‘Surgical strikes’: Journalists flown to LoC to debunk Indian myth

Published: October 2, 2016
SHARES
Email
DG ISPR briefs media persons during a visit to LoC. PHOTO: NNI

DG ISPR briefs media persons during a visit to LoC. PHOTO: NNI

FORWARD LOCATIONS ALONG LOC: India has yet to come up with evidence to substantiate its claim that its special forces carried out ‘surgical strikes’ against so-called ‘launch pads’ of terrorists in the Pakistani side of Kashmir earlier this week. Indian officials are still tweaking the script of the loosely choreographed drama in a desperate bid to fix plot holes in the storyline. In the meantime, however, Pakistani military took local and foreign journalists on a rare visit to forward locations along the Line of Control to debunk the myth of Indian surgical strikes.

On Sept 29, Lt Gen Ranbir Singh, the director general military operations of India, claimed at a news conference that India’s special forces had conducted ‘surgical strikes’ across the Line of Control (LoC) to thwart attacks on some of India’s biggest cities — a claim immediately ripped to shreds by Pakistan’s military. New Delhi couldn’t sell its story internationally while at home, too, it was received by many with a dose of skepticism.

‘Surgical’ farce blows up in India’s face

While India is reluctant to share details or evidence of its trumpeted strikes, Pakistan Army took the journalists to some of the sectors where the Indian military claimed special forces had decimated perceived ‘launch pads of terrorists’. “No such incident took place nor will we allow any such incident to happen in future,” Lt Gen Asim Saleem Bajwa, the director general of the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), told the visiting journalists. “If the adversary attempted so, it will be responded with an ever stronger force,” he added.

The journalists were taken to mainly two spots of Boxor Formation and Hotspring Formation out of the 190-kilometre stretch of the LoC, where India claimed it forces had carried out the so-called surgical strikes. At both locations, which are about 50 kilometres apart, no signs of destruction or casualties were found except the two soldiers, who had been killed – one each at the two formations – due to unprovoked firing by Indian forces. Besides, nine soldiers who have since recovered from injuries and returned to their respective duties.

At the foothills of Boxor Formation, one can find two villages of about 130,000 inhabitants. None of them seem to have the slightest clue about any intrusion by Indian troops. But they do recall that crossfire had taken place on the particular night and nothing else.

The purpose of the embedded tour was to allow journalists to independently investigate the Indian claim. If the Indian military has really carried out a cross-border strike, then it should also open up their side of the LoC to the media. The journalists represented international media outlets, including CNN, BBC, VOA, Reuters, AP, AFP, News Week and BBC Urdu Service.

The chief military spokesperson said the Indian claims of carrying out surgical strikes across the LoC were absurd, baseless, and unfounded, which were meant to not only misguide the Indian people but also the international community. “No physical violation of the LoC has taken place, nor it will be allowed to happen by our resilient forces,” he said in reply to a question. “Pakistan Army is fully prepared to take on any misadventure and any such attempt will be responded in a more effective and forceful manner.”

GOC Bhimber Sector Major General Chiragh Haider apprised the journalists that no physical violation of the LoC happened on the night between September 28 and September 29 as claimed by India’s DGMO.

The journalists were earlier given a full picture of the geographical and physical location at the Boxor Formation by Brigade Commander Brigadier Furqan Moazzam. The entire scenario was drawn to make them understand how Indian forces had carried out unprovoked firing due to which a Pakistani soldier embraced martyrdom.

Meanwhile, Pakistanis and Indian forces exchanged fresh fire across the LoC, with Indian officials stating there was no damage. “Pakistani troops befittingly responded to Indian unprovoked firing” which started at 4:00 am and continued for four hours in the Bhimber sector on the Pakistani side of the LoC, a military statement said. It did not mention casualties.

“There was small arms fire and mortar shells fire from across the LoC in Akhnoor sector which lasted for around two hours,” Pawan Kotwal, a top civilian official in Indian occupied Kashmir told AFP. “No damage was caused. We are ready for any eventuality but it is peaceful in Jammu region.”

Tensions between the two arch rivals have been boiling since the Indian government accused Pakistan-based militants of launching an assault on an army base in Uri, IOK, earlier this month that killed 18 soldiers.

Indian, Pakistani troops trade fire across LoC

“This is a dangerous moment for the region,” Pakistan’s Ambassador Maleeha Lodhi told AFP after meeting with UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon at UN headquarters in New York.

Ban Friday offered to act as a mediator between New Delhi and Islamabad to defuse the tensions.

