Pakistan slams US plan for India to join export control regimes

Pakistan's ambassador to UN warns that the deal would destabilise South Asia.


Reuters January 26, 2011

GENEVA:


Pakistan warned major powers on Tuesday against granting India membership of four-key multilateral export control regimes that allow trade in nuclear and other materials, as proposed by the United States.

The plan, announced during US President Barack Obama's visit to India last November, would further destabilise the volatile nuclear-armed South Asian region, said Zamir Akram, Pakistan's ambassador to the United Nations in Geneva.

This reinforced Pakistan's opposition, announced a year ago, to global negotiations to ban future production of nuclear bomb-making material, he said.

"These developments will amount to a paradigm shift in strategic terms," Akram said in a speech to the opening session of the UN sponsored Conference on Disarmament.

"The message that such steps transmit is that the major powers can change the rules of the game if it is in their interest to do so," he added.

Pakistan is the only one of 65 member states holding up consensus to launch the fissile talks, arguing that existing stocks of plutonium and enriched uranium should be included to counter its neighbour's advantage.

The United States clinched a civilian nuclear deal with India in 2008, ending its nuclear isolation and granting it access to nuclear fuel and technology while allowing it to continue its nuclear weapons programme.

The Obama administration has announced backing for Indian membership of four regimes: the Nuclear Suppliers Group, the Missile Technology Control Regime, the Australian Group, which aims to reduce the spread of chemical and biological weapons, and the Wassenaar Arrangement, a multinational effort to control the transfer of conventional arms and dual-use technology.

"Apart from undermining the validity and sanctity of the international non-proliferation regime, these measures shall further destabilise security in South Asia," Akram said.

The 46-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group tries to ensure that nuclear exports are not diverted for military purposes.

But Pakistan's envoy said that membership would enable India to improve its nuclear weapons and delivery capability.

"As a consequence, Pakistan will be forced to ensure the credibility of its (nuclear) deterrence," Akram added.

The United States said on Monday it was easing curbs on exports of high-tech goods to India in recognition of the two countries' stronger economic and security ties.

Pakistan has turned to ally China for help. But Akram made no reference to China's offer to build two new nuclear powered reactors for Pakistan at its Chashma complex – which have raised global concern about nuclear proliferation.

To import nuclear goods, all nations except the five officially recognised atomic weapons states must usually place nuclear sites under safeguards of the International Atomic Energy Agency, the UN nuclear watchdog, NSG rules say.

When the United States sealed its nuclear supply accord with India in 2008, it won a waiver from such NSG rules.

COMMENTS (51)

sumit yadav | 13 years ago | Reply What about the size of Pakistan.Had Pakistan got size of Indian. Population below poverty would have been 100% .Say what now.
Observer | 13 years ago | Reply Enough already ! Bunch of juvenile arguments from the so called 'enlightened' Indian and Pakistani posters. To my fellow Indian posters, will you please stop riding your moral high horse and get your asses off a Pakistani website- let them debate their problems, its their country and their headache. Its a pity i see this perverse habit of picking on selected reports and bashing them, i guess it sort of gives your ego a kick ! Its not worth it and its juvenile, and doesn't befit our culture. And i see it just stokes anti-India feelings. I think we have to raise up over our petty 'Schadenfreude' attitude. Remember ! the world and humanity is progressing and i think we need to understand and move on- Both India and Pakistan ! hateful and juvenile comments from both nationalities doesn't help the cause. I am an Indian and have been reading Pakistani journals for a few years now. Its fascinating and tragic to see the turn of events in Pakistan, hope you can sort it out. I wish the winds of the' jasmine revolution' keeps blowing east and engulfs south Asia, lets kick out corruption, nepotism and religious bigotry.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