Fakhr-e-Alam’s demand for security of artists leaves entertainment industry divided

Published: June 24, 2016
SHARES
Email
While some said Alam’s demand for security of artists is justified, others opposed it, terming it promotion of VIP culture. PHOTOS: FILE

While some said Alam’s demand for security of artists is justified, others opposed it, terming it promotion of VIP culture. PHOTOS: FILE

KARACHI: Amjad Sabri’s unexpected death appears to have jolted the Pakistani artist community severely. In a show of solidarity, multiple stakeholders of the entertainment industry uploaded a video message on Facebook, demanding the same level of security that is generally reserved for government officials.

Led by Fakhr-e-Alam, the video features some of the industry’s most recognisable faces — including Faisal Qureshi, Faakhir and Maria Wasti — requesting the government to provide artists with the same security protocol that politicians receive as artists are as popular as them. While the video has gone viral, the demand has ended up dividing not only the general public but also the artist community.

In the over two-minute-long video, the Sindh Board of Film Censors chairman says, “We are deeply shocked by Amjad Sabri’s death and have realised that there is no one to look after our safety and security. We want the same security that the government officials are being given. And if that does not happen, then government officials should also give up their protocols so that we at least feel that all of us are equally vulnerable.”

Weighing in on the matter, actor-cum-screenwriter Vasay Chaudhry felt that while Fakhr-e-Alam does have a point, the argument works both ways. “I totally agree with him on the point that we [Pakistani artists] are amongst the most recognisable faces in the country and by that account we should receive security,” Chaudhry told The Express Tribune.

“But then again … certain politicians are actually government employees so it is their constitutional right to have security,” he explained. “We may be doing a service to our country as actors but we have not been employed by the government.”

Maalik director Ashir Azeem felt that it is possible that the video is being misinterpreted by the people.

“It is not about artists demanding security, in my opinion,” he said, adding, “The point they are trying to raise is that the government should either provide security to everyone or no one.”

Another counter argument raised by Chaudhry is that it is impractical to provide all celebrities with the same level of security. “Not every artist featuring in that particular video enjoys the same level of fame or popularity. Some are more famous,” he said. “So giving them all the same level of security would be something very difficult,” added the Jawani Phir Nahi Ani (JPNA) writer.

Seconding Chaudhry, singer Umair Jaswal also felt that Sabri’s case was very different. “Sabri was a legend. And given that he had filed for security, he should have been provided with it,” noted Jaswal. “But demanding security for all artists is not the solution. I am firmly against this VIP culture as I believe we should improve our judicial system and ensure that the law is equal for everyone so that before committing such a heinous act, people would think twice.”

Despite multiple attempts, Fakhr-e-Alam could not be reached for comment.

Sabri was killed on Wednesday when unidentified assailants opened fire on his car.

The legendary qawwal will make his posthumous appearance, recorded a few weeks earlier, in the ninth edition of Coke Studio, where he will be seen collaborating on the qawwali Aj Rang Hai with Ustad Rahat Fateh Ali Khan.

Published in The Express Tribune, June 25th, 2016.

Like Life & Style on Facebook, follow @ETLifeandStyle on Twitter for the latest in fashion, gossip and entertainment.

 

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (6)

  • Parvez
    Jun 24, 2016 - 9:40PM

    If you listened to Fakhr-a-Alam’s full statement ……… it was not realy a demand, it was critique, a condemnation of the government’s policies.Recommend

  • wasim ahmed
    Jun 25, 2016 - 12:42AM

    All vip get security and people will sufer more from these protocols cars… very strange demand… these artists are earning in millions for them hiring two gaurds is no issue at all… instead they want police to give them gaurds….Recommend

  • Bahrul Abyadh
    Jun 25, 2016 - 4:46AM

    I think that Lahore is safer city for artists than Karachi.Recommend

  • Tariq
    Jun 25, 2016 - 8:26AM

    Why artistes? If security is to be given then it should be for each and every individual living in the country. It is the job of govt. to apprehend the criminals so that these type of incidents never happen again.Recommend

  • Procrastinator
    Jun 26, 2016 - 12:59PM

    Artists promoting VIP culture? Strange…Recommend

  • Muhammed Ali hyhaki
    Jun 28, 2016 - 4:24PM

    At receiving the tragic shocking news and then the artiste demanding security, I supported the demand, but then on the 2nd thought I realized, it was not right, we are not some super humans but like all the other countrymen equally vulnerable and unsafe especially there are minorities and communities who are being particularly targeted, killed, blown and mascaraed. In my opinion instead of being selfish and promoting another VIP culture (that will create anger and resentment amongst our friends fans and generally people who’s love and support have brought us the fame and popularity that we claim!. We should be demanding the Govt for further safety and security for each and every individual as per the constitution of Pakistan. Terrorists have no human in them but they are vampires who would just kill and blow any body or any thing as per their own assigned agenda. It is not possible for any Govt in the world to provide protocol, bullet proof vehicles, body guards etc etc to every body even for that matter a not 20 or 50 artiste. Hence it would be more appropriate to demand, either security gear for every body or nobody.Recommend

More in Life & Style