Speaking to the media after holding protests the whole day, members of Pemra strictly said that they are an independent entity and like to make decisions as such.
They also stated that they will seal the TV channel's offices.
“I would like to congratulate all of Pemra’s private members for making this decision, keeping in mind Pemra’s rules and regulations as well as Pakistan’s constitution,” said Pemra private member, Mian Shams.
Speaking to the media after holding meetings the whole day, Shams said that Pemra is an independent entity and will make decisions as such.
“Pemra is an independent organisation, and it would have been better if a government representative attended today’s meeting as well and help us come up with a decision,” he said.
Shams lamented that apart from him, only four other private members of the media authority attended today’s meeting which included Israr Abbasi from Azad Kashmir, Shama Parveen from Balochistan, Zeba Hussain from Sindh and Fariha Iftikhar from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (K-P). He added that it was the government's job to implement the recommendation.
The private member said the recommendation has been sent to the Council of Complaints (CoC) and their recommendations are expected to be returned in a week’s time.
Moreover, he said that once the recommendations come back, a special committee will be formed to make a final decision regarding Geo TV’s licenses.
[embed width="628"] ]
Confusion surrounds PEMRA decision
There was some confusion regarding the decision to suspend Geo TV when the government late on Tuesday released a statement apparently from PEMRA which disowned the decision by the members and claimed that Tuesday’s meeting had no legal standing.
According to a PEMRA statement issued by the Press Information Department late on Tuesday, it read that the regulatory body "disowns the decisions announced by three members of PEMRA on cancelling Geo TV’s licenses."
The statement, which did not carry any signature of a competent authority or otherwise, further said that a majority of the body’s members had decided in their May 9, 2014, meeting to refer the case to the Ministry of Law for a legal opinion.
“The complaint against Geo Entertainment was already referred to the Council of Complaints Sindh. The CoC in its meeting called today has already recommended about status of Geo’s license. The minutes of the CoC are awaited and the Authority would consider this matter in the next schedule meeting,” the statement read.
The statement further clarified that Tuesday’s meeting of the members was “called without following the laid down procedures and thus had no legal standing.”
It said that according to Rule 3(4) of PEMRA Rules 2009, the chairman or as the case may be more than half of the total members can call the meeting, that is seven of the 12 members can call a meeting.
The statement said that Tuesday’s meeting was an informal meeting attended only by five members.
“The Executive Member was not even asked to officially convene the meeting and notify it through the Secretary to the Authority which is the set procedure.”
The statement declared that Tuesday’s meeting was convened by the members without any official intimation or invitation to other members in accordance with the procedure.
COMMENTS (68)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1725612926-0/Tribune-Pic-(8)1725612926-0-165x106.webp "article")
1725254039-0/Untitled-design-(24)1725254039-0-270x192.webp "no talks currently taking place as dialogue can t be held under threats mohsin naqvi")
Geo is working again due to bad government.
Nevertheless it still seems that geo will never give up its asha for india come what may
I was reading the news paper of Jung just to see what news they are publishing? and i was not wonder to see 70% of news they published were their face saving and blackmailing the authorities and institutions. Geo Must be baned now atleast for 190 days :D
For God's sake, are Pakistanis mad?
Shouting so much for blasphemy that too unintentional and apologised for. What about the inappropriate Pashto and punjabi films, style 360 modelling, dances in ary award shows? Are these Islamic? If saying iddat widdat is wrong according to Islamic principles what about these dances and cocktail dresses. Have these become Islamic suddenly or showing alcohol or mujras in dramas is suddenly ok?
Once apologised this should be forgotten and left to be decided in Allah's court. And as for the morning shows, these should be immediately banned on EVERY channel having useless topics and vain idle talk.
A temporary ban would do the job. Freedom of speech has become the tool to try anyone in this country.
@Irfan: Do u even know the complete course of action ? Once the show cause is issued & the reply is submitted then again show cause is issued and the inquiry is conducted.. dude in which world are u living ?
Please Ban GEO
I do not understand how suspending GEO's licenses is linked with democracy. Democracy does not mean crossing limits of freedom of speech to hurt the sentiments of the people of Pakistan. The narrative being put forward by handful GEO trolls has no merit, the issue is simple that GEO has committed violation of the terms and conditions of their licence in accordance with section 20(e) of the Pemra Ordinance, 2002 and now they are facing the music for the violation committed. Please do not link the issue of GEO TV with Democracy in Pakistan, there is no correlation between the two. GEO TV is not the fourth pillar of the State and they are certainly not above the law.
Media is no 4th pillar. Media is a corporate entity mostly that is open to government taxation and public inspection like any other private profit seeking organization. This is the truth.
