Sindh's chemists defy science, use senses to detect alcohol

Published: September 4, 2018
SHARES
Email
Sharjeel Memon. PHOTO: EXPRESS/FILE

Sharjeel Memon. PHOTO: EXPRESS/FILE

KARACHI: Footage of the ‘chemical examination’ of the contents of liquor bottles found in Sharjeel Memon’s has raised questions on the operating procedure and method of examiners as they apparently declared the contents as oil and honey just by smelling and tasting them, without making the slightest effort to perform chemical tests.

The bottles were found on Saturday during a surprise visit of Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Mian Saqib Nisar to Ziauddin Hospital where Memon, who has been arrested in a corruption case, had been shifted from jail for medical treatment.

The footage, which was captured through a mobile phone by a laboratory staff member, shows the Chemical Examiner to the Sindh government, Dr Zahid Hasan Ansari, opening the bottles in Services Hospital and pouring their contents on his palm. The investigation officer of the case and other staff are also seen present.

The examiner smelled and tasted the contents and then asked the IO and other staff to taste and smell them as well. Later, it was announced in a loud voice that the bottles contained honey and oil. This was all apparently how the chemical examination was carried out.

Lack of cooperation from Sindh govt: SC decides to transfer Sharjeel to Punjab

A few minutes after the ‘examination’, the examiner prepared the reports which declared that one of the bottles sent to the laboratory contained honey while the other contained oil.

According to experts, chemical examination of any liquid that is suspected to contain alcohol has to be carried out by adding chemicals which can detect alcohol.

After the surfacing of the footage, questions are being raised on the competence of the staff in the laboratories of the province which is responsible for preparing chemical analyses reports of postmortems. Such reports are often essential for police to trace suspects.

Investigations continue

Meanwhile, the police have added another section of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) in the case of the discovery of liquor bottles from Memon’s hospital room.

The three-member investigation committee under South Zone DIG Javed Alam Odho has also included jail staff, court police and personal staff of Memon in the investigations. The committee has also asked the health secretary for further chemical examination of the contents of the liquor bottles.

It has still not been ascertained whether the number of liquor bottles found in Memon’s room was two or three. According to DIG Odho, suspects and witnesses have been giving contradictory statements regarding the number of bottles.

According to the committee, the case is based on weak evidence, witnesses and CCTV footage of the hospital. The footage showed that a shopper was transferred from the room by Memon’s staff. The committee suspects that it was an attempt to destroy the evidence.

No alcohol found in Sharjeel Memon’s bloodstream, says medical report

It has been reported that behaviour of the hospital staff also appeared suspicious in the footage after Justice Nisar left the hospital. The discovery of bottles from another location of the hospital is also fuelling suspicions that deliberate attempts were made to destroy the evidence.

It appeared to the investigation committee that the court police and sub-jail staff deployed at the hospital committed negligence in their duties, after which the Section 201 of the PPC was added in the case against Memon’s personal staff, court police and jail staff.

According to sources privy to the matter, the committee has also taken Karachi Central Jail officials Mujahid Khan and Naseem Shajraj and two court police officials into custody.

Looking ill again

Memon, who has been elected an MPA on the Pakistan Peoples Party ticket, was the centre of attention in the Sindh Assembly on Tuesday where he had arrived to cast his vote in the presidential election.

Memon came into the House with a walking stick. He held a long conversation with Local Government Minister Saeed Ghani and was seen roaming in the assembly with the aid of his stick.

It was reported earlier that when the CJP visited the hospital on Saturday, Memon came out of his room without any stick and appeared healthy. Justice Nisar remarked that the PPP leader was not seriously ill and ordered the authorities to shift him back to jail. Later, the CJP entered the room and found liquor bottles inside.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (4)

  • Andrew
    Sep 5, 2018 - 12:19AM

    The report is fake. I have already commented on another article in the same newspaper on the subject the nature of the liquids shown in the video.

    This is the first time I have heard that clinical analysis of crime scene objects is being carried out simply by the sense of smell. Ridiculous.

    Are we supposed to to trust reports if the chief is so causal about the seriousness of the nature of his duties. Recommend

  • rafeeq
    Sep 5, 2018 - 5:08AM

    if its prima facie honey and oil, why media wants it to be alchol desperatelyRecommend

  • Manzoor Ahmed
    Sep 5, 2018 - 9:12AM

    Its not defying science its defying the CJ of Pakistan and the law. Its to protect a criminal who has used medical excuses to party and drink alcohol under the guise of sub jail. Although this is not the first time this has occurred and many main stream parties have used this medical card to do such activities. KUDOS for CJ for exposing this practice and salute his patience.Recommend

  • Ozair
    Sep 5, 2018 - 9:33AM

    PPP has destroyed all institutions in Sindh for political gains.
    Pakistan will never prosper until PPP is sent to oblivion.Recommend

Leave Your Reply Below

Your comments may appear in The Express Tribune paper. For this reason we encourage you to provide your city. The Express Tribune does not bear any responsibility for user comments.

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

More in Pakistan