Muslim judge in NYC criticised for taking oath on Holy Quran

Several Americans took to social media to criticise Carolyn Walker's decision to take oath on the Quran over the Bible


Web Desk December 15, 2015
PHOTO: FACEBOOK

In a first in the United States, a black Muslim woman took oath as a civil court judge in New York City while swearing to abide by the US Constitution placing her hand on the Holy Quran.

While it is a norm in the United States and most western countries for oaths to be administered with the individual swearing on the Holy Bible, Judge Carolyn Walker took her oath on the Holy Quran.

We must support Muslims in US, says Google CEO

"I, Carolyn Walker-Diallo, do solemnly affirm that I will support the constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State of New York and I will faithfully discharge my duties as judge of the civil court of the city of NY, so help me God," Diallo said as took oath on the Holy Quran.

The video of her swearing in ceremony as a civil court judge of the 7th Municipal District at the Brooklyn Burough Hall was posted on Facebook leading to widespread criticism.

While a few posted in favor of Carolyn’s induction, many Americans objected to the judge’s decision to swear on the Hole Quran rather than the Bible. Some went as far as calling it "a slap in the face of all Americans."



One social media user went as far as saying, "Hope she gets hit by a train or something.”





Meanwhile some took what seemed to be a sensible approach, by quoting the US constitution.





He had something decent to say about the Holy Quran and Islam:



Food for thought?



Watch the video here:

COMMENTS (4)

syed & syed | 9 years ago | Reply Why so much hue and cry. Oath is an Oath whether taken on Holy Books or even ordinary books of law, algebra, or public relations etc etc. Remember Raisani saying degree is a degree whether.........
Zahid | 9 years ago | Reply Islam is a peaceful religion, as a Muslim I love every one in this world Terrorist and Islam two different things
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