Geo Group was spreading fire instead of making things calm. I dont know by whom they are contiously consulted wrongly. Pemra has done absolutely rite. Geo has no right to get decisions always in their favor.
Its surprising that PML N troll is missing in comments
@Bhulla: Freedom of speech doesn't mean disrespecting religious personalities without even thinking.
Shame on Express News and Express TV for the role they played. Used to be my favorite liberal media outlet. Will never trust it again. Lost credibilty when it became an ISI mouthpiece
Shameful conduct from the mods by censoring pro freedom of expression comments.
If the same Geo had accused the government of the day, all commentors here will switch sides and praise Geo. This is the sate of mind in Pakistan.
@uzair: If you live in the West, than tell me: who brought down Richard Nixon, USA President. Do you think that was right or wrong.
its about time that media and internet be filtered for offensive material and immoral contents
@A Journalist: Its a lie that media is a 4rth pillar of state.
Shame!
@Khan Ahmed: Show cause notice was issued to GEO and their written reply was also taken on the case. This case is open since April 19 and due proceedings have been insured before taking this decision
The same geo virtually brought PPP government down. Don't forget the arrogance shown by humid Mir and kam ran khan The actions of geo tantamount to mutiny and it should be punished And Zardari sabar KA phal meetha!!
I also want to add that Geo has been complaining that ARY did the same blashemy material earlier... If one does wrong, second does too, it does not make it right. If musharaf called martial law, is it ok for Raheel for call martial law? Then Raheel says that Musharaf called it, so can he? Can two wrongs make a right? Why didn't GEO object to other channels airing similar content (blamed express too!), but now? Like they say why Imran took a year to levy elections allegations over GEO. see the double policy?
Bye Bye Democracy, Welcome Martial Law. First Milestone achieved, many more to come. Keep on eye on supporting actors, IK, Religious parties, PML (Q) all alive now. Waiting for Lion to sleep to attack.
Establishment has spoken. Koi shak!
It appeared for a while that "freedom of press" meant that they have a free hand and are not accountable to anyone. They overstepped and they need to face the music Congratulations to PEMRA for making the rule of the law prevail. It
That's excellent news
I live in the west, and I'm all for freedom of speech. But even in west, with powerful media, CIA or it's head is not outrightly accused of attempted murder. Moreover, GEO plays duopoly. They say, we asked for forgivness, so let us go. Well, if Musharaf ask for this forgiveness, should he be forgiven? Or that speech of Khawja Asif that geo said was made years ago and made to be seen as a recent speech was bad.... Then why do they show Musharaf with hand over his head? Those pictures were years ago and Musharaf was just fixing hair. Point is, GEO presents his idea without being impartial. Plus, one time a GEO numainda was trying to ask question from ex military guy and that's ok, but he was teasing him, laughing at him on camera, kept annoying him and threating an army guy by angrily saying not to touch him, because he's part of media. (shown on capital talk).I watch GEO everyday and the amount of hate spurred at army is questionable. HOWEVER, there are only a few handful people at geo that are ruining the program and should be fired than entire channel shut down. ET pls publish my voice. GEO and other pro-geo news websites are vastly approving comments that are to their taste (Irony = they talk about freedom!)
Once again proven that the cronies appointed during PPP's tenure were totally incompetent.
About time!
Biased reporting, Shame on you ET. From now onwards, I'll never believe any of your news item unless I counter check.
Geo was the first and only channel in Pakistan to confirm India's accusations that Pakistan was behind the Mumbai attack. They not only showed this village but his parents also. On this GOP had to finally come out clean that yes it was hatched in Pakistan.
Not Good .. silly move by GOP .. wont bear fruitful results
Nonsense, how the licenses could be suspended without issuing notice and giving an opportunity to reply. This will not stand before judiciary. It is like closing the courts because sixty eight lawyers are charged under blasphemy. What about ARY, it repeated the video hundred times enabling all Pakistanis to view.
Thank God
atleast i can live somedays without Geo's Propaganda news now!
In Pakistan, the Army & ISI always wins.
Dumb, dumb, dumb. History keeps repeating itself, media keeps getting clamped, Pakistanis remain happy being ignorant. Who needs foreign aid for destruction of Pakistan, we're good enough to destroy it on our own.
Goood. May this ban forever. amen
Let law take its course on God's earth. Let the authority administer the law it has been entrusted to enforce. Let the charge-sheet be presented. Let the accused defend itself, if it can. If not, let it suffer the punishment. Let it repent, and demonstrate to others what does it cost to run an unbridled news enterprise, with thinly veiled semblance of a boisterous theatre company. Let the trumpets blow announcing to the whole world that the accused has been summoned by the judge to answer for its acts of omission and commission. Why be sad over this. After all, it is the 'breaking news' of the day.
