens.

According to the Sindh Engro Coal Mining Company, the notion that Dr Anwar has not been able to see a visible difference in income generation opportunities is incorrect. The company clarified that the majority of employees of Thar Coal Block II are Thari locals. Many of these locals were previously working in different cities and have now returned to work closer to their home towns and families.

As per data available with SECMC, 75 per cent of the workforce belongs to district of Tharparkar, who earn at least Rs16,000 a month. The second point raised by the SECMC was regarding  the quantification of carbon emissions which the researchers said isn't possible.

This, according to SECMC is a false assumption and misrepresentation of facts. Globally accredited environmental management systems such as ISO 14064 and ISO 14067 are used by SECMC that can help assess carbon footprint for the projects.

In its story The Express Tribune quoted Anwar as saying that the local media has been implicit in encouraging the discourse that people of Thar are backward, which she termed a colonial narrative.

The SECMC rejected this claim and added that the researchers should have verified the claim. Another point raised in the story was the issue of future household expansion which the SECMC clarified that unlike current household setups where members of the communities live in a joint family system, the company is providing one household unit of 1,100 square yards to each married couple which suffices the need of one family for the future.

During the session, the researchers raised questions on the compensation scheme of land and the colonial-era Land Acquisition Act, 1894. To this, the SECMC responded that all land for the project was acquired legally under the Land Acquisition Act 1894 by the Revenue Department of the Government of Sindh, while SECMC helped local land owners to secure up to four times the compensation compared to the land


Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read