'NAB chief must be bipartisan'

Opposition leader reserves `final word' till Supreme Court detailed verdict

Express March 22, 2011

ISLAMABAD: Opposition Leader in the National Assembly Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan has apparently rejected a government proposal that Justice (retd) Deedar Hussain Shah be reappointed as head of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB).

Khan, who is a member of the Pakistan Muslim LeagueNawaz (PML-N), conveyed his disagreement in a two-page response to a letter President Asif Zardari wrote to him earlier this month.

Khan said he had previously rejected Shah’s appointment because of his ties to the PPP and was inclined to do so again for the same reasons as he felt the post of NAB chief should be bipartisan.

The letter, written by Khan’s secretary and addressing Zardari’s secretary, adds, however, that the leader of the opposition would get back to the president with his final word after the Supreme Court issues a detailed verdict.

The Supreme Court in a short order earlier this month declared the appointment of Shah, a loyalist of the ruling Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP),

illegal in response to a petition filed by Khan arguing that he was never consulted.

The next day, Zardari wrote letters to both Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani and Khan seeking their opinions on reappointing the same person in what appeared to be an attempt to fulfil his legal obligation to “consult” the premier and the opposition leader.

The government is bound under the Constitution to consult the opposition leader on the appointment of the NAB chief, a powerful position that has been used by past governments to pursue politically-motivate cases against opposition members. PPP members say that “consult” does not mean consent or consensus.

PML-N sources said that they would consider moving the Supreme Court again if Zardari issued a fresh order for Shah’s appointment.

Published in The Express Tribune, March 22nd, 2011.


Mirza | 10 years ago | Reply All the leaders of Sindh have been murdered in Punjab. ZAB was arrested from his residence in Sindh and taken to Punjab and tried in Punjab HC and put to death by all the SC judges from Punjab. Liaqat Ali Khan was murdered in Punjab by an ex army man and the case is still unsolved. Most of the NAB cases of Sindh PPP leaders are in Punjab and can be used against them anytime suitable. Why are there no cases againt PPP leaders in Sindh HC? Deedar Shah has no charges of any wrongdoings against him. He is a retired judge of the Sindh HC but not good enough to be acceptable to leader of the opposition! The free SC, went in favor of leader of opposition and not the govt. If the Pakistan HC/SC appoint NAB prosecutor then basically they become judge and the prosecutor at the same time! No civilized country has that. The prosecutor is govt appointed, defence is from defendent and the judges are third and independent party. They should have no connection with either prosecution or defence, the primary condition for justice. Mirza, USA
ali | 10 years ago | Reply shouldn't he or she be NON partisan rather than bipartisan?
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read