FREEDOM OF SPEECH looks like a joke in the land of pure. Allah hi hafeez hay Pakistan ka.
let me tell you the end of the story, geo licenses reinstated with final warning notice etc. They are banned to please mullahs who have been asking to ban geo..
What on Earth is happening in this country?????? Is PEMRA out of its mind!! A very, very shameful moment for this country!!!!
Stupidity galore. Pakistan, dig a hole, stick your head in it. That is the world you think that exists.
Well done...ban jang and geo once and for all....ban all the morning shows..these are good for nothing
It should be banned permanently for its anti state behavior. Media should be free but responsible.
next might be ur turn.
This is an unfortunate decision and will affect a number of people. Nevertheless, this is the outcome an irresponsible attitude of people sitting at helm of the affairs as well as their adamant and inflexible behaviour.
No one must be considered above law.
Well done Imran Khan!! Well done PEMRA!!
Unfortunately a black day for democracy and freedom of expression in Pakistan.
Hasta La Vista Geo....:)
Shame on the so-called 'liberal' media which didn't support GEO at this time. An institution bullying it and all the media can do is find excuses for them to do so.
Geo Tv licenses Suspended By PEMRA - 20th May 2014 The Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra) on Tuesday announced that it has suspended Geo News, Geo Entertainment and Geo Tez’s licenses till May 28, Express News reported. Speaking to the media after holding meetings the whole day, Pemra private member Mian Shams said that Pemra is an independent entity and will make decisions as such. “Pemra is an independent organisation, and it would have been better if a government representative attended today’s meeting as well and help us come up with a decision,” he said. Shams lamented that apart from him, only four other private members of the media authority attended today’s meeting which included Israr Abbasi from Azad Kashmir, Shama Parveen from Balochistan, Zeba Hussain from Sindh and Fariha Iftikhar from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (K-P). The Pemra official said the recommendation has been sent to the CoC and their recommendations are expected to be returned in a week’s time. Moreover, he said that once the recommendations come back, a special committee will be formed to make a final decision regarding Geo TV’s licenses.
What Lucman fails to take note of is the fact that ‘Ali keh saath’, a qawwali popularised by Amjab Sabri, is a common recitation at Shia weddings particularly in the rural areas.
This is due to the qawwali’s general matrimonial theme, and not because it’s intended to compare the bride and groom to personalities of religious significance. Geo neither composed the qawwali, nor invented the tradition of using it in weddings.
This point should be easy for warring media houses to understand, given that old videos have surfaced on the internet of multiple channels airing similar instances with the same qawwali.
That said, it is understandable that those who are not accustomed to the tradition may be offended, and it was prudent of Geo to apologise given the prevailing environment.
Unfortunately, this accusation sets a dangerous new precedent.
Good move. Media has to learn to respect the Country's institutions. It's job is reporting. Courts Judge.. Media can not be let loose, that experiment failed when Media sensationalized and overstepped all cultural. moral and ethical values. Pakistan is not for Sale!
LOST THE HOPE OF FREE AND FAIR SOCIETY......UNFORTUNATELY ALL THE MEDIA HOUSES LOST THEIR CREDIBILITY BY DEFAMING EACHOTHER. GOD MERCY ON PAKISTAN "THE LAND OF PURE".
I agree with what everyone here says- censorship is bad but media houses need to act responsibly as well in line with industry standards- if they cant they should go! I really like GEO but only if they changed their name to GEO gup instead of GEO News.
Just an other Eyewash!!! They r just giving lollipop.
I am against total ban on geo but they should be punished at the same time. Temporary suspension for few days or a monetary fine will do the job.
Shaishta Lodhi was the last straw that broke the camel's (Geo's) Back. Good to see that irresponsible and blasphemous behaviour is being punished.
Good Riddance (FINALLY)
Finally.......
It is a shame the game these guys play. These PEMRA members need to be fired.
Thanks to PEMRA. They deserve this punishment. Now may be something fruitful happen in Pakistani media. At least such program will be shown in the boundary of Islam.
I dont know I am sad or Happy on suspension of Geo licence . Its time media learn . Enough is enough for God's Sake in lust for ratings dont cross limits. If media is 4th piller of the state ,act like one. you are the most powerful pillar . you effect 20 million people. Instead of becomming threat to ideological and Physical boundaries of Pakistan be a defender. All media outlets need introspection. Plz be mature