Taliban send message of impunity with Bacha Khan university massacre

Published: January 21, 2016


ISLAMABAD: As grieving Pakistani parents lament the government’s failure to keep their children safe, analysts say the Taliban have sent a message with their latest campus massacre — a national crackdown on extremism has failed and they can hit targets at will.

The rampage at Bacha Khan university left 21 people dead Wednesday and shattered the sense of security growing in the troubled northwest, a year after Pakistan’s deadliest ever extremist attack, a 2014 assault on a school in nearby Peshawar.

Nation in mourning: Blood on the campus

The chilling similarities between the two atrocities starkly underscored the failings of a government- and military-led initiative launched in the wake of the strike on the army-run school.

“It happened again,” said Zaheeruddin, father of Kashan Zaheer, a ninth grade student who was wounded in the assault which saw Taliban gunmen storm the Peshawar school and kill more than 150 people, most of them children, a year ago.

“Staff and students were martyred again. The government has failed. It has not been able to provide us security.”

The Peshawar attack, carried out by the same Taliban faction that claimed the latest strike in nearby Charsadda, prompted the military to intensify an offensive in tribal areas where militants had operated with impunity.

The military says it has killed thousands in the campaign and swept others over the porous border into Afghanistan.

The government launched a much-vaunted National Action Plan to combat extremism, including the creation of military courts and the resumption of executions after a six-year moratorium.

Breakthrough achieved in identifying Charsadda attackers: DG ISPR

Together the initiatives are credited with making 2015 the least deadly in terms of militant attacks since the formation of the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistani (TTP) in 2007.

But the Bacha Khan attack was a message, said Peshawar-based senior analyst and retired brigadier Saad Khan — that despite the pressure “they can hit any target”.

The killing of young people “brings a lot of pain, despondency and hopelessness, and that arouses emotions against the government, the same government which claimed it had broken the back of the terrorists,” he said.

Defence and security analyst Talat Masood said the government and military had failed to follow through.

“This is the same pattern. They are looking for soft targets and it is simply impossible to provide security to the soft targets, especially those near the border (with Afghanistan),” he told AFP.

“Pakistan needs to do a lot more.”

Among the criticism is that little has been done about key issues including oversight of Pakistan’s thousands of Islamic seminaries, widely seen as breeding grounds for intolerance.

The resumption of hangings has been particularly controversial, with rights activists saying that the majority of the more than 300 people executed in the past year were not linked to extremism.

Then, Charsadda happened

And observers such as the Pakistan Institute for Peace Studies argue that execution is no deterrent for militants who are already prepared to die for their cause.

Pakistan’s reaction to a recent attack on an Indian air base also highlighted what is viewed as a practice of only cracking down on certain types of radicals, tolerating militants it deems useful to its aims, such as those targeting arch-rival India.

Islamabad moved swiftly against Jaish-e-Mohammad, the group believed by Delhi to be behind the attack on the base in Pathankot that left seven dead, detaining some of its leadership and sealing its offices.

But media commentators expressed wry surprise that the group had any offices still open for the government to seal, seeing as it had been banned in 2002.

For those who survived the 2014 attack, described as Pakistan’s 9/11 for the way it united the country in shock and outrage, “sequels” such as Wednesday’s university assault are making their courage waver.

Ajun Khan lost his only son, Asfand, a tenth grader, in the Peshawar school massacre.

Timeline of deadliest insurgent attacks in Pakistan

“We understand their pain, we understand how one feels when one sends his son to school or university and later receives his dead body,” Khan said of the families of the latest strike.

Khan said parents of the Peshawar victims are meeting on Thursday to express their sympathy and to chalk out a strategy — such as compulsory military training for all civilians.

“We are not safe, even parents do not feel safe, we are worried about the future,” he said. “It is now the people’s war.”

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (4)

  • Bharti
    Jan 21, 2016 - 1:23PM

    Be ready for bricks,you have not blamed India.Pak is not going to like you. Recommend

  • ishrat salim
    Jan 21, 2016 - 1:50PM

    Unless accountability of those responsible in terms of intel failure, security lapse, lack of trained security guards ( there were 54 security guards, they together could not confront 4 terrorists ), lapse in raising the back wall without watch tower etc; are some of the pertinent questions being raise every where. Had JIT formed in APS & report made public of all similar incidents & those found responsible in any way, should have been punished, this kind of repeat incident would not hve taken place.

    Implementation of NAP in its strict form is yet another topic of discussion, why not yet fully implemented ?

    NACTA till today, has not been fully made operational. Resulting in miscommunication & co-ordination between different law enforcement agencies. No effective anti-terrorist force has been formed to tackle such incidents & even today, we have to depend on SSG, why ?

    Presently, our intel driven action is based on information received from arrested terrorists & its facilitators etc;. This has to change & infiltration of our agents is must if we have to implode these extremist outfits from within. This strategy has been used by the Americans & they have been able to avoid many major incidents after 9/11, while, though we have advantage of similarity in culture, dress, language etc; till today, we have not been able to infiltrate any extremist outfits. Israelis have used similar strategy & have been successful in preventing major incidents in Israel. They have used American aid to their advantage for internal security, not withstanding, Palestinians right to independent state & right to co-existence.

    And, finally, please, STOP glorifying our dead & those fighting the menace. Those fighting, it is their job. Glorifying & showering praises on our LEAs only make them complacent. We have to make our LEAs strong to face these terrorists, train them & provide them with every kind of resources, then expect results.

    Accountability, when repeat of similar incidents is MUST, in absence of which our govt machinery goes into sleep mode, only to wake up after a HIT. Recommend

  • Jan 21, 2016 - 6:49PM

    People of pakistan need to keep courage at this movement and need to support its govt and military to fight against militancy and to eradicate this mance .inshallaha pakistan will soon come out this termoil and choasRecommend

  • Nasir
    Jan 21, 2016 - 7:38PM

    Alhamdolillah we have Lal Masjid and its Imam and more like them with FIR and complaints but no action has been taken so far. We should be ready for another massacre soon. As long as we have no action against Madressa and so called Mullahs, we will see this happening again and again.Recommend

More in Pakistan