Is "hang 'em all" always the answer?

People are enraged at the shame the trio had brought Pakistan. But why do they want them stoned to death?

Sidrah Moiz November 04, 2011
Working as a part of the web team at The Express Tribune has given me  exposure to peoples' reactions online which always tend to take me by surprise. However, during this week, after the spot-fixing verdict story was shared on Facebook, I was more than just a little surprised by the harsh, emotional and blunt responses that came from a majority of readers. They were thirsty for the trio's blood – literally.

One commenter, Usama Zulfiqar, proposed capital punishment for the players which began a flood of comments that agreed with him - most readers were demanding Asif and Butt be "hanged".

While the news saddened, enraged and infuriated the officials in Pakistan Cricket Board, cricket lovers in Pakistan had an entirely different approach to the news.

Zulfiqar had written:
“Simply hang them. Why worry about prison or a fine when they did not worry about the stake of their country!”

Other readers followed with similar angry demands and soon the thread was full of “hang ‘em all". People like Aamir Zia strongly felt “they should be stoned to death.”

The spot-fixing scandal seems more to do with the national dignity than cricket ethics for Pakistanis. Zulqarnain Shinwari said:
"It should be dealt as treason, I hate them."

His words echo those of captain, Shahid Afridi who had said that the incident "damaged the country’s reputation."

Evidently, Pakistanis are not concerned with what is legal and what is not. Instead, you will find many of them saying:
“Qoum k muun pe kalak mal di (They brought shame to the nation)."

Sometimes our rage and desire for vengeance leads us to become inhumane and brutal in our approach. People should treat this issue as any other criminal move and accept the punishments that Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir have been awarded.

Do you have a video that you want to share with The Express Tribune readers? Submit your url with a brief description to Only local content will be considered.
Sidrah Moiz
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.


Tahir | 12 years ago | Reply They committed a mistake and have been punished for that. They have definitely hurt the national pride and disappointed the nation but do we think they are the only culprits out there? Critics, both home and abroad have revealed that cricketers from around the world are guilty of similar offences but have been lucky since there are no proofs against them. In a way they have committed the same crime and thus should merit the same response 'hang them all...." but do we hear such rhetoric from public of those countries? In my reckoning, most of the readers here have vented out their anger and disappointed and they do not literary mean to hang them! They are in fact victim of 'emotional cum inflammatory-response syndrome' to which this nation is generally hostage to! The remaining 'those' who might mean it in literal sense are imbalanced souls who need to visit nearest Mental Health Facility as soon as possible!
Umer Farooq | 12 years ago | Reply Hang them all,,,,,and see the rest wont even think about treason...
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