Indian minister wants compulsory prenatal sex tests

Published: February 2, 2016


NEW DELHI: India’s children’s minister has called for mandatory tests to determine the sex of an unborn child in a bid to counter high levels of female foeticide, sparking fierce criticism Tuesday from women’s activists.

Prenatal sex tests are officially illegal in India, a policy designed to stop so many unborn girls being aborted by parents desperate for a boy.

Pakistan’s stillbirth rate worst in 186 countries

But in a speech late Monday, Women and Child Development Minister Maneka Gandhi said a more effective strategy would be to record the sex of a foetus at the outset of the pregnancy and then monitor its progress.

“How long are we going to keep making criminals out of people? How long are we going to put the onus on sonographers?

“My view is why not change the present policy. Every pregnant woman should be compulsorily told whether it is a boy or girl,” Gandhi said.

“When a woman becomes pregnant it should be registered and that way you will be able to monitor right until the end whether she gave birth or not and what happened,” she said in the western city of Jaipur.

Parents and doctors can be jailed for up to five years for asking for or conducting a pre-natal sex test but they are still thought to be widespread, particularly in impoverished rural areas.

A 2011 study in the British medical journal The Lancet found that up to 12 million girls had been aborted in the last three decades in India.

India had 940 women for every 1,000 men, according to the last official census published in 2011, up from 933 in 2001 in a trend that some campaigners say vindicates the current policy of banning sex tests.

World Prematurity Day: High preterm births linked to malnutrition

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has previously spoken out against the killing of unborn girls, warning India’s gender imbalance will have serious consequences for the country’s development, although he has not addressed the issue of sex tests.

Gandhi, who is the sister-in-law of opposition leader Sonia Gandhi, said she was “just putting out this idea” which was being discussed with her ministerial counterparts.

“We have not reached a conclusion, we are still discussing the pros and cons,” she said.

But women’s rights groups said a change of policy would be a mistake and result in women from rural areas coming under even more pressure from their families to have an abortion.

“This is not a very productive idea, in fact it could make things worse,” Ranjana Kumari, director of the Delhi-based Centre for Social Research thinktank, told AFP.

“This might work among educated women, but not for large numbers of women living in rural areas who are still under enormous pressure to live up to the social and cultural traditions to have a boy.”

The All India Democratic Women’s Association, a Delhi-based advocacy group, said that Gandhi’s proposal was “shocking” and appeared aimed at absolving the medical profession of responsibility for foeticide levels.

“It will fuel a proliferation of illegal facilities for getting rid of unwanted female foetuses,” the organisation said in a statement.

“What is required is a continued and stringent implementation of the present act, which has clearly acted as a deterrent wherever it has been used effectively.

14 children die of malnutrition in Tharparkar

“The Modi government must not pander to the interests of commercial interests at the expense of the girl child.”

Since coming to power, Modi has sought to position himself as a champion of women’s rights, emphasising education for girls and an end to female foeticide in a country where boys are more desirable than girls.

A year ago, Modi urged a largely female audience in Haryana — the state with the lowest ratio of female to male births that they must resist pressure from family and society to abort girls.

And in July, he launched a Twitter campaign #SelfieWithDaughter appealing parents to post snapshots with their daughters to tackle the skewed sex ratio.

Maneka Gandhi’s was one of the more eye-catching appointments to Modi’s cabinet given her family ties to the main opposition Congress party.

Maneka is the widow of Sanjay Gandhi, whose mother Indira was assassinated in 1984 while serving as prime minister.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (3)

  • Bunny Rabbit
    Feb 2, 2016 - 5:32PM

    Hmmm Worth a thought .. I guess …Recommend

  • PrakashG
    Feb 2, 2016 - 6:23PM

    Neither idea is good, and both seek to burden the parents with an unwanted child. We need affirmative action. If we can make reservations in schools and jobs for the lower castes, why not for women too? That will make the girl child less burdensome to the parents, and more acceptable.Recommend

  • John B
    Feb 2, 2016 - 7:18PM

    Existing law on DONT ask DONT tell on fetus sex is hard to implement and a real burden. The present proposal is not a bad idea. It provides a good data base for rate of pregnancy and sex ratio ahead of birth and data on prenatal mortality if live birth does not occur. It could help to fine tune the focus.

    Preferential sex based a option whether self induced or done under clinic must be banned and prosecuted whereever it is done. In the present model clinic can be controlled but back door / self induced abortions can’t be controlled.

    India already has a good data base on adults of each family under family ration card scheme. This system can be extended into prenatal census. Recommend

More in Pakistan