In a statement to AFP, India’s mission to the United Nations said “India has no desire to aggravate the situation,” and that “our response was a measured counter-terrorist strike”.

On Friday authorities in parts of northern India said they had started evacuating villages within 10 kilometres of the border following the raids earlier this week. India and Pakistan have fought three wars since they gained independence from Britain seven decades ago, two of them over the disputed Himalayan region of Kashmir.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 2nd, 2016.

Related Videos

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (12)

  • Arrow
    Oct 2, 2016 - 9:55AM

    If there are any surgical strikes.and casualities as per india and we say it is fake.then we must do an action replay this time.we should really create the terror launch pads and let para in..Hunt their para rats with our SSG commandos this time if they dare to step in…..lets show them how we are made up of….this is a best way of retaliation……Recommend

  • Kamran
    Oct 2, 2016 - 10:04AM

    Modi has made a fool out of innocent Indian public by creating the so-called “Surgical Strikes” drama.Recommend

  • Aakashvaani
    Oct 2, 2016 - 10:57AM

    Just take a step back and think where this hate is taking us.Recommend

  • Fast
    Oct 2, 2016 - 11:52AM

    That time is not far away when even Indian people will be asking the same questions where are proves of so called strikes. Sorry no face saving for modi then.Recommend

  • Reddy
    Oct 2, 2016 - 11:55AM

    so after 3 days pakistani reporters are allowed in these areas that too with army supervision,chauffeured around by army…if nothing happened why do you have to wait for 3 days,what is the need for army overseeing things… amusing to say the least Recommend

  • AD
    Oct 2, 2016 - 1:33PM

    Well good!! Now everybody is satisfied.So move on.
    Now Pakistanis know no strike so no issues.
    Indians also know strike happened so no issues.
    Social media got lot of traffic so no issues
    US ,Russia , China have opporunity to sell their billions of dollars weapons so no issues
    No issues , everybody is satisfied .
    What a wonderful world!Recommend

  • SYM
    Oct 2, 2016 - 1:38PM

    Dear Ishq Wala India,

    BIG LOL :)Recommend

  • Pak is love
    Oct 2, 2016 - 2:15PM

    Response to reddy…
    Atleast our army has shown proof of no surgical strike after 3 days, ask ur lame and liar indian army to show proof lolx its been three days and we are still counting days:p hahhaha what a nation believe on fake story lolx its not an individual issue actually ur all indian mentality is based on fiction as dipected in bollywood flims lolxRecommend

  • Haider
    Oct 2, 2016 - 2:31PM

    @Reddy
    Even if conditions are normal can u walk freely without army supervision at LOC..Recommend

  • Mr Obvious
    Oct 2, 2016 - 7:50PM

    If all this is nothing but an Indian fabrication then why close down Pakistani airspace for military drills? Why close down civilian roadways to practice landings? Why made numerous UN appeals? Why not just respond with a “shrug” and move on?Recommend

  • Asad Zaidi
    Oct 3, 2016 - 10:40PM

    @Mr Obvious.: for someone whose name is Mr obvious you seem to be getting a lot less than what’s obvious. All India could do was fabricate a story to satisfy the Indian public, Pakistan went ahead and showed the world of the real power they have. Also for your knowledge, the army training exercises with Russia (who USED to be pro India BTW) were planned before any of this nonsense started. As for closing civilian roads, it’s been used before as well as a runway. And please stop being blind, it is logistically impossible to plant a whole village with tons and of civilians even in 3 days. As for taking 3 days to take the journalists to LOC, we couldn’t have taken them there with you firing blindly like someone who just lost their wits and kill international journalists. Next time please hire a good writer of international repute to write a good story and beta check it for any plot holes, as this one has many with the size of black holes. Don’t use your B grade film industry writers, who have convinced you that rajnikanth level of strengths and bullet proofing are real. Now that the myth has been debunked, accept the truth and move on, albeit with a sour taste in your mouth….Recommend

  • imran jahangir
    Oct 4, 2016 - 1:16PM

    @Reddy:
    if india is so insisting that they have launched a surgical strike then why still not they are giving a mere proof of it,,, where are the bullets shells ,, dead bodies, bomb shells, where on the earth is any sign of this surgical strike…??

    the saying that why Pakistan army has waited for 3 days also suggests a question that why India is reluctant to take media to their side of LOC or give any proof while they have done what is supposed to be done after a time requiring planning and can be proven by alot of evidencesRecommend

More in Pakistan